[00:00:04]
GO AHEAD AND GET STARTED. MORNING, EVERYONE, UM. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. AH! TUESDAY, APRIL 19TH. NOW, 10 O'CLOCK. WE'RE GONNA GO AHEAD AND START THE HEARING. MY NAME IS KEITH L. WILLIAMS. I'M ESPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOR TODAY.
AND I WILL BE CONDUCTING THE HEARING ON BEHALF OF VILLAGE, MANY IN TOWN. AH! IF ANYONE IS PRESENT HERE, WHO WAS ALSO ON THE DOCKET WILL GET TO YOU AND DO TIME. UH TO THE EXTENT THAT WE CAN GO OUT OF ORDER TO HELP SOMEONE HELP FACILITATE GETTING PEOPLE IN AND OUT. MORE QUICKLY.
WE CAN DO THAT. UM BUT PLEASE EXHIBIT TO PATIENTS AS WE DO HAVE A QUITE A FEW CASES ON OUR DOCUMENTS. MORNING WE WANT TO MAKE SURE WE TAKE THEM ALL IN THE IN THE TIME THAT ARE A LOT OF AND ALSO GIVE PEOPLE AN OPPORTUNITY TO COME HERE AND BEING APPEARANCE. TO THE EXTENT THAT THOSE FOLKS HAVE NOT ALREADY CONTACTED THE VILLAGE. SO THE HEARING COMING ORDER THANKS. SO. MS PEREZ, DO YOU HAVE THE FIRST MATTERS THAT YOU'D LIKE TO PRESENT TO THE
[1.
April Docket 2022
]MAGISTRATE? UM YEAH, IF YOU'D LIKE WE COULD START WITH THE RESPONDENTS THAT ARE HERE. NOW, UM RIGHT, AND THEY'RE OUT OF ORDER, WHICH WHICH NUMBER ON THE DOCKET TODAY, WE'RE GONNA GO WITH 22 046 TO HAVE 15 ON THE DOCKET. DENTISTS. MARIEL. OKAY? START THERE.ALL RIGHT. VILLAGE IS READY TO PROCEED. MY NAME IS ROBERT PEREZ AND I'VE BEEN HAVE NOT BEEN SWORN IN LIKE TO SWARM ME IN, SIR. NO AND BEFORE THIS PROCEEDING STARTS, LET ME FIRST AGAIN. WE DID HAVE SOMEONE COMING LATER. MY NAME IS KEITH WILLIAMS. I'M SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. IF YOU ARE GOING TO PRESENT TESTIMONY HERE TODAY IT WILL BE SWORN TESTIMONY. IT WILL BE ON THE RECORD. ANYTHING YOU SAY HERE TODAY WILL BE PRESERVED FOR THE FUTURE AND WILL BE COUNTED AS TESTIMONY AND OR EVIDENCE IN THE MATTER THAT YOU HAVE BEFORE THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. SO BEFORE WE GET STARTED TODAY, ANYONE WHO'S PLANNING ON GIVING TESTIMONY I LIKE TO SWEAR EVERYONE IN AND TO TAKE AN OATH. SO EVERYONE WHO IS PLANNING ON GIVING TESTIMONY CAN YOU RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND? ALL RIGHT. DO YOU HEREBY SWEAR, AFFIRM? THAT ANY TESTIMONY THAT YOU'RE GOING TO GIVE HERE TODAY WILL BE THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH. YES, SIR. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU, AND EVERYONE'S BEEN SWORN AGAIN. MY NAME IS ROBERT PEREZ AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. I'M A COLD COMPLIANCE INSPECTOR FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TONE. UM THIS CASE WAS INITIATED PROACTIVELY UPON MY DISCOVERY. ON MARCH 8TH OF 2022. THE RESPONDENT EXAMPLES . MARIELLE UM, APPEARS TO BE PRESENT. UM I'M GATHERING EITHER. UM UH, IS SHE SENT THIS MARIO? DOLLAR IS ENGLISH. AND GOOGLE. OKAY YES. SANTIS, MARIEL. MADDALENA. THE ONLY. OH DONE LIKE OKAY, SO THEY'RE ACTUALLY NOT EVEN THE OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY THERE. THE TENANTS UM, HAVE THEY NOTIFIED THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY? SEE NOW WE SO I DON'T GET NO. THEY'RE SAYING NO . UM I MEAN, I DON'T WANT TO GET AHEAD OF THE PRESENTATION, BUT I DO TAKE THEIR TESTIMONY AS IT COMES IN, BUT THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY ISN'T HERE THAN IT MIGHT BE DIFFICULT TO REACH. REACH. CONCLUSION FOR WHATEVER WHATEVER TESTIMONY THEY'RE
[00:05:06]
PLANNING TO GIVE DIFFICULT TO HAVE, YOU KNOW? HAVE THEY BEEN ASKED TO REPRESENT OR FILE ANY NOTICE OF REPRESENTATION ON BEHALF OF THE PROPERTY OWNER. HOTEL. YOU TELL ME SO I DON'T GET DINNER GAVE PRESIDENT. MHM, OKAY? SO THEY SAID THAT SHE SAID THAT THEY RECEIVED NOTIFICATION FROM THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY THAT THEY NEEDED TO ADDRESS THE ISSUES THAT WERE ON THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION AND THEY WERE INSTRUCTED TO COME HERE. ON BEHALF OF THE OWNER. OKAY BUT THE OWNER DIDN'T FILE ANYTHING OR THEY DIDN'T FIND ANYTHING AUTHORITY TO TALK TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE OWNER. NO NO. OKAY, SO, UH, AGAIN. WHATEVER EVIDENCE YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO PROVIDE THAT MIGHT BE RELEVANT THAT I CAN APPLY. I'LL TRY TO TAKE THAT IN BUT UNDERSTAND THAT BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY. THIS YOU MAY AND YOU HAVEN'T BEEN FORMALLY PRESENTED TO EITHER THE VILLAGE OR TO THIS PRODUCER DENNIS TRIBUNAL AS AN OFFICIAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE PROPERTY OWNER. THE WHATEVER YOU SAY ON BEHALF OF PROPERTY OWNER MAYBE LIMIT LOOK AT THE LOOK AT THE. A PRESENT. I GOTTA GET THE PNEUMONIA. MUTA. PROCESSING OF MOMENTOUS PRESENTED TO SO. THEY'RE THEY'RE ASKING, IF BE RECOMMENDED THAT THEY JUST INSTRUCT THE OWNER TO BE TO BE HERE, BUT OBVIOUSLY WE'RE ALREADY HERE. SO WE ARE ALREADY HERE, AND THEY HAVEN'T ASKED FOR A CONTINUANCE OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT. I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S POSSIBLE FOR THE OWNER TO APPEAR AND ASK FOR A CONTINUANCE AND PERSON. IF THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE ABLE TO CONTACT THE OWNER BY PHONE, CAN. YEAH, WE MAY WANT TO GO AHEAD AND PUSH THIS BACK UNTIL THEY CAN HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT FOR TELEPHONES. IT DOES. HOW IS HE SEES A BLACK AND WHEN HE GOT OMEGA GEARY'S. NO NOT YET. SURROGATE NOT ANY INFORMED BY THE SOVIETS. IKARIA MARTY, MEAL. ASSOCIATE LOOK AT ASIAN C THE BURGER MONEY. 11 WE SEND THE SUPPORT. POSSIBLY OR ALAMO, JOSE PABLO, COME IN. OKAY? OKAY, SEE YOU GET A PERSON. W OKAY, SO YOU GET A PASS ON. MHM. HOW YOU DOING, DRAMA? THEY'RE GOING TO GO ACTUALLY GET THE OWNER. I GUESS THEY DON'T HAVE A WAY OF CONTACTING THEM BY PHONE. BUT SHE SAID THE OWNERS LITERALLY JUST A MATTER OF LIKE FIVE MINUTES FROM HERE. SO THEY'RE GOING TO GO GET IT. IF YOU WANT TO PUSH THIS BACK THIS ONE BACK , YOU KNOW, BECAUSE LET'S GO BACK TO THE BEGINNING OF THE DOCKET. OKAY? ON BECAUSE. THE MITIGATION AND SPECIAL SET, SO LET'S DO THE REMAIN. LET'S DO THE OTHER PARTS OF THE DOCTOR FIRST BEFORE WE GET TO THAT, OKAY? IN THAT WAY, WILL HAVE THE MOST TIME FOR THAT. SO THE WE HAVE. FIRST TIME ON THE DOCK AT 22 32. WAS COMPLIED. AND THE SECOND TAB. CASE NUMBER 22 0 33 ALSO COMPLIED. SO GOING ON TO TAB THREE. WE HAVE 22 0 34. UM.THIS PROPERTY IN PARTICULAR AT 15181 SOUTHWEST 169TH AVENUE. I'VE BEEN IN CONTACT WITH THE REGISTERED OWNER, MR ABBERLINE TRUJILLO. AND WE'VE ACTUALLY DISCUSS REQUEST FOR A CONTINUANCE. AND HE WOULD LIKE TO HAVE ADDITIONAL TIME TO ADDRESS THE VIOLATIONS IN QUESTION. UM AT THIS TIME, THE VILLAGE IS NOT OPPOSED TO ALLOWING 30 DAY CONTINUANCE ON THIS CASE. AND WE LIKE. IN ORDER TO REFLECT THE 30 DAY CONTINUANCE FROM TODAY'S
[00:10:05]
HEARING. RIGHT AND. BASED ON YOUR TESTIMONY TODAY IS THAT MR TRUJILLO CONTACTED THE VILLAGE AND STATED THAT THE VIOLATIONS WERE BEING ADDRESSED. YES SIR. HAS A VILLAGE LOOKED AT IT AND HAVE, YOU KNOW? HAVE YOU EXPECTED THE PROPERTY TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THAT'S ACCURATE WE HAVE. YEAH THERE'S A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF PROGRESSION. UM THAT'S GOING ON AND THE OWNER'S BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH OUR BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT IN ORDER TO DISCUSS THE NATURE OF SOME OF THE VIOLATIONS, SEEING AS THERE'S SOME STRUCTURAL ISSUES AND UNPERMITTED, UH, WORK THAT'S GOING ON AND THEN WITH REGARDS TO NUISANCE VIOLATIONS UNDER 67.201, A FOR OVERGROWN. VEGETATION AND 67.201 B FOR EXCESSIVE. AMOUNTS OF TRASH AND DEBRIS. THOSE THINGS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED, SINCE THE VIOLATION HAS BEEN ISSUED. UM SO THE ONLY THINGS THAT ARE OUTSTANDING OR MORE OF THE STRUCTURAL ISSUES AND BUILDING SERVICES PERMIT ISSUES THAT ARE ONGOING. RIGHT AND DO YOU THINK THAT YOU KNOW YOUR RECOMMENDATIONS FOR 30 DAYS BY THE 30 DAY CONTINUES. UM IF. SEEING AS YOU KNOW, IT COULD BE A LONG DRAWN OUT PROCESS. I MEAN, IF WE CAN GET 60 DAYS THAT WOULD BE IDEAL. YEAH SO YOU'D RATHER HAVE A 60 DAY CONTINUANCE? YEAH. AND THE OWNER IS ADDRESSING THE ISSUES. YES, SIR. ALRIGHT. I'M GOING TO.BASED ON THAT, BASED ON YOUR TESTIMONY, AND BASED ON THE PROGRESS, I'M GOING TO GRANT THE GO AHEAD AND GRANT THE 60 DAY CONTINUANCE IN THIS MATTER, OKAY? DRINK. WITH 60 DAYS TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE. AND IF NOT , THEY'RE NOT IN COMPLIANCE IN 60 DAYS, THEN SCHEDULE IT BACK BEFORE THE HEARING AND DO A FINAL NOTICE AND FINES. OKAY? OKAY. THANK YOU.
NEXT CASE. THE NEXT TAB WILL BE TOUGH. 4 22 0 35 WAS COMPLIED. AND FOLLOWING THAT WOULD BE TAPPED 5 22 036. AND MAKE A PRESENTATION. SO THIS CASE HERE, UM IS REGARDING THE PROPERTY OF 15565 SOUTHWEST WAR FIELD. BOULEVARD. THE RESPONDENT WAR FUELED INVESTMENTS LLC AND THE REGISTERED AGENT OF THIS, UM CORPORATION, UM, HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS MR JOHN LEONARD.
UM THE. MAJORITY OF THESE VIOLATIONS HAVE BEEN COMPLIED. UM WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE FIRST VIOLATION ON THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION OF 3-4, 0.11 PARKING, LOADING AND DRIVEWAYS. UM. THE RESPONDENT HAS REQUESTED ADDITIONAL TIME IN ORDER TO ADDRESS THIS. HE'S GOT, UH, SET OF CONTRACTORS AND ENGINEERS THAT ARE DRAWING OUT A SET OF PLANS THAT ARE SAID TO BE PRESENTED TO OUR BUILDING DEPARTMENT FOR APPROVAL. UM AND OUR ZONING OFFICIALS, UM, SO HE'S REQUESTED ADDITIONAL TIME IN ORDER TO ADJUST THIS VIOLATION. WE AT THIS TIME LIKE TO REQUEST UM, 60 DAY CONTINUANCE ON THE CASE IN ORDER TO A LOT AMPLE TIME TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. ALRIGHT. AND BASICALLY, THIS IS AN ISSUE WHERE THEY'RE GOING FOR PERMITTING, AND THEY'RE IN THIS IN THE VILLAGE AND THE OWNER SIMPLY WORKING OUT THE PARAMETERS OF THE PERMIT. EXACTLY BUT EVERYTHING ELSE HAS BEEN COMPLIED. EVERYTHING ELSE HAS BEEN COMPOSER. AND IN THE MATTER OF. CASE NUMBER 222 OH 2036 VILLAGE VERSUS WAR FIELD INVESTMENT CONTINUOUS OF 60 DAYS A WEEK GRANTED. AND IF THE PROPERTY ISN'T. COMPLIANCE HAS NOT OCCURRED WITHIN THAT 60 DAYS, THEN. DURING THE MATTER BACK BEFORE THIS MAD STRIP FOR SCHEDULING OF IMPOSITION OF FINES AND OR UH, MEANS RIGHT? NEXT TIME WILL BE, UM TAP SIX.
[00:15:04]
CASE NUMBER 22 037 MM. THIS CASE. UM IS REGARDING THE PROPERTY OF 15077 SOUTHWEST 173RD AVENUE. UM. AND THE RESPONDENT, UM, A NONPROFIT IDENTIFIED AS INDIAN TOWN, NONPROFIT HOUSING AND THE REGISTERED AGENT HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS A JENNIFER EHLE WILLIAMSON. UM. THIS PROPERTY HERE WE'VE BEEN IN, UH, COMMUNICATION WITH A REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE, UM NON PROFIT HOUSING CORPORATION. AND CURRENTLY WHAT THEY HAVE THE PROPERTIES OF VACANT LOT THAT HAS, UH ON FOUR. HELLO. UNFORTUNATELY A LARGE AMOUNT OF INOPERABLE VEHICLES THAT ARE BEING STORED BY SOME OF THE NEIGHBORING RESIDENTS SURROUNDING THE VACANT LOT. AND RIGHT NOW THE RESPONDENT IS WORKING ON HAS, UH ISSUED A FORMAL NOTICE TO ALL THE. INDIVIDUALS ALL THE RESIDENTS SURROUNDING THE VACANT LOT, AND THEY'RE ACTIVELY WORKING ON GETTING THE VEHICLES REMOVED FROM THE VACANT LOT. UM, SO WE'D LIKE TO WE'VE WE'VE BEEN IN. LIKE I SAID, WE'VE BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THEM, AND THEY'VE REQUESTED ADDITIONAL TIME IN ORDER TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. AND AT THIS TIME WE'D LIKE TO FACILITATE A 60 DAY CONTINUANCE IN ORDER TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL TIME FOR COMPLIANCE.UM THIS VACANT LOT. UM. IS THERE . ARE THERE ANY STEPS BEING TAKEN TAKEN TO SECURITY FOR FUTURE? FROM. THE FUTURE EFFORTS OF PEOPLE TO CARS OR JUNK THEM THERE. YES SO THE INTENTION OF THE RESPONDENT IS ONCE THE VEHICLES ARE REMOVED. THEY WANT TO PUT SOME NO PARKING SIGNS.
ALONG THE PERIMETER OF THE VACANT LOT AND IN ORDER TO DETER ANY UNLAWFUL PARKING OR STORAGE OF INOPERABLE VEHICLES ON THE PROPERTY. AND. LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT IS ALSO HELPING IN THAT EFFORT. I IMAGINE. YEAH, WE'VE BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH OUR LOCAL COMMUNITY POLICING UNIT, UM DEPUTY HICKMAN, HERE FROM MORTON COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE. AND HE'S ALSO BEEN MADE AWARE AND HAS BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THE RESPONDENT. OKAY IN CASE NUMBER 22 OH 37 VILLAGE VERSUS ANY TOWN NONPROFIT, NONPROFIT HOUSING. I'M GOING TO GRANT A 60 DAY CONTINUANCE. WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT HAVE BEEN 60 DAYS. THE VIOLATION HAS NOT BEEN REMEDIED. THE BILL IS CAN BRING IT BACK BEFORE THE MAGISTRATE FOR IMPOSITION OF.
THE NEXT TAB IS GOING TO BE TAPPED. SEVEN CASE NUMBER 22 038 UM, THIS CASE IS RELATED TO THE LAST CASE. UM IT'S A NEIGHBORING LOT RIGHT NEXT DOOR TO THE TO THE LAST PROPERTY UNDER PARCEL NUMBER 01 SPORT 0-38, THE 008. DOES 000. DASH. ZERO UM AND AGAIN THE RESPONDENT WAS IDENTIFIED AS INDIAN TOWN NONPROFIT HOUSING AND THE REGISTERED AGENT OF THE CORPORATION WAS IDENTIFIED AS JENNIFER EHLE WILLIAMSON. UM AGAIN. SAME SITUATION. IT'S A BACON LOT THAT IS RIGHT NEXT DOOR TO THE LAST VACANT LOT WHERE THERE ARE NEIGHBORING RESIDENTS THAT ARE STORING INOPERABLE VEHICLES. UM ON THE LOT, AND THE RESPONDENT HAS BEEN ACTIVELY WORKING ON NOTIFYING EACH AND EVERYONE OF THE RESIDENTS SURROUNDING THE VACANT LOTS. UM AND THEY'RE WORKING ON GETTING THESE VEHICLES REMOVED. UM WE'VE ALSO BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH LOCAL SHARE. THE LOCAL SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT HAS ALSO BEEN MADE AWARE OF THE ISSUE, AND THE RESPONDENT INTENDS ON, UM, INSTALLING SOME SIGNAGE ALONG THE PERIMETER.
THESE VACANT LOTS IN ORDER TO DETER ANY UNLAWFUL PARKING OR STORAGE OF INOPERABLE VEHICLES IN THE FUTURE. SO AT THIS TIME, WE'D LIKE TO REQUEST. UH 60 DAY CONTINUANCE IN ORDER TO A LOT OF AMPLE TIME TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. ON BOTH OF THESE CASES INVOLVING THAT VACANT LOT.
[00:20:03]
DO YOU KNOW WHETHER OR NOT INDIAN TOWN, NONPROFIT HOUSING OR, YEAH, UM. LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT. DO THEY HAVE ANY CONTRACTS WITH TOE COMPANIES TO JUST AUTOMATICALLY REMOVED, UM, UNWANTED, SO FROM THE LOCK, SO INDIAN TOWN NONPROFIT DOES. UM, AND THERE JUST TAKING THE MEASURES OF NOTIFYING THE NEIGHBORING RESIDENTS THAT WHAT WHAT THEIR INTENTIONS ARE, BECAUSE OBVIOUSLY, IF THERE ARE ANY REMAINING VEHICLES, THAT IS THEIR INTENTION TO HAVE A UM, TOWING COMPANY CONTRACTED AND COME OUT AND REMOVE THESE VEHICLES THAT ARE STILL EXISTING ON THE ON THE VACANT LOTS. SO THEY'RE JUST TRYING TO TAKE THEIR TIME TO AMPLE, YOU KNOW, GIVE EVERYBODY AMPLE TIME TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE THAT YEAH. I MEAN, YOU KNOW FOR THE PEOPLE WHO YOU KNOW, FOR THE VILLAGE ITSELF, AND FOR THE PEOPLE WHO THE NEIGHBORS OF THIS WHO HAVE TO KIND OF LIVE WITH IT? YEAH. THAT MIGHT NOT BE QUICK ENOUGH FOR THEM, BUT I'M GOING TO GRANT THE 60 DAY CONTINUANCE BECAUSE IT'S ADJACENT TO THE OTHER LOT, AND IT'S POSSIBLE THESE CASES MAY BE CONSOLIDATED FOR FUTURE FOR FUTURE REFERENCE. BUT AGAIN . THE WHOLE POINT OF THIS IS TO MAKE SURE THEY COME INTO COMPLIANCE AT SOME POINT. I'M KIDDING. SO IF IN THAT 60 DAYS, YOU KNOW HASN'T BEEN COMPLIED WITH BRINGING BACK BEFORE THE MAGISTRATES BURGER. IMPOSITION OF A FINE, THANK YOU. NEXT CASE. OKAY THE NEXT CASES TAB EIGHT. CASE NUMBER 22 039.UM WITH WITH REGARDS TO THE PROPERTY AT 15300 SOUTHWEST JACKSON AVENUE. UM THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY BEEN IDENTIFIED AS THOMAS INVESTMENT. LLC AND THE RESPONDENT WAS IDENTIFIED AS MOHAMMED. YOU DIDN'T UM. THIS PROPERTY HERE, UM GOOD MAJORITY OF THESE VIOLATIONS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED, PARTICULARLY WITH REGARDS TO THE SIGNAGE VIOLATION UNDER CODE 3-4 0.15. AND THE TRASH AND DEBRIS UNDER 67.201 B, UM. AS WELL AS OUTDOOR STORAGE UNDER 3-5 0.5. AND THE DISPLAYING OF ADDRESS UNDER 5-2 0.8. UM. CURRENTLY THE RESPONDENT IS WORKING WITH.
STAFF OTHER STAFF WITHIN THE VILLAGE IN ORDER TO GET A SET OF PLANS AND PERMITS. UM APPROVED FOR THE PARKING LOT DIRECTLY OUTSIDE OF THE STOREFRONT. IT'S A CONVENIENCE STORE. UM LIKE, ALMOST LIKE A LIKE A QUICK STORE , UM, ALONG JACKSON AVENUE, AND THEY'RE WORKING ON GETTING SOME OF THE POTHOLES ADDRESSED WITHIN THE PARKING LOT AS WELL AS THE STRIPING. AND THE ACTUAL STRUCTURE ITSELF NEEDS JUST SOME GENERAL MAINTENANCE PAINT PRESSURE CLEANING, UM SO AND, UH , IN MY COMMUNICATION WITH THE RESPONDENT. MR MOHAMMED YOU DIDN HE DID REQUEST ADDITIONAL TIME IN ORDER TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE? UM AND THE VILLAGE IS NOT OPPOSED TO ALLOWING THAT TIMEFRAME NEEDED TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. THAT BEING 60 DAYS. SO AT THIS TIME WE'D ASKED FOR A 60 DAY CONTINUANCE IN ORDER TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. ALL RIGHT, UM. AND YOUR STATEMENT THAT STATEMENT IS THAT THEY'RE THERE ARE THEY HAVE BEEN MOVING STEADILY TOWARDS COMPLIANCE ISSUE ON ALL THE ISSUES THAT THEY WERE CITED? YES, SIR. UM ALL RIGHT. SO IN CASE NUMBER 22 DASH OH 39, THE VILLAGE VERSUS TO MEET INVESTMENT LLC. UM AND MR ARDEN. UM GOING TO GRANT THE CONTINUANCE OF 60 DAYS WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT HAVE BEEN 60 DAYS? THEY HAVEN'T COMPLIED. WE BROUGHT BACK FOR THE MAGISTRATE FOR THE IMPOSITION OF. NEXT MATTER, OKAY. THE. NEXT MATTER ON THE DOCTOR. JUST TAB NUMBER 9 22 040, WHICH IS COMPLIED. UM AFTER THAT, WE'LL BE TAB NUMBER 10 22 041. UM. THE RESPONDENT DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE HERE FOR THIS ONE. UM, I DO BELIEVE THE VERY NEXT TAB TAB 11. MISS EDNA , ARE YOU? WHAT? WHICH CASE? ARE YOU HERE FOR MAN? WHAT WAS THAT? YEAH. FOR EXAMPLE. OKAY. SO THE OWNER OF THE OF THE LAST CASE WE'RE TRYING TO BRING BEFORE IS
[00:25:06]
HERE. MR IS HERE. YES. WONDERFUL LET'S LET'S INSTEAD OF GOING WITH CASE 22 OH, 22 OH 4104 TO MOVE FORWARD WITH 22. OH, 46, AS ALL THE WITNESSES AND RESPONDENTS ARE HERE NOW. OKAY, OKAY. SO LET'S MOVE FORWARD THAT CASE, OKAY? AS OF COPIA, GET THOSE ARE YOUR COPIES OF MY OF MY CASE LAW. OKAY JUST SO YOU COULD HAVE IT AS A REFERENCE AS WE GO ALONG, OKAY? THEY'RE FOR YOU. THEY'RE FOR YOU. OKAY? YEAH. UM. OH, YEAH. UM. SO MY NAME IS ROBERT PEREZ AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. I'M A COLD COMPLIANCE INSPECTOR FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. THE CASE WAS INITIATED PROACTIVELY UPON MY DISCOVERY ON MARCH 8TH OF 2022. AND THE RESPONDENT MARY ALEXANDER'S IS PRESENT AS WELL AS THE RESIDENTS OR TENANTS OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 15388, SOUTHWEST 100, OR RATHER, FORGIVE ME, 151. 55 SOUTHWEST FOX STREET. UM VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN, FLORIDA 34956. UH ACCORDING TO THE OFFICIAL RECORDS OF THE MARTIN COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISERS, UM, THE PROPERTY OWNER HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS MS MARY ALEXANDER'S AND A COPY OF THIS RECORD HAS BEEN MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT ONE. UM. ON MARCH , 8TH OF 2022 INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. AT THAT TIME I OBSERVED THE BEFORE. DO YOU HAVE A COPY OF THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION FOR THIS? YES, IT'S GOING TO BE MARKED BEFORE US.EXHIBIT THREE IN YOUR PACKAGE. DO YOU HAVE ONE THAT'S OUTSIDE OF THE EXHIBITS. UM NO. OKAY.
JUST WANTED TO KNOW. OKAY? UM. BEFORE WE PROCEED. HAVE YOU GIVEN A COPY OF ALL THESE EXHIBITS, TOO? YES SHE HAS A ENTIRE COPY OF THE DARK IN THE CASE. MET AND. UH MA'AM, IS YOUR NAME MARIEL EGGS, ENTITIES OR SENTENCE? MIRIAM IS MATERIAL EXAMINERS. OKAY SO ON BECAUSE ON HERE IT HAS YOUR LAST NAME IS BEING FIRST. SO I WANTED YEAH. WE JUST RECORDED ON THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION AS IT'S REFLECTED ON THE TAX RULES. SO IF YOU LOOK AT EXHIBIT ONE, IT HASN'T REFLECTED AS EXEMPT. UM, SO FORGIVE ME FOR THAT. NO, THAT'S ALL RIGHT. THAT'S WANT TO MAKE SURE ADDRESSING EVERYBODY. MARK. MM YOU CAN PROCEED, MR PARUBIY. SO ON MARCH 8TH OF 2022. I INSPECTED THE PROPERTY AND AT THAT TIME I OBSERVED THE FOLLOWING VIOLATIONS. WE HAD CODE VIOLATIONS UNDER 3-5 20220.2 FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF LIVESTOCK THAT BEING CHICKENS ON THE RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY. WE ALSO HAVE VIOLATIONS ON THEIR 21-1. FOR THE, UH, BOARDED UP WINDOW SKYLIGHT OR DOORFRAMES. AND THEN WE HAVE A VIOLATION. THERE'S 67.201 B FOR THE EXCESSIVE ACCUMULATION OF TRASH AND DEBRIS ON THE PROPERTY. UM. AT THAT TIME I PHOTOGRAPH THE PROPERTY AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS ACTUALLY SHOW WHAT I SAW THEN AND ARE MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBITS TO A THROUGH TO SEE ONE EXHIBITS HERE, ONE BY ONE ON TO A YOU HAVE A AERIAL DEPICTION OF THE PROPERTY, JUST MARKING WHERE IT'S AT IN RELATION TO THE INTERSECTION THERE ON FOX ROAD AND IN JACKSON AVENUE. AND. GOING ON TO BE, UM SO. THERE WAS IT WAS VERY DIFFICULT FROM BECAUSE WHEN I ARRIVED AT THE PROPERTY, I WASN'T ABLE TO MAKE CONTACT WITH ANY OTHER RESIDENTS , BUT I TRIED MY VERY BEST. YOU KNOW, GATHER SOME DEPICTIONS FROM, UM YOU KNOW THAT WERE WITH HIM PLAYING VIEW OF THE PUBLIC RIGHT AWAY. SO IF YOU LOOK BACK ON THE AERIAL JUST AS A REFERENCE. CURRENTLY I'M ON THE WHAT WOULD BE THE FOUR EAST SIDE. OF THE PROPERTY. UM. SO
[00:30:03]
THE FRONT END AND I'M JUST GOING TO KIND OF USE THIS AS AN EXAMPLE FOR YOU. THIS IS FOX STREET. SO THIS IS THE FRONT END OF THE PROPERTY. AND THE FIRST PHOTO ON TO BE ON STANDING HERE ALONG THE PUBLIC RIGHT AWAY. BACKYARD WHICH WOULD BE THE FAR EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. UM, AND YOU'LL SEE THERE. IT'S UH MAKESHIFT AND CLOSURE THAT THEY'VE BUILT THEIR ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY IN ORDER TO MAINTAIN, UM, THE CHICKENS THAT WERE BEING STORED ON THE PROPERTY. AND SOME OF THESE CHICKENS WERE JUST AT LARGE ROAMING WITHIN THE COMMUNITY IN AND OUT OF THE YARD. UM AND IF YOU GO ON TO THE BOTTOM TAB ON TO BE, YOU'LL SEE ON THE FORE END. THERE IS A MAKESHIFT ENCLOSURE. WHERE UM THEY APPEARED THAT THEY WERE STORING. UM SOME LIVESTOCK THERE AS WELL ON THE PROPERTY. ON TO BE. WHERE IS THAT? CAN YOU. HOLD UP THAT PHOTO? YES SO TO BE, I'M ACTUALLY NOW STANDING ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY, WHICH WOULD BE JACKSON AVENUE AND I'M LOOKING IN BETWEEN BECAUSE IT HAS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE AND THEN THE GARAGE. WHAT WOULD BE THE GARAGES? I CAN ACCESSORY STRUCTURE FACING. JACKSON AVENUE , AND THERE'S A SLIGHT GAP THERE WHERE I WAS ABLE TO GET ADVANTAGE POINT INTO THE BACKYARD. UM SO THAT ENCLOSURE YOU SEE ON THE FOUR END OF THAT IMAGE IS ACTUALLY ALONG THE EAST SIDE. OF THE YARD. WHEN YOU SAY THAT ENCLOSURE THIS ENCLOSURE AND TO BE THE TOP PHOTO ON TO BE THE BOTTOM PHOTO, THE BOTTOM PHOTO YEAH. SO ON THE RIGHT HAND SIDE OF THE BOTTOM PHOTO. THAT'S WHERE THEY CAN CLOSURE IS THAT YOU'RE TAKING A PICTURE OF THEM BOTH. IN THE TOP PHOTO AND THEN THE BOTTOM PHOTOS THE SAME NO. SO IF YOU LOOK AND THERE'S A THERE'S A AN EASEMENT ON THE BOTTOM PHOTO BETWEEN TWO STRUCTURES. THERE'S LIKE A EASEMENT POINT. ON THE FOUR END OF THAT EASEMENT, YOU'LL SEE, UM, LOOKS LIKE A LITTLE SQUARE CAGE ON THE BACK END, AND IT WAS ELEVATED ON A SET OF SOME SOME TWO BY FOUR PLYWOOD THAT HAD THE ACTUAL ENCLOSURE WAS ELEVATED FROM THE GROUND, AND I'VE ONLY GOT TWO PHOTOS AND EXHIBIT TO BE, YEAH. SO MAYBE IF YOU COULD, IF YOU COULD GO RIGHT HERE. SO THIS HERE IS ALONG THE EAST SIDE. THEY HAVE A PRIVACY WALL.THIS HERE IS THE TOP PART OF AN ENCLOSURE THAT THEY HAVE ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY.
IT'S A LARGER ENCLOSURE ENCLOSURE WHERE YOU'RE A STATE WHERE YOU'RE ALLEGING THAT THE CHICKENS ARE BEING HELD. YES OKAY. YES AND THEN THAT IS A CHICKEN COOP. YES YES. AND THEN ON THE BOTTOM SIDE, IF YOU LOOK DIRECTLY IN BETWEEN THIS LITTLE BREEZEWAY EASEMENT. ON THE FAR END, THERE'S ANOTHER ENCLOSURE THAT'S BEING MAINTAINED THEIR WHERE THEY'RE ALSO STORING. OR THEY WERE STORING THE SAME ENCLOSURE TO SEPARATE TWO SEPARATE ENCLOSURES FOR THE HOUSING OF. OF CHICKENS. EXACTLY YES, SIR. I'M JUST CLARIFYING THAT THE HERE IS THAT THE SAME PHOTO OR SOMETHING ELSE. AND THEN THERE'S THIS PHOTO ALSO SHOW THE VIOLATION. FOR WINDOW COVERINGS. IS THAT ALSO SHOWN HERE? YES SO, UM, NOT IN THE FIRST OR YOU COULD PARTIALLY SEE IT ON THE BOTTOM IMAGE OF TABBY. SO WHAT'S BEING ENCLOSED IS A IS A GARAGE DOOR. AND IF YOU GO ON TO EXHIBIT TO SEE YOU'LL SEE THAT THIS, UM THIS. STRUCTURE THIS GARAGE AREAS THE DOOR. IT DOESN'T HAVE A GARAGE DOOR. IT'S BEING ENCLOSED BY A SET OF WHAT APPEARS TO BE SOME STEEL SHEETS.
UM THAT ARE DRILLED INTO THE ACTUAL WALL. AND THAT'S WHAT APPEARS THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE USING AS THE DOOR, YOU KNOW, WHATEVER TO COVER THE GARAGE AND IN YOUR INSPECTION WAS ANYBODY FROM AH, THE VILLAGES BUILDING DEPARTMENT. DID THEY HAVE A CHANCE TO GO ON INSPECTION WITH, YOU KNOW DO NOT. SO THE. THE VIOLATIONS THAT RELATE TO THE WINDOW SKYLIGHT AND DOOR FRAMES . ARE YOU GOING TO HAVE ANYBODY GIVE ANY TESTIMONY FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TODAY? UM, I DIDN'T HAVE ANYBODY, UM, AVAILABLE TODAY FOR THAT, UM. WHAT I CAN SAY IS THAT IT'S YOU KNOW, I DO KNOW THAT IT'S AN ACCESSORY TO THE PROPERTY. IF YOU LOOK AT THE AERIAL UM, ON
[00:35:01]
FOX ROAD, YOU'LL SEE THE RECTANGULAR SHAPE OF THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. AND THEN JUST ADJACENT TO IT, UM ALONG THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE LOT. THERE'S ANOTHER SQUARE STRUCTURE THERE. IT'S LIKE AN ACCESSORY STRUCTURE THAT AT SOME POINT WAS TO SEPARATE THE PART THAT LOOKS LIKE THE SEPARATE GARAGE AND THAT'S WHERE ALL THIS ALL THOSE PHOTOS OF OR OF THAT BUILDING BUILDING IN PARTICULAR. UM WHERE THERE WERE AT LEAST THE PHOTOS OF THE WHAT APPEARS TO BE ABORTED UP GARAGE? YEAH BAD BUILDING AND THEN YES, PHOTOS OF THE OF THE COOP. YES, THAT BUILDING IN THIS YES, SIR. IN THE BACK YARD AREA. YES, SIR. SO NONE OF THE PHOTOS ARE OF THIS MAIN BUILDING THERE ALL OF THE OUTSIDE BUILT GARAGE BUILDING IN THE COOP IN THE BACKYARD. YES, SIR. UM SO. BASED ON MY INVESTIGATION, I HAD ISSUED A NOTICE OF VIOLATION. NOTICE A HEARING TO THE RESPONDENT ON MARCH 8TH OF 2022 FOR THE HEARING OF MARCH OR RATHER, APRIL 19TH 2022, WHICH IS MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT THREE. AND AGAIN THESE NOTICES DETAILING THE SAME THREE VIOLATIONS THAT WERE PREVIOUSLY UM, CITED IN MY TESTIMONY. UM THE NOTICE WAS SENT TO THE RESPONDENT VIA CERTIFIED MAIL AND THE PROPERTY WAS POSTED ALONG WITH THE POSTING AT VILLAGE HALL. THE RETURN RECEIPT WAS RECEIVED ON MARCH 18TH OF 2022. AND THE AFRICAN I AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE IS MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT FOR. ALONG WITH A DEPICTION OF THE POSTING. ON 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING ON APRIL 8TH, UM MARK BEFORE YEAR'S EXHIBIT FIVE.AND THEN THERE'S THAT PICTURE SHOW THE FRONT OF THE MAIN BUILDING OR THE FRONT OF THE GARAGE BUILDING, WHERE THE VIOLATION IN THE MAIN BUILDING THE MAIN BUILDING. AND DOES THE VILLAGE. NO, UM. IS THAT MAIN BUILDING HAS THAT BEEN CERTIFIED OR HAS THAT BEEN INSPECTED TO ENSURE THAT IT'S PROVIDES DECENT SAVINGS, SANITARY HOUSING FOR TENANTS. UM IT IT HAS NOT. UM, LIKE I SAID, WHEN WE WENT OUT THERE WE WEREN'T ABLE TO MAKE CONTACT WITH ANYBODY, SO I HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO VERIFY WHETHER OR NOT THAT'S BEING USED AS A AS A HOUSING AREA, UM OR IF IT'S JUST SIMPLY A GARAGE THAT THEY'RE STORING EQUIPMENT AND THAT WE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO ESTABLISH AS OF YET. ALRIGHT, SO MAYBE I CAN HEAR FROM THE TENANTS AND THE OWNER TO FIND OUT THAT INFORMATION. SPORT. UM AS FAR AS COOP ITSELF. YES. YOU ABLE TO OBSERVE ANY LIVE CHICKENS IN THE COOP ITSELF IN THE COOP ITSELF. I DID NOT. UM WHAT? WHAT THERE WAS THROUGHOUT THE COMMUNITY THERE ON THAT LITTLE CORNER. UM IT WAS JUST A LARGE AMOUNT OF CHICKENS THAT WERE AT LARGE. UM AND THAT YARD ON THAT PROPERTY? YES YES, IN AND OUT OF THE YARD GOING INTO THE BACKYARD. UM SO THAT THIS KIND OF CAME, UM, AS A RESULT OF SOME CALLS THAT WE'RE GETTING WITH REGARDS TO CHICKENS JUST FREE ROAMING THE AREA. UM SO WHEN WE WERE ABLE TO IDENTIFY THAT THERE WAS SOME CHICKEN COOPS IN THERE, WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE WERE NOTIFYING THE RESPONDENT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. AND THIS THIS AREA ON FOX STREET AND INDIAN TOWN THAT THAT'S A RESIDENTIAL ZONING. THERE'S NO RURAL DESIGNATION TO THAT ZONING. NO. SO THERE AREN'T ALLOWED TO KEEP ANY LIVESTOCK. ANY CHICKENS? ANY PETS LIKE THAT? NO, SIR. WHAT I CAN SAY IS, UM, WE DID GET A CHANCE TO RE INSPECT THE PROPERTY. UM YESTERDAY. ON APRIL. APRIL 18TH.
AND I WAS ABLE TO VERIFY THAT WE CAN GO AHEAD AND COMPLY. VIOLATIONS UNDER 67.201 B FOR TRASH. UM. AND AS WELL AS THE VIOLATION FOR THE LIVESTOCK, IT APPEARED THAT THEY HAD TAKEN APART THE CHICKEN COOP. AND THERE WAS SOME WOOD AND THE BREEZE AS A RESULT OF THAT STORED ALONG THE FRONT END OF THE PROPERTY FOR BOTH PICKUPS. UM SO I'M GATHERING THAT THESE VIOLATIONS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED. WHEN I WENT OUT THERE. I DID NOT SEE ANY OTHER CHICKENS, UM, AT
[00:40:02]
LARGE OR OUTSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE. SO THE OUTSTANDING ISSUE IS JUST THE VIOLATION UNDER 21-121 FOR THE BOARDED UP , UM, GARAGE DOOR AREA. OR. FIND AND HIS. VILLAGE RESTING.THERE'S A VILLAGE HAVE ANY MORE INFORMATION THAN WANTS TO PRESENT TO THEM AS OF RIGHT NOW, NO, UM WE I GUESS AT THIS TIME LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND LET THE RESPONDENT ALRIGHT. YEAH.
BEFORE. AH! I APOLOGIZE, MR EXANTA. WE WEREN'T SURE THAT YOU'RE GOING TO BE ABLE TO MAKE IT BEFORE YOU ARRIVED. I HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO SWEAR EVERYONE TO ENSURE THAT, UH, IF THEY'RE GOING TO PRESENT PRESENTED EVIDENCE OR GIVE WITNESS TESTIMONY AT THIS HEARING THAT THEY ARE THAT THEIR TESTIMONY WAS SUFFICIENT TO PROVIDE EVIDENCE. SO AT THIS TIME BEFORE YOU BEFORE YOU RESPOND I WOULD LIKE TO SWEAR YOU IN AS A WITNESS, SO THAT IF YOU MAKE STATEMENTS, THOSE STATEMENTS CAN BE PUT ON THE RECORD AND CAN PROVIDE EVIDENCE TO THIS TRIBUNAL. SO AT THIS TIME AH, I'VE ASKED YOU TO RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. AND MS MARIELLE, DO YOU SWEAR? AFFIRM THAT ANY TESTIMONY OR STATEMENTS YOU'RE GIVING HERE TODAY ARE THE TRUTH , THE WHOLE TRUTH OR NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH. ALL RIGHT. AND ARE YOU GOING TO PRESENT? ARE YOU GOING TO MAKE A PRESENTATION OR TWO? GIVE EVIDENCE IN DEFENSE OF WHAT THE VILLAGE HAS STATED HERE TODAY. OKAY? IF YOU WOULD, I WOULD. CAN YOU APPROACH THE DAIS AND MAKE YOUR STATEMENTS TO THE MICROPHONE SO THAT THEY CAN BE PICKED UP FOR THE RECORD. AND YOU ARE MISS MURIEL EXAMPLES ? YES ALRIGHT. GOOD MORNING THIS MORNING. GOOD MORNING. ALRIGHT YOU'VE HEARD WHAT THE VILLAGES STATED ABOUT YOUR PROPERTY. AND YOU ARE THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY. YES, YES AND THIS IS YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND TO WHAT THE VILLAGERS SAID ABOUT THE PROPERTY AND THE VIOLATIONS ON THE PROPERTY. AND DISCUSS WHAT YOU'RE GOING TO DO ABOUT IT. SO WOULD YOU, PLEASE? AH! AT THIS MOMENT. TELL ME WHAT YOU WANT ME TO HERE SO THAT I CAN HEAR YOUR TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE AND COMPARED TO THEIRS AND MAKE IT I DON'T LIVE IN THIS HOUSE. BUT THIS IS MY HOUSE CHILI ON THIS HOUSE. BUT I WENT HURTING HOUSE. ALL THE TIME TO HER. DON'T PUT ANYTHING BUT IN THE HOUSE. THAT'S NOT THE FIRST TITLE LIKE ME FOR THE CHICKEN. THAT'S IT. I THINK THIS IS THE SECOND TIME. OKAY, TELL HER DO EVERYTHING RIGHT? THEREFORE THE GUY'S DOOR. I TALKED TO HER ABOUT IT ALREADY. ALL RIGHT. IT'S YOUR HOUSE, ARE THEY? ARE THEY RENTING FROM YOU? YEAH DO YOU HAVE A WRITTEN LEASE BETWEEN THEM? NO. LET'S SEE LIVE A LONG TIME. THEIR HOUSE A HANDSHAKE.
THEY'RE RUNNING FROM YOU. IS THERE AN AGREEMENT THAT THEY TAKE CARE OF ALL THE HOUSE AND MAKE SURE IT COMES AS IT STANDS UP THE CODE? YEAH OKAY. WHEN THEY DON'T DO THAT, HOW DO YOU DRESS? I WOULD TALK TO HER TO DO WHAT SHE'S SUPPOSED TO DO. IN THEIR HOUSE BECAUSE WHEN I WENT TO HER THE HOUSE NOTHING WRONG IN IT. SHE PUT A LOT OF MESS IN THERE. MYSTICAL WISH PUT THE CHICKEN I ALWAYS TELL HER KEEP EVERYTHING CLEAN. OKAY? DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT SHE CANNOT KEEP A CHICKEN COOP AND CHICKENS AT THIS HOUSE? YOU CAN'T THAT TOLD HER. YOU TOLD THE TENANTS BEFORE THEY CAN'T DO THAT. I TELL HER. THIS IS THE SECOND TITLE HER NO CHICKEN AND THEIR HOUSE THE SECOND TIME. NOT ANYMORE. IN THERE THEY ARE. DID YOU TEAR DOWN THE CHICKEN COOP AND PUT IT OUT FOR THE GARBAGE? CHICK. NO THE CHICKEN HOUSE CHICKEN. I TOLD HER THAT I TOLD HER THAT SHE SAID SHE MOVED THE CHICKEN. I SAID I HEARD IT. UNITY. TAKE THAT THING OUT. WAS IT TAKEN OUT ? I DON'T KNOW FOR NOW. DID YOU GO? I MEAN, DO YOU LIVE AT THE SAME PLACE? I'M LIVING OFF. NO 1 50 SWEET. HAVE YOU GONE BY YOUR OTHER PROPERTY? WHERE THESE LADIES LIVE TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THAT STUFF HAS HAPPENED. SOMETHING HAPPENED. I'M GOING DOWN THERE AND TALK TO HER. OKAY AS FAR AS THE BOARDED UP GARAGE. HOW HOW ARE Y'ALL DEALING WITH THAT? I TOLD HER ALREADY. I THINK SHE'S DOING FOR THE I DON'T DO EVERYTHING COMMENT. I TELL HER SHE WAS BROKE THERE.
THEY DON'T SHE'S HERE. OKAY TOLD HER THAT YOU UNDERSTAND THAT THE PROPERTY OWNER IF YOUR TENANT IF SHE DOESN'T DO IT, THEN YOU HAVE TO DO THAT. OKAY, OKAY. MAYBE AND THEN DON'T DO IT. I NEED TO
[00:45:06]
GO THERE AND DO IT YOUR PROPERTY . YOU OWN THAT PROPERTY. MHM THERE WRITTEN FROM YOU. YOU OWN THAT PROPERTY, SO YOU NEED TO GO TAKE CARE OF IT. OKAY Y'ALL PAY FOR THAT. YOU WORK IT OUT BETWEEN YOU TWO. YEAH, BUT WITH THE VILLAGE. ANYTHING THAT HAPPENS ON THE PROPERTY IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY? YES OKAY. YEAH THEN YOU WORK IT OUT WITH YOUR TENANTS. AS TO WHOEVER DID WHAT? SO FIRST THINGS FIRST GOT TO GET RID OF THE CHICKENS AND THE CHICKEN HOUSE. OKAY, FIX THE GARAGE. OKAY, OKAY. REMOVE THE CHICKEN HOUSE. THAT'S WHAT HE SAID. FIXING THE GARAGE. HOW LONG IS THAT GONNA TAKE YOU TO HMM. I NEED TO GO LOOK AT IT AND LOOK AT FOR SOMEBODY TO DO IT FOR ME. OKAY. HOW LONG YOU NEED ME TO TAKE A DIP. PROUD OFTEN DAMAGE. OH IT NEEDS TO. IT'S A VIOLATION OF THE CODE NEEDS TO BE CORRECTED. SO IF YOU TELL ME IT'S GONNA TAKE YOU A WEEK. TWO WEEKS. HOW LONG WILL IT TAKE YOU TO FIX THAT? ABOUT MARK. ABOUT FOUR WEEKS. OKAY TRIED TO FIND SOMEBODY TO HELP ME. WE DIDN'T AS FAR AS, UM. THE TRASH AND EVERYTHING ELSE. ALL THAT STUFF'S BEEN CLEANED UP, AND THAT'S WHAT THE VILLAGERS SAID. AH! AS FAR AS GETTING THE GARAGE FIXED MHM. IS THE GARAGE. THE ONLY THING THAT'S WRONG BECAUSE IF YOU FIX THE GARAGE AND YOU HAVE THE VILLAGE, COME BACK AND LOOK AT IT. IF THEY SEE SOMETHING ELSE WRONG, THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE TO SAY OKAY, THIS IS FIXED. BUT THIS OTHER THING IS WELL YEAH. IS IT GOING TO TAKE YOU? A MONTH OF FIXED JUST THE GARAGE. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE THE VILLAGE MIGHT BE NEXT? I NEED TO BE THE FIX. WELL RIGHT NOW IT'S JUST THAT'S THE GUY GARAGE. BUT IF ANYTHING ELSE IS OUT OF OUT OF ORDER WHEN THEY COME LOOK AND SEE. THE GARAGE IS FIXED. THEY MIGHT SEE SOMETHING ELSE. YEAH, I KNOW. I'M TRYING TO GIVE YOU AN OPPORTUNITY TO GET EVERYTHING RIGHT. OKAY.OKAY, OKAY. RIGHT SO, UH, SO IS IT YOUR TESTIMONY THAT YOU'RE GOING TO FIX THE GARAGE IS GOING TO TAKE YOU ABOUT FOUR WEEKS. YEAH. OKAY? SO IF WE WERE TO GIVE YOU AN OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE THAT TIME AND FIX THAT CAME BACK IN A MONTH THAT WOULD BE FIXED. THAT'S RIGHT. I DON'T KNOW. I A BECAUSE THAT'S DIFFICULT TO FIND SOMEBODY TO DO SOME JOB. ALRIGHT I KNOW SHE'S GONNA HELP ME, THOUGH IT BUT SHE'S A GOOD LADY. YEAH ALRIGHT, WELL, THE MAIN THING IS THE LIVESTOCK AND THE CHICKEN. CAN'T HAPPEN. TOLD HER THAT I TELL HER NO CHICKEN. THIS IS THE SECOND TIME SHE CHICKEN IN IT, BUT NEVER THE CHICKEN. I TOLD HER DUMP WITH CHICKEN. YOU BRING CHICKENS BACK. IT'S GOING TO BE YOUR FAULT. YOU KNOW, I AIN'T GOT NO TIME TO GO OVER THERE ALL THE TIME, BUT EVERY TIME. I DON'T EVEN KNOW IF SHE GOT CHICKEN DOWN THERE THAT YOU'RE DOING LIVESTOCK BREEDING CHICKENS OR HAVE A CHICKEN COOP IN A RESIDENTIAL STREET. IF SOMEBODY HEARS A ROOSTER CROW, YOU'RE GONNA BE CALLING. YEAH THEY REALLY DON'T CALL THE VILLAGE THAT MUCH OVER THE EGGS.
ROOSTER CROW. OKAY, OKAY. OKAY? WHO WANTS TO GET WAKEN UP BY ROOSTER CROW. WHEN YOU DON'T LIVE ON A FARM, UNDERSTAND? OKAY, YEAH. GET THOSE THINGS REPLACED. 30 DAYS. OKAY DAYS.
YOU THINK IT'S GONNA BE GOOD? GIVE ME MORE THAN THAT. YOU CAN'T GIVE ME MORE THAN THAT, TOO. WELL LET'S LET'S LET'S LET'S HEAR WHAT THE VILLAGE HAS TO SAY RESPONDED. AND YOU SAID THE CHICKEN COOP IS GONE. YOU'RE WORKING ON THE GARAGE? TRASH IS GONE. OKAY? THREE THINGS, THREE THINGS THINGS, OKAY? SO. DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE YOU'D LIKE TO SAY. IN DEFENSE OF WHAT THE VILLAGERS SAID. AS FAR AS THE VIOLATIONS THAT THEY SAID THAT THEY SAID THAT YOU MADE NO. I GOT NOTHING TO SAY. SURE I'M GIVING YOU EVERY TIME BECAUSE ONCE IT STOPS, THEN I HAVE TO WRITE UP IN ORDER. BASED ON WHAT YOU SAID. IF THERE'S ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT ME TO HEAR ABOUT THIS? YOUR PROPERTY. ISSUES. NOW'S THE TIME TO SAY IT. I THINK I HAD THAT TALKING ABOUT SOME FRAME. WINDOW. I DON'T UNDERSTAND. THAT'S THE GARAGE. THAT'S THE FOR THE GUARDS.
THAT'S BECAUSE OF IT. WHEN YOU FRAME WHEN YOU CLOSE IT UP THAT WAY, YOU HAVE TO CLOSE IT UP A PROPER WAY. YOU HAVE TO DO WITH THEM BUILDING CODE. OKAY JUST GO OUT THERE AND SLAP SOMETHING TOGETHER. IT'S GOT TO WITHSTAND HURRICANE FLOODS, RAIN INSULATION, HE YOU KNOW, THERE'S
[00:50:01]
A RE BUILDING CODES OF THAT TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE ARE PROTECTED AS THEY CAN BE WHEN THEY BUILT SOMETHING, SO IT WON'T FALL DOWN ON THEM. THE GET BLOWN AWAY DURING THE WIND, STONE THINGS LIKE THAT. SO IF YOU CAN MAKE SURE THAT YOU WORK WITH THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO GET THAT UP TO CODE. I THINK THAT VIOLATION CAN GO AWAY. OKAY BUT YOU HAVE TO DO THAT. YEAH.ALL RIGHT. WE CAN GIVE YOU MORE THAN MARK. TO FIX IT. LET'S LET'S SEE. LET'S LET'S SEE WHAT THE VILLAGES RESPONSE TO THAT IS , BUT I WANT YOU TO TELL ME I WANT YOU BECAUSE THEY'RE GONNA HAVE THEY THEY'RE GONNA HAVE A CHANCE TO RESPOND TO WHATEVER YOU SAID ABOUT WHAT YOU'RE GONNA DO, OKAY? BUT FOR INSTANCE, ANYTHING ELSE? YOU SAID YOU'RE GONNA TAKE CARE OF IT, AND IT'S ALREADY BEEN TAKEN CARE OF. SO THAT ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR VIOLATION. OKAY? BUT I'M ASKING YOU. IS THAT ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY? YEAH. YEAH. I DON'T WANT I DON'T WANT YOU TO FEEL LIKE YOU DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE TO SAY. EVERYTHING YOU COULD ABOUT WHAT THIS VIOLATION IS AND WHAT YOUR DEFENSES TO THAT UNDERSTAND. OKAY, THIS IS THE VALIDATION. BUT. I DON'T KNOW WHY I WANT TO SAY YES. WE'RE TOO MUCH FROM ME. I DON'T EXPECT THAT. ALRIGHT. WELL, I UNDERSTAND THAT AND I UNDERSTAND YOU WERE KIND OF UNDERGROUND, PREPARED AS A LITTLE BIT OF A SURPRISE. BUT JUST UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU OWN THE PROPERTY. YOU'RE RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERYTHING THAT GOES ON, I KNOW . YEAH SO EVEN THOUGH YOUR TENANTS WERE SHOWING UP HERE IF I WAS TO ORDER THE OWNER TO DO SOMETHING THAT THEY GO BACK AND TELL YOU YEAH, AND THEN IF YOU DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE TO BE HERE TO SAY SOMETHING, OKAY, THAT POSES A PROBLEM FOR YOU, OKAY? ALL RIGHT. WELL, IF THAT'S IF THAT'S ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY IN YOUR DEFENSE I'M GOING TO SAY THE DEFENSE RESTS. THANK YOU. AND THEN WE'RE GOING TO GIVE THE VILLAGE ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND TO WHAT YOU SAID. AS FAR AS THE AMOUNT OF TIME YOU NEED AND WHAT YOU DO. OKAY. OKAY.
THANK YOU. UM ON BEHALF OF THE VILLAGE. I'M NOT OPPOSED TO ALLOWING MISS SANTA'S ADDITIONAL TIME. UM REALLY AT TODAY'S HEARING WAS THE FIRST UM, IF ANY INTERACTION THAT I'VE BEEN ABLE TO HAVE WITH HER, UM, WE NEVER GOT A CALL AFTER THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION WAS RECEIVED, THEY HAVE SHOWN A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF PROGRESSION. WITH REGARDS TO THE VIOLATIONS SINCE MY LAST VISIT, UM SO I'M CONFIDENT THAT IF SHE NEEDS MORE THAN 30 DAYS, IF YOU'D LIKE I'M NOT OPPOSED TO ALLOWING MAYBE 45. UM DAYS A MONTH AND A HALF. GIVE OR TAKE, UM, TO FACILITATE COMPLIANCE. UM IF IT'S OKAY, CAN I ASK THE RESPONDED SOMETHING I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY BECAUSE I DID SEE SOME DEBRIS. BUT I'M NOT I'M GATHERING. IT'S FROM THE CHICKEN COOP BECAUSE IT LOOKED LIKE A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF WHAT WAS ON THE EAST SIDE WAS NO LONGER THERE. UM, IS IT OKAY IF I ASKED THE TENANTS THAT ARE HERE NOW, IF THAT'S BEEN ADDRESSED, BECAUSE I KNOW THAT I DON'T KNOW IF THERE IS A LANGUAGE BARRIER OR NOT. YEAH I THINK THAT IF THERE IF THEY HAVE SOMETHING THAT THEY WANT TO SAY ABOUT THEIR EFFORTS IN GETTING THE PROPERTY AND THE COMPLIANCE TO HEAR THAT. OKAY THIS RECORD, OKAY? UM ATTENDING AGO BY THE SCENE. A LOT. SIEBERT'S IN. NO YOU'RE YOU'RE YOU'RE SO LONELY. SHE'S GONNA IF IT'S OKAY WITH YOU, SIR. SHE'S SHE ONLY SPEAKS SPANISH. BUT IF YOU WOULD LIKE FOR HER, I'D LIKE FOR HER WORDS TO BE ON THE RECORD. YES, SIR. I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH YOU BEING THE ONLY TRANSLATOR SINCE YOU REPRESENTATIVE OF THE VILLAGE SO WE MAY HAVE TO GET A TRANSCRIPTION SERVICE TO TRANSLATE HER WORDS IN CASE THAT EVER COMES UP, OKAY? BUT TO THE EXTENT THAT YOU CAN BE HONEST, BE TRUTHFUL WORDS WHAT SHE SAID . OKAY OKAY. ALL RIGHT. PLEASE GIVE YOUR TESTIMONY AND YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD POLICE.
MAGDALENA, PEDRO LEON. HEY YES, SIR. CAN YOU SPELL THAT FOR ME? SIMILAR MY BOYFRIEND PHENOMENA.
OKAY SHE'S GONNA WRITE HER NAME DOWN FOR ME, OKAY? WILL BE M A G. D A L E. N A. UM AND THEN THE LAST NAME IS PEDRO . COMMENTS BUILDING P E D R O, UH LEON L E O N IN EUROPE AND
[00:55:09]
PEDRO LEON. HMM. NOT A WINDOW, OKAY? AH ROBERT, WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK YOU TO DO IS I'M GOING TO ASK QUESTIONS OF HER TRANSLATOR. COME HERE NOW. YES, YES. SIMILAR SENORA WORK AHEAD, OKAY? GO AHEAD. COME ON. THEY'RE ON THEIR WAY RIGHT NOW. THEY'RE COMING FROM JUST NEXT DOOR.BEING ARGUING THE LAW. THAT'S OKAY.
GOOD MORNING. CAN YOU PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD? CIA MENDOZA, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIANS HEALTH, OKAY, AND YOU'RE HERE TO TRANSLATE FOR MISS PEDRO LEON. AND I WANT TO. I WANT TO BE ASSURED THAT ALTHOUGH YOU ARE AN EMPLOYEE OF THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN, YOU'RE HERE SPECIFICALLY TO PROVIDE TRANSLATION SERVICES FOR MISS PEDRO LEON. SO WE CAN GET HER TESTIMONY AS A PARTICULAR AS A IN ANY EVIDENCE SHE MAY GIVE IN THIS TRIBUNAL ON THE RECORD, OKAY, THAT'S CORRECT. ALRIGHT SO, MISS PENDLEBURY, I WOULD LIKE TO ASK YOU NUMBER ONE. HAS THE CHICKEN COOP IN THE BACKYARD BEEN REMOVED. REMOVING. YES.
YEAH. SHE'S REMOVED THE CHICKEN COOP. DOES SHE UNDERSTAND THAT SHE LIVES IN A PLACE WHERE YOU CAN'T RAISE CHICKENS? AND I DON'T SEE YOU. THE SPOILS. T AS WELL. CARLOS NAME, TOO. SHE UNDERSTANDS SHE UNDERSTANDS THAT IT IS NOT PERMITTED IN THE AREA THAT SHE LIVES. SHE DID EXPLAIN THAT. ALTHOUGH THEY ARE ENCLOSED THEY'RE HOUSED INSIDE THE CHICKEN COOP. IN HER CHILDREN DO ENJOY THE ANIMAL. SHE DOES UNDERSTAND THAT IT'S NOT PERMITTED. IT'S NOT PERMITTED BECAUSE IT'S A FARM USE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA. YOU KNOW WHAT YES, BUT THE. AREA RESIDENTS HERE. AND THE MAIN REASON THAT MOST PEOPLE DON'T ALLOW THAT, ESPECIALLY IN ESPECIALLY HERE.
IS BECAUSE MAINLY BECAUSE ROOSTERS AND THE NOISE AND THE SMELL MEETING. SPORT GASSING.
AND IF I EVER MISSED. PLANE THAT IT'S NOT EXPLAINED THAT NOBODY IN HER AREA IS ALLOWED TO HAVE A CHICKEN AND IT'S NOT SPECIFICALLY AGAINST HER. BUT I CAN STAY IN THE NEWEST SOLAMENTE PARA ESPRESSO MUST GIVE EVEN IN THIS STUFF. SO SOLOMON. SO I WANTED TO. I WANTED HER TO UNDERSTAND THAT, BUT THE CHICKEN COOP AND THE CHICKEN COOP HAS BEEN REMOVED. IS THAT CORRECT? DON'T REMOVE YOUR MIND. THERE'S NOTHING THERE. WHERE ARE THE CHICKENS THAT USED TO LIVE IN THE COOP. YOU'RE BENDING. SHE SOLD THEM ON. OKAY SO THEY'RE NOT NO MORE CHICKENS LIVING THERE. LOST. SHE HAS TWO LITTLE BIRDS. AND JUST BY HAVING SITCOMS. SHE HAS TWO SMALL BIRDS. SHE'S LISTENING. THEY ARE NOT CHICKENS. THEY ARE BIRDS, BABY PARENTS OR OTHER PETS.
[01:00:05]
THEY'RE NOT LIVESTOCK. CHICKENS ARE CONSIDERED LIVESTOCK SOMETIMES. SOMETIMES. OKAY ALL REGULAR. THOSE ARE THE TWO THAT REMAIN ARE TOO SMALL BIRDS THAT HER LITTLE HER CHILDREN DO NOT WANT TO GIVE UP. THEY ARE NOT CHICKENS. THEY'RE VERY SMALL BIRD. SHE'S EXPLAINING PARAKEET OR FRENCH OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT . PEOPLE LISTEN. LOOK AT LOOK AR GREATER. ELLIS BEGAN AS A PARROT. WHAT'S A STAKE OF SMOKING? NO SECOND KILLERS, BUT. PERILOUS NAMES AROUND THEIR ENCLOSED THEY HAVE THEIR INDICATE THEY EVEN IF THEY WERE TO BE LET OUT. THEY DON'T RUN LIKE CHICKENS. SO THERE ARE SMALL BIRDS VERY, VERY SMALL BIRDS, AND SHE WAS LOOKING INTO GIVING THEM AWAY. TO SOMEONE THAT DOES HAVE SPACE FOR THEM, BUT HER CHILDREN ARE VERY ATTACHED TO THE TO THESE TWO SMALL BIRDS. SO THOSE ARE THE TWO THAT REMAINS. LET HER KNOW THAT IF THESE BIRDS OR CHICKENS SHE'S GOING TO STILL BE IN VIOLATION. SON. ORLANDO LAST NO MORE. THEY ARE NOT CHICKENS. AS FAR AS THE REMOVAL OF THE DEBRIS AND TRASH HAS THAT ALL BEEN DONE. TO REMOVE. YEAH, YEAH, YEAH, YEAH. YEAH. THEY HAVE REMOVED THE CLEANED UP. AND THEN SHE IS GOING TO WORK WITH HER LANDLORD TO FIX THE GARAGE. THE GARAGE OPENING. BUT IT'S POSSIBLE AND WHAT CLAUDIA BUMPS UP IN OKAY, SO YES, ALONG WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER AND MY HUSBAND SHE'S MENTIONING IN HER HUSBAND IS GOING TO REPAIR. DO THE REPAIRS TO THE PROPERTY, OKAY? DOES DOES SHE THINK HER HUSBAND CAN HAVE THE REPAIRS COMPLETED WITHIN 45 DAYS POSSIBLE? LIKE A SOUR TASTE IN CLOTHES. SIN ON MY MOTO SOLAMENTE LOS LOST. CHRISTIAN POINT C. WITH THAT TIME ALLOTMENT, IT WOULD BE FINE. DOES SHE UNDERSTAND THAT THE VILLAGE HAS ISSUED A VIOLATION AND THAT SHE'S HERE TO SHE'S HERE WORKING WITH THE LANDLORD AND THAT THIS IS IF SHE'S GOT ANYTHING TO SAY IN DEFENSE OF HERSELF IN THE IN REGARD TO THE VIOLATION THAT THIS IS THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE EVERYTHING THAT SHE NEEDS TO SAY. STATE IN THE HONEST LAYERS GOING APPROPRIATE THEM, VIVIAN. THOSE APPROPRIATE. HISPANIC BUT I'M LIKE SOBRE ESTOS. MOMENTUM BUT IT'S SPEAKER FROM THE DVD. EITHER UM. SENORA POLICY. IN MIDDLE NEWS. WHAT WOULD I SAID? ONE THING. POPULAR UNION MASTER WHEN A HANDY PERLA WHICH HOW.MAY I TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH HER PROPERTY? THE PROPERTY OWNER BECAUSE SHE DOES BELIEVE THAT ALL OF THESE COMPLAINTS CAME FROM A NEIGHBORING PROPERTY. AND. IT MAY BE A POSSIBILITY FOR HER TO LOOK INTO PUTTING A FENCE BETWEEN NEIGHBORS SO THAT THERE ISN'T NO FURTHER. UM, UM ANY FURTHER ISSUES. SHE DOES FEEL LIKE, INCLUDING IF HER CHILDREN ARE TO BE OUTSIDE. IT'S AN ISSUE BETWEEN THE NEIGHBORS, YOU KNOW. SO SHE JUST SHE'LL PROBABLY SPEAK TO THE PROPERTY OWNER REGARDING THAT NEXT STEP. THAT SHE WON'T HAVE ANY FURTHER
[01:05:01]
COMPLAINTS FROM NEIGHBORS AS WELL. OKAY WE'LL JUST EXPLAIN TO HER THAT IT'S NOT JUST COMPLAINTS FROM NEIGHBORS, BUT THE VILLAGE ALSO HAS. PEOPLE ALSO HAS MEMBERS. YOU KNOW MEMBERS OF ITS STAFF THAT GO AROUND AND LOOK TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT PROPERTIES ARE IN IN OR OUT OF VIOLATION. SO SIMPLY PUTTING UP A FENCE MIGHT NOT SOLVE EVERYTHING IF EVERYTHING ELSE ISN'T FIXED. OKAY, BUT IT'S A GOOD START. MASLOW'S VILLAGE. SKIP PASS IN ALASKA. LIMIT. OKAY AND THEN THERE'S THERE A DOG IS THAT HER DAUGHTER HAVE YES. OKAY. DOES SHE HAVE A IS SHE GOING TO SAY ANYTHING ON BEHALF OF HER OF AS A TENANT, OR DOES SHE HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY IN DEFENSE OF ANY OF THE CLAIMS THAT ARE BEING MADE BY THE VILLAGE HERE? AREA BASKET. DEL CASO STATUS OR. PART SO IS THAT IS THAT COMPLETE ANYTHING THAT YOU WANTED TO SAY IN REGARD TO THIS? NO FURTHER QUESTIONS, OKAY? THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TEST.OKAY SO THE VILLAGE GOING TO MAKE A RECOMMENDATION, YOU MADE A RECOMMENDATION BEFORE THAT YOU'RE WILLING TO CONTINUE THIS, POSSIBLY FOR 45 DAYS TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE. YES, SIR. AH I DON'T. I THINK THAT'S. THINK THAT'S ADEQUATE. WHAT I'M GOING TO ORDER TODAY IS I'M NOT GOING TO ISSUE AN ORDER OF VIOLATION. I'M GOING TO CONTINUE THIS MATTER FOR 45 DAYS. TO ALLOW, UE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE TO WORK WITH HER TENANTS, ESPECIALLY MS PEDRO DE LEON. TO BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE WITH VILLAGE CODE, AND IF IN THAT TIME THEY CAN BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE, I THINK THAT THE VIOLATION PROBABLY CAN BE DISMISSED AT THAT POINT, BUT UNTIL YOU BRING THE PROPERTY AND THE VIOLATION, THIS VIOLATION STILL IS OUT HERE. YOU HAVE 45 DAYS FROM TODAY TO BRING IT INTO COMPLIANCE. IF YOU DON'T YOU'LL BE BROUGHT BACK BEFORE A MAGISTRATE AND THERE'LL BE HEARING AND MORE THAN LIKELY THERE WILL BE A FINE OR LEANING POST. OKAY? SO THE WHOLE POINT IS TO BRING THE PROPERTY AND COMPLIANCE. AGAIN CAN'T HAVE LIVESTOCK AND RESIDENTIAL AREA. I KNOW THAT. A LOT OF PEOPLE. MAY OR MAY NOT AGREE WITH THAT, BUT I THINK THAT FROM A DECENT, SAFE AND SANITARY HOUSING PERSPECTIVE, IT'S PREFERABLE. IT MAKES IT EASIER TO KEEP THINGS DECENT, SAFE AND SANITARY. AND IT ALSO MAKES IT SO THAT NOBODY'S ROOSTERS KEEPING PEOPLE UP AT NIGHT. SO. THIS POINT. I'M GOING TO ORDER THAT THIS CASE BE CONTINUED FOR 45 DAYS. CASE NUMBER 22. OH 46 EXAMPLES MS MARIA MURIEL SANTA'S CONTINUE FOR 45 DAYS TO ALLOW THEM TO COMPLETE. THEIR WORK ON ON AH, CORRECTING THE VIOLATIONS. OKAY? THANK YOU. OKAY? MM. THANK YOU, MR PREZ WORKING WITH US ON THAT. AH! YOU READY TO MOVE FORWARD? MOVE FORWARD, OKAY. IF YOU WANT TO GO BACK TO UM, IS ANYONE ELSE HERE? BESIDES NO, NO ONE ELSE IS HERE FOR ANOTHER CASE. LET'S TRY. LET'S TRY TO GO AHEAD AND GET THROUGH THE REMAINING THESE SO YOU CAN GET TO MR TAYLOR. OKAY. OKAY IF YOU WANT TO GO BACK TO TAB NUMBER 10 WHERE WE LEFT OFF ON 22 041. AH! YEAH. GO BACK THERE. OKAY? SO AGAIN. MY NAME IS ROB PEREZ. I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. I'M A CO COMPLAINTS. INSPECTOR FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. UH THIS CASE WAS INITIATED PROACTIVELY UPON MY DISCOVERY ON MARCH 1ST OF 2022. AND THE RESPONDENT WAS IDENTIFIED AS ONE MIGUEL MARTELL, WHO IS CURRENTLY NOT PRESENT. THE CASE CONCERNS THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 15094 SOUTHWEST SEMINAL DRIVE WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN.
[01:10:05]
34956 ACCORDING TO THE OFFICIAL RECORDS OF MARIN COUNTY. THE PROPERTY OWNER AGAIN IS IDENTIFIED AS MR JUAN MIGUEL MOTEL. AND A COPY OF THIS PROPERTY APPRAISER RECORD HAS BEEN MARKED BEFORE YOURS. EXHIBIT ONE. ON MARCH, 1ST OF 2022 INSPECTED THE PROPERTY, AND AT THAT TIME I OBSERVED THE FOLLOWING CODE VIOLATIONS. WE HAVE VIOLATIONS UNDER 91 POINT.32 FOR ABANDONED, SALVAGED OR JUNK PROPERTY. UM VIOLATIONS ON THEIR 67.201 B FOR TRASH. AND VIOLATIONS UNDER FIVE DESK 2.1 OR RATHER 0.8 FOR DISPLAYING OF ADDRESS. UM AT THAT TIME I PHOTOGRAPH THE PROPERTY AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS ACTUALLY SHOW WHAT I SAW THEN AND OUR MARK BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBITS TO A THROUGH TO B. UM. GOING OVER THESE EXHIBITS ONTO A U HAVE A AERIAL DEPICTION OF THE PROPERTY. UM THE FRONT SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. UM OR THE ROADWAY. RATHER THAT'S ALONG THE FAR RIGHT SIDE OF THE IMAGES, SEMINAL DRIVE AND THE PROPERTY. IS ALONG THE WEST SIDE OF THE ROAD FACING EAST. AND GOING ON INTO EXHIBIT. UH TO BE, UM, WE HAVE A SET OF TWO DEPICTIONS. UM THE ISSUES ARE PRIMARILY AH! REVOLVING AROUND THE CARPORT AREA ALONG THE FOR NORTH SIDE OF THE PROPERTY, SO THE TOP IMAGES JUST A GENERAL DEPICTION OF THE PROPERTY ITSELF. AND THEN ON THE BOTTOM SIDE, WE HAVE ZOOMED IN, UH, DEPICTION OF THE CARPORT. UM SO IN THIS CARPORT, WE HAVE A LARGE AMOUNT OF JUST MISCELLANEOUS DEBRIS. UM, I'M IN MY COMMUNICATIONS WITH, UM MR JUAN MIGUEL MOTEL. HE HAS ADVISED ME THAT HE DOES SCRAP METAL. SO THERE'S A LARGE AMOUNT OF JUST METALS, DIFFERENT FORMS OF METALS THAT ARE JUST PILED, UH, WITHIN THE CARPORT AREA, AND THEN HE HAS A SERIES OF LAWNMOWERS. AND IF YOU LOOK IN THE LOWER DEPICTION, YOU'LL SEE A RED GOLF CART. AND IT'S ON FLAT TIRES COMPLETELY INOPERABLE . UM THAT'S JUST BEING STORED WITHIN THIS CARPORT AREA. UM SOR CONVERSATIONS, UM MR JUAN MIGUEL. DID EXPRESS. UM THE INTENTION OF FACILITATING COMPLIANCE. UM. BUT UH, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE YET TO GAIN ANY COMPLIANCE AS A AS OF TODAY. UMY QUESTIONS REGARDING THE DEPICTIONS THAT THE AS I SAID THE MAIN ISSUES ARE REVOLVING AROUND THE LITTLE CARPORT AREA THERE ALONG THE NORTH SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. FOR IT, UM, IN THE CARPORT AREA. LET ME LET ME ASK YOU FIRST AN EXHIBIT TO BE OR ANY OF THOSE VEHICLES, AUTOMOBILES THAT ARE SHOWN IN FRONT OF THE RESIDENTS ARE ALL OF THOSE OPERABLE. YES THOSE ARE INOPERABLE VEHICLES. ARE YOU TALKING? LANDSCAPING EQUIPMENT.
MOSTLY YEAH, YEAH, AND AGAIN UNDER, UM 91.32. IT'S REGARDING. I GUESS THE UM, INOPERABLE OR JOINT PROPERTY THAT'S BEING STORED IN THERE, SAYING THAT HE'S SAYING HE DOES SCRAP AT THE PROPERTY LOCATION, AND THERE'S NO WAY TO GET A REAL PERMIT FOR DOING SCRAP. OUT OF THIS RESIDENTIAL. IT'S A RESIDENTIAL ZONE. HE WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO GET A HOME OCCUPATION. UM PERMIT OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT FROM US IF YOU WERE TO ENCLOSE THAT CARPORT AREA AND MAKING A GARAGE STORED IN THERE. WHAT WOULD BE THE DIFFERENCE? UM WELL THERE, THERE WOULD BE A BUFFER. AT THAT POINT , THERE'D BE A BUFFER, UM, OBSTRUCTING THE VIEW OF THIS MATERIAL FROM THE PUBLIC RIGHT AWAY. SO UM BECAUSE NORMALLY WHEN. YOU KNOW WHAT IS HE RUNNING A REPAIR BUSINESS THERE.
IT'S NOT A REPAIR BUSINESS. HE JUST HE SAYS THAT HE DOES THIS AS A SIDE INCOME WHERE HE COLLECTS, UM THIS INOPERABLE EQUIPMENT STRIPS IT DOWN TO ITS DIFFERENT COMPONENTS OF METAL, AND THEN HE'LL UH, YOU KNOW, TAKE THAT OVER TO RECYCLING AGENCY FOR PAYMENT. SO HE'S BASICALLY HE'S USING HIS CARPORT AS A STORAGE GARAGE FOR. FOR HIS YARD BECAUSE IT LOOKS LIKE
[01:15:09]
NURSERY EQUIPMENT. SQUASH CRAP IS WHAT HE'S GOING THROUGH YAHOO! SO HE DOESN'T REPAIR ANY OF THIS NURSERY EQUIPMENT AND WE SELL IT JUST BREAKING IT DOWN FOR SCRAP. THE GOLF CART THAT'S SITTING THERE. UM HAS THAT, YOU KNOW. HAS HE MADE ANY EFFORT TO AT LEAST BREAK IT DOWN FURTHER.UM NO. AS OF OUR YOU KNOW, LAST INSPECTION, IT WAS STILL IN THE IN THE SAME STATE OF WHICH IS, YOU KNOW, DEPICTED IN THESE IMAGES. IS IT POSSIBLE FOR HIM TO GET THIS ZONING AREA WHERE IT'S POSSIBLE FOR HIM TO GET A PERMIT TO RUN A SALVAGE OR YOU KNOW? YEAH SMALL REPAIR SHOP? NO SINCE IT'S A RESIDENTIAL ZONED AREA, IT WOULDN'T FIT THE ZONING REGULATIONS OF. FOR SALVAGE YARD . YOU CAN'T REALLY RUN THE SANFORD AND SON OF NURSERY EQUIPMENT ON THAT YARD. NO ALL RIGHT. UM. ALRIGHT AND BASED UPON MY INVESTIGATION, I ISSUED A NOTICE OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF HEARING TO THE RESPONDENT ON MARCH 1ST 2022 FOR THE HEARING OF APRIL 19TH OF 2022. UM WHICH HAS BEEN MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT THREE AND AGAIN. THE NOTICE OF VIOLATION DETAILS THE SAME THREE VIOLATIONS THAT I CITED EARLIER IN MY TESTIMONY. UM THE NOTICE WAS SENT TO THE RESPONDENT VIA CERTIFIED MAIL, REGULAR MAIL AND THE PROPERTY WAS POSTED, UM, ALONG WITH THE POSTING OF VILLAGE HALL. THE RETURN RECEIPT WAS RECEIVED ON MARCH 3RD OF 2022. AND IS MY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE IS MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT FOR AND MY, UM. DEPICTION OF THE POSTING HAS BEEN MARKED BEFORE HE WAS EXHIBIT FIVE. RIGHT I'M GONNA ADMIT EXHIBITS ONE THROUGH FIVE AND THE EVIDENCE SIR. AND THEN, UM, AS I STATED, WE, YOU KNOW, DID, UM, PERIODICALLY GO BY. I HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH , UM, THE RESPONDENT AND HE WAS MADE WELL AWARE OF THE VIOLATIONS AND QUESTION UM, WE RECENTLY DID GO BY AND. AS I STATED EARLIER, IN MY TESTIMONY, THERE WEREN'T ANY CHANGES FROM ON THE STATE OF WHICH THE PROPERTY WAS WHEN WE INITIALLY CITED MOM. SO BASED UPON MY TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE, WE'D REQUEST THAT THE RESPONDENT BE ORDERED TO COMPLY WITH THE CITED PROVISIONS OF THE VILLAGE CALLED WITHIN THE NEXT 30 DAYS. IF NOT WITHIN COMPLIANCE BY THEN WE ASKED THAT THEY BE REQUIRED TO PAY A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 PER VIOLATION FOR EVERY DAY THAT THE VIOLATION CONTINUES THEREAFTER. UM THE VILLAGE HAS ALSO INCURRED A REASONABLE ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF $150 CONDUCTING THIS INVESTIGATION AND WE'D REQUESTED THAT ALSO BE RECORDED IN THE ORDER. UM AND AT THIS TIME THIS THIS WILL CONCLUDE MY TESTIMONY. OR MR CRAZE ON THE. BEEN ON THE TRASH WAS WAS ALL THE TRACKS CONTAINED WITHIN THAT DRIVE WITHIN THAT CARPORT AREA? YES, SIR. THERE WASN'T TRASH OUTSIDE OF THAT AREA. NO. RIGHT? MM. BECAUSE IT DOESN'T IT LOOKS LIKE THAT'S KIND OF THE SAME AS THE ABANDONED AND JOKE PROPERTY. VIOLATION IF YOU KNOW IF IT WASN'T THERE WASN'T TRASH IF, FOR INSTANCE, BECAUSE THE CARTILAGE OF THIS AREA LOOKS FAIRLY NEAT, EVEN THOUGH IT'S EVEN THOUGH IT'S UH, IT MIGHT BE A LITTLE FRED BEAR FROM A FOLIAGE POINT OF VIEW. IT STILL LOOKS. I DON'T SEE THE TRY. THAT'S WHY I'M NOT. I'M NOT SEEING THE TRASH OTHER THAN THAT CARPORT AREA. UNDERSTOOD THE ONLY TRASH THAT WE HAD, WHICH HE , UM I CAN'T SAY HAS BEEN REMOVED WAS IN THE LOWER DEPICTION OF EXHIBIT TO BE YOU HAVE A BLACK GARBAGE BAG THERE.
UM WHICH HE SAID THAT HE HAD SOME ALUMINUM'S IN THERE LIKE CANS AND STUFF. I CAN SAY THAT THAT'S NOT THERE ANYMORE. THAT THAT HAS BEEN REMOVED. I'M NOT GONNA I'M GONNA SAY THAT THE VIOLATION FOR THE TRASH. I'M GONNA SAY THAT'S BEEN COMPLIED WITH, OKAY, JUST DEALING WITH THE ABANDONED JUNK AND SALVAGE PROBLEM. OKAY BECAUSE I JUST DON'T SEE THAT AT LEAST NOT FROM FROM THE EVIDENCE THAT I'M SEEING. I DON'T SEE THAT. SO MY ORDER GOING TO ISSUE AN ORDER VIOLATION BUT WITH THE PARAMETERS REQUESTED BY THE VILLAGE, BUT ONLY AS TO THE, UH THE ABANDONED JUMPED IN SALVAGE PROPERTY. BEST TO THE TRASH, OKAY? IT WILL END AS TO THE DISPLAYING ADDRESS. AND WHERE WOULD THEY WHERE THEY DISPLAY THEIR ADDRESS HERE AT THIS
[01:20:07]
PROPERTY NEAR THE, UM OR THEY, ACTUALLY, ACTUALLY WHAT WE COULD KEEP IT ON IS, UM. BECAUSE THEY DID DISPLAY ON THE MAILBOX. UM. AND MY POSTING WHEN I LATER WENT AND DID MY POSTING, THERE WERE, UM SOME NUMBERS ON THE ACTUAL AH! MAILBOX AND ON THE TOP SIDE OF YOU COULD SEE IN MY EXHIBIT FIVE AND THAT DEPICTION THAT THEY ADDED NUMBERS TO THE TOP SIDE SO WE COULD ACTUALLY COMPLY THAT AS WELL. OKAY I'M SORRY FOR THAT COMPLIANCE WITH THE SIGNAGE. THEY'RE JUST NOT OUT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE JUNK. YES, SIR. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. ISSUE AN ORDER ON THAT ORDER REQUIRING TO GET IN COMPLIANCE WITH THAT, AND JUST AS TO THE JUNK, OKAY? MR. RIGHT? ALRIGHT NEXT MATTER, 22 OH, FOUR TO EDNA WILLIAMS. OKAY? AGAIN MY NAME IS ROBERT PEREZ AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN AMOCO COMPLIANCE INSPECTOR FOR THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. THIS CASE WAS INITIATED PROACTIVELY UPON MY DISCOVERY ON MARCH 1ST OF 2022. THE RESPONDENT. IDENTIFIED AS EDNA WILLIAMS IS NOT PRESENT. THE CASE CONCERNS THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 14736, SOUTHWEST 172ND AVENUE AND THE INTEL, FLORIDA 34956, ACCORDING TO THE OFFICIAL RECORDS OF MARTIN COUNTY. PROPERTY APPRAISERS. THE OWNER AGAIN IS MISS EDNA WILLIAMS, AND A COPY OF THE RECORD HAS BEEN MARKED BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBIT ONE. ON MARCH, 1ST OF 2022 INSPECTED THE PROPERTY. THAT TIME I OBSERVED THE FOLLOWING VIOLATIONS, UM, GOT VIOLATIONS UNDER 3-5 20220.5. FOR OUTDOOR STORAGE. UH 67.201 B FOR TRASH AND 91.3 TO 4 ABANDONED, SALVAGE OR JUNKED PROPERTY. AT THAT TIME, THE PROPERTY THAT TIME I PHOTOGRAPHED THE PROPERTY AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS, UM, ACCURATELY SHOW WHAT I SAW. THEN IN OUR MARK BEFORE YOU AS EXHIBITS TO A THROUGH TO B. UM. SO ON TO A WE JUST HAVE AN AERIAL DEPICTION. UM THIS IS A VACANT LOT ON SOUTHWEST 172ND AVENUE. WHICH IS ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THIS AERIAL DEPICTION AND THE PROPERTY WOULD BE FACING EAST ALONG THE WEST SIDE OF 100 AND 72ND AVENUE. AND GOING ON TO BE, YOU'LL SEE THAT THERE IS A RECREATIONAL VEHICLE THAT'S BEING STORED ON THE VACANT LOT. UM, IT HAS, UM. NO REGISTRATION, UM AND ACCORDING TO MY COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE RESPONDENT IS CURRENTLY INOPERABLE. THE RECREATIONAL VEHICLE. UM AND THEN THERE WAS A SERIES OF SOME. LIKE FIVE GALLON TUBS THAT ARE BEING STORED ON THE VACANT LOT, ALONG WITH THE DRESSER THAT YOU'LL SEE ON THE TOP DEPICTION. AND THEN ON THE LOWER DEPICTION OF TO BE THERE'S A ZOOMED IN VIEW OF THE ACTUAL RV ITSELF. AND SOME OF THE TUBS AND. AND THE DRESSER ALONG THE LOWER RIGHT SIDE OF THE OF THE DEPICTION. ALL RIGHT. HAVE YOU HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO TALK WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER IN THIS, BUT I DID. YEAH, I DID. SHE SHE CAME BY, UM, ACCORDING TO HER, SHE HAD AN AGREEMENT WITH A UM. INDIVIDUAL AND THE COMMUNITY.SHE NEVER REFERENCED THEM AS A FAMILY MEMBER OR ANYTHING, AND THERE WAS AN AGREEMENT FOR THEM TO BE ABLE TO PARK THE VEHICLE THERE ON THE VACANT LOT. SHE WASN'T AWARE THAT THAT WASN'T PERMITTED. UM, SEEING AS THERE ISN'T A PRIMARY STRUCTURE ON THERE. WE CAN'T STORE YOU KNOW, RECREATIONAL VEHICLES. BUT ASIDE FROM THAT, UM THE VEHICLE ISN'T PROPERLY REGISTERED AND IS IN AN INOPERABLE STATE. SO THE INTENTION IS TO STORE IT THERE WITH THE INTENTION OF WORKING ON THE TRAILER TO GET IT INTO AN OPERABLE STATE. OKAY SO THE QUESTION. MY QUESTION IS, IF THIS WAS REGISTERED VEHICLE, WOULD THEY BE ABLE TO PARK IT THERE? UM NO, BECAUSE THERE'S
[01:25:05]
BECAUSE THERE ISN'T A PRIMARY STRUCTURE THERE. SO UNDER OUR, UM UM. SORRY OUR LAND DEVELOPMENT CALLED, UM, THE STORAGE OF RECREATIONAL VEHICLES IS ONLY PERMITTED, IF IT OCCURS WITHIN A RESIDENTIAL ZONED AREA . THERE NEEDS TO BE A PRIMARY STRUCTURE THERE AND THERE NEEDS TO BE A BUFFER. PROVIDED BOTH FOR MEANING SOME SORT OF VEGETATION OR FENCING AS AN ATTEMPT TO OBSCURE THE VIEW FROM THE PUBLIC. IS IT POSSIBLE THAT THE VEHICLE, IF MADE INOPERABLE , COULD SERVE AS A PRIMARY STRUCTURE ON THE ON THE PROPERTY. NO SO THIS THIS TYPE OF VEHICLE, RECREATIONAL VEHICLE OR TRAILER, UM, WOULD NOT BE PERMITTED ON THERE ARE ZONING CODES AS A PRIMARY STRUCTURE OR RESIDENTS FOR RESIDENTIAL ZONED AREA. BECAUSE I MEAN, IT APPEARS THAT THE WHEELS ARE INFLATED. SO IT LOOKS LIKE IT COULD MOVE. YEAH, VERY AND IF SOMEBODY'S PARKING IT I'M TRYING. I'M TRYING TO FIND OUT JUST I'M TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT THE CODE IS BEING IS AH, PERMITTING PEOPLE TO USE THEIR PROPERTY IN A WAY THAT DOESN'T RESTRICT IT UNNECESSARILY. UNDERSTOOD FOR INSTANCE, IF YOU WERE PARKING THIS HERE TO REPAIR IT, THAT WOULD BE OKAY. CORRECT. IF THERE WAS A PRIMARY STRUCTURE THERE, SO ACTUAL, YOU KNOW, HOME, UM AND THEY HAD IT PARKED IN AND IT WAS THERE WERE BUFFERS. UM, YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY. IT'S GOING TO BE SLIGHTLY TALLER THAN A SIX FT PRIVACY FENCE. BUT IF THE INTENTION IS THERE TO PROVIDE A BUFFER, IT WOULD BE FUN. YEAH. SO YOU COULD PARK IT THERE PERMANENTLY. IF YOU HAD THAT.BUT IF YOU WERE JUST TRYING TO REPAIR IT BECAUSE THAT'S THE OWNER SAID THAT SOMEBODY WAS GOING TO TRY TO PREPARE THIS COOL. YES, THEY'RE REPAIRING IT . THEY WOULD NEED TO. IS THERE A WAY THAT YOU COULD PARK OF RECREATIONAL VEHICLE ON A VACANT PROPERTIES SO THAT YOU CAN PREPARE FOR THE PURPOSE OF REPAIRING IT. IS THERE A WAY THAT THAT COULD BE DONE UNDER THE VILLAGE CODE? NO. HAS SHE ADDRESSED ANY OF THE OTHER DEBRIS THAT'S ON THE PROPERTY? NO. ALL THE PROPERTIES STILL ARE RATHER ALL THE DEBRIS AND START THINGS THAT ARE BEING STORED.
THERE STILL THERE. SHE SAID THAT SHE WOULD MAKE AN EFFORT TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE INDIVIDUAL THAT, UM PLACED ALL THESE THINGS THERE AND HAVE THEM MAKE AN EFFORT TO ADDRESS IT, BUT THEY HAVE NOT DONE SO YET. AND WHAT'S THE PLAN FOR THE RV? UM SHE WAS MADE AWARE THAT IT COULD NOT BE, UM, STORED THERE AND MAINTAIN THEIR AND SHE SAID THAT SHE WAS GOING TO NOTIFY THEM AND HAVE THEM REMOVE IT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. HOW LONG AGO WAS THAT? UM IT'S PROBABLY BEEN ABOUT TWO WEEKS OR SO. GET SOMEONE IS GOING TO HAVE SOMEONE ALREADY PURCHASED THIS RV. SHE'S NOT THE OWNER OF YOUR SHE'S NOT THE OWNER OF THE RV. NO OWNER OF THE R B WHAT IS THERE? WHAT IS THEIR RESPONSE? UM I'M GATHERING THAT SHE'S BEEN ABLE TO MAKE CONTACT WITH THEM. I HAVEN'T I HAVEN'T HAD ANY COMMUNICATION WITH THE OWNER OF THE OF THE RV. WHOLE POINT IS, IT NEEDS TO GET MOVED AND MHM, THE OWNER, THEN WHO'S GOING TO MOVE? YEAH. SO. ALRIGHT I'M GONNA MOVE. UH, EXHIBIT ONE.
ACCEPTED EXHIBIT EXHIBIT ONE THROUGH FIVE HAS BEEN ACCEPTED IN EVIDENCE. FOR CASE NUMBER UM 22 DOT OH, 42. AH! AS FAR AS THE OUTDOOR STORAGE CODE VIOLATION. THAT IS THE R B THAT THAT IS THE VIOLATION ON THERE, NOT SOME OTHER EQUIPMENT. UM NO. SO THE RV IS GOING TO BE THE END UP PROPERTY, INOPERABLE PROPERTY, AND THEN THE OUTDOOR STORAGE IS GOING TO BE THE, UM THE DRESSER THAT'S BEING MAINTAINED THERE AND THEN THE TRASH AND DEBRIS WILL BE THE FIVE GALLON BINS THAT ARE ARE BUCKETS RATHER THAT ARE BEING STORED THERE. WALTER. I MEAN, I THINK THAT UM I THINK IT'S BETTER TO PUT THE R B UNDER UNDER THE VEHICLE SALVAGE IF IT'S NOT GOING TO IF IT'S NOT WORKING, OUTDOOR STORAGE. I DON'T KNOW IF THAT I DON'T KNOW IF THAT CODE ADDRESSES YOU KNOW , SEEING THAT THE CODE IS ALREADY ADDRESSING INOPERABLE VEHICLES THAT CODES INTENDED TO ALSO ADDRESS VEHICLE STORAGE IN THAT MANNER, AS OPPOSED TO IT LOOKS LIKE IT SAYS INOPERABLE.
MACHINES ARE WASTE EVEN THOUGH IT VEHICLE COULD BE WAITING A MACHINE. AH YEAH, IT'S REALLY
[01:30:04]
MORE INTENDED TO LOOK AT, UM YOU KNOW, WASHING MACHINES, REFRIGERATORS, THINGS LIKE UNDERSTOOD ANY OF THOSE TYPE OF APPLIANCES FARMERS KNOW I'M GONNA ORDER THAT, THOUGH. THE CODE HAS BEEN VIOLATED IN THERE , AND I WILL ISSUE AN ORDER. BUT JUST BE BE MINDFUL OF THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE CODE AND WHAT MATERIALS FIT UNDER IT. YOU KNOW, UM. IT JUST IT SEEMS LIKE A REASONABLE USE OF VACANT PROPERTY TO USE IT. AS A REPAIR AS A TEMPORARY REPAIR FOR REMOTE FOR A LARGE VEHICLES SUCH AS THIS, EVEN THOUGH THE YOU KNOW, BUT AS THE VILLAGE COACH DOESN'T ALLOW TO UNDERSTAND, BUT I THINK THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE OWNED A LOT OF PROPERTY OWNERS MADE MAYBE CONFUSED. SURPRISED BY THAT YOU MAY WANT TO AH! DO YOU MAY WANT TO HAVE THE VILLAGE KIND OF DO A AND INFORMATIONAL CAMPAIGN TO LET PEOPLE KNOW WHAT IS AND ISN'T ALLOWED ON THEIR VACANT PROBLEM. THEY'RE MAKING LOTS UNDERSTOOD SO THAT MAYBE YOU'RE NOT YOU WANT TO AS MANY OF THESE VIOLATIONS AND THAT PEOPLE CAN WORK PROACTIVELY TO GET THEIR PROPERTIES IN THE COMPLIANCE, UNDERSTOOD? OKAY? YES, SIR. UM WHAT WE'VE ACCEPTED, UM. EVERYTHING INTO EVIDENCE THAT I GUESS I JUST ASKED THAT, UM THAT AT THIS TIM, IMPOSED TO WARRANTING COMPLIANCE , UM, WITHIN THE NEXT 30 DAYS, AND IF NOT WITHIN COMPLIANCE THAT THEY'D BE REQUIRED TO PAY A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 PER VIOLATION PER DAY. UM AND THEN WE ALSO ASKED THAT 100 AND $50 MINISTRATIONS FEE BEING POSED AS THIS WAS INCURRED. UH, DOESN'T THROUGHOUT THE INVESTIGATION, AND AT THIS TIME THAT WILL CONCLUDE MY TESTIMONY. ARGUMENTS FOR IS OKAY FOR CASE NUMBER 22.OH 42. I'M GOING TO ISSUE AN ORDER VIOLATION. WITH 30 DAYS TO COMPLY. $100 A DAY IF NOT $100 A DAY AND THEN $150 ADMIN COSTS. UM. AND I UNDERSTAND ALL THE EVIDENCE HAS BEEN TAKEN IN THAT CASE AND ACCEPTED IN THE HAS BEEN ACCEPTED INTO EVIDENCE. BUT I JUST WANTED TO BE MINDFUL OF THE APPLICATION OF THE CODING AND THE EXACTITUDE, WHICH YOU KNOW, EVEN THOUGH THE CODE IS SOMEWHAT VAGUE, IN SOME WAYS, WE STILL NEED TO KIND OF PUT PEOPLE ON NOTICE ON WHAT IS GOING TO BE ON THE VIOLATION, AS OPPOSED TO KIND OF BEING AS FREE RANGING IS A CODE MAY BE SEEN TO ALLOW, UNDERSTOOD, OKAY. NEXT CASE. SO GOING ON TO TURBO 12 22 043 HAS BEEN COMPLIED. UM 13 22 044 SPEND COMPLIED. TO 14 22 045 HAS BEEN COMPLIED. WE'VE HEARD, UM TO 15 22 046 SO WE'LL BE A TAB 16 22 0. UM 47. AND SO THIS PROPERTY HERE IS, UH, REGARDING THE PROPERTY OF 14676 SOUTHWEST 169TH DRIVE. IN THE IN TOWN, FLORIDA 34956. THE OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS JOHN AND CAR. LET MCKNIGHT UM. AND AT THIS TIME I'VE YET TO BE IN CONTACT WITH JOHN AND CALL IT MIDNIGHT, BUT I'VE BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THE INDIVIDUAL THAT IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATIONS AND QUESTIONS . UM AND HE'S A GENTLEMAN IDENTIFIED AS MR BOBBY BYRD. UM HE, HE IDENTIFIED MISS JOHN AND CALL IT MCKNIGHT AS A FAMILY MEMBER. AND HAS EXPRESSED THAT HE IS. MANAGING OR MAINTAINING THE PROPERTY. UM, AND THEIR ABSENCE. UM IN MY CONVERSATIONS WITH THE VIOLATOR, MR BOBBY BYRD, UM THE VIOLATIONS CONSIST OF SOME UM, WE HAVE SOME BUILDING SERVICES PERMIT ISSUES THAT ARE STILL BEING WORKED OUT WITH REGARDS TO A FENCE THAT WAS PRIVACY FENCE THAT WAS BEING INSTALLED, UM, WITHOUT PROPER PERMITS. UM AS WELL AS AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM THAT IS BEING INSTALLED. UM THE ISSUE WITH THE IRRIGATION SYSTEM IS IT IS TIED INTO A SEPARATE METER A METER OF A NEIGHBORING PROPERTY. UM SO CURRENTLY THE VILLAGE IS WORKING WITH THE RESPONDENT, UM, TO ADDRESS THESE ISSUES, UM JUST TO GIVE YOU SOME INSIGHT ON THE PROPERTY ITSELF. IT'S A DOUBLE LOT. THAT IS VACANT. IT'S A VACANT DOUBLE LOT THAT'S BEEN
[01:35:06]
ASSIGNED AN ADDRESS. UM. AND HE'S INSTALLED A. UH, I GUESS THE PARTIAL COMPONENTS OF AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM UM, THAT IS TIED INTO A METER ON A NEIGHBORING PROPERTY, UM, ON 175TH AVENUE, SO IT'S JUST BEHIND COULD BE ADJACENT. JUST ADJACENT TO THE ACTUAL VACANT LOTS. THE OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY WITH THE METER THAT IT'S TIED INTO IS AWARE OF THIS AND IS ACTUALLY ASSISTED THE RESPONDENT IN DOING THIS UM SO CURRENTLY WHERE WE'RE WORKING ON IS NOT ONLY WOULD THE RESPONDENT BUT WITH OUR UTILITIES DEPARTMENT AND OUR BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT AND ENSURING THAT, UM NOT ONLY THE IRRIGATION SYSTEM, BUT ALSO DEFENSE IS, UM YOU KNOW , GOING THROUGH PROPER PERMITS AND THE PROPER PROCEDURES IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT EVERYTHING IS WITHIN COMPLIANCE. UM THEN WE ALSO HAVE A FEW VIOLATIONS REGARDING TRASH. UM THE MAINTENANCE OF ABANDONED, SALVAGED OR JUNK PROPERTY AND OUTDOOR STORAGE AND ALL OF THOSE FALL UNDER WE BASICALLY HAVE A SOME INOPERABLE. TRAILERS AND BOATS, UM, THAT ARE BEING MAINTAINED ON THE LOT, UM, AS WELL AS JUST SOME MISCELLANEOUS DEBRIS ON THERE'S THESE LARGE LOGS, UM, THAT ARE BEING MAINTAINED THERE. THE INTENTION THAT THE RESPONDENT HAS IS TO DEVELOP SOME SORT OF NURSERY THERE. BUT HE WAS MADE AWARE THAT PRIOR TO GOING FORWARD WITH THESE THINGS HE WOULD NEED TO APPLY. UM WITH OUR ZONING DEPARTMENT AND BUILDING SERVICES IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT THAT'S EVEN PERMITTED WITHIN THIS PRESIDENTIAL HE'S OWNED. AREA.UM NUTSHELL. WE'RE TRYING TO GET SOME ADDITIONAL TIME FOR THE RESPONDENT IN ORDER FOR HIM TO FILE THIS INFORMATION WITH OUR BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT. UM AND WE'D LIKE TO REQUEST THAT 30 DAY CONTINUANCE. AND IN ORDER TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL TIME TO COMPLY. UM. SO I GUESS YOU KNOW, 30 DAYS WILL BE SUFFICIENT TO WORK OUT THE IS THERE ANY ISSUE WITH REGARD TO THE BOUNDARIES OF THESE PROPERTIES AND WHERE THEY LAY UM, SURVEY BATTERIES LIKE THE QUESTION ABOUT THE SURVEY BOUNDARIES AND WHERE THEY ARE, AS A MATTER OF FACT, THERE IS SO THE REASON UM, WHY WE WERE EVEN LED TO THIS ISSUE WAS BECAUSE A NEIGHBORING RESIDENT HAD MADE A COMPLAINT WITH REGARDS TO A PROPERTY LINE DISPUTE THAT THEY WERE HAVING WHEN THEY WERE INSTALLING THIS PRIVACY FENCE AROUND THE VACANT LOT. SO OBVIOUSLY, WHENEVER ON A COLD STANCE WHENEVER WE HAVE A PROPERTY LINE DISPUTE OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, IT IS MORE OF A CIVIL ISSUE BETWEEN THE TWO PARTIES. BUT WE DID IDENTIFY THAT THE FENCE THAT WAS BEING INSTALLED WAS BEING DONE SO WITHOUT ANY PERMITS. OR SURVEYS. UM SO THERE IS A BIT OF A STANDSTILL. AND UM, WE'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THE SURVEY TO TAKE PLACE AND ACCORDING TO THE RESPONDENT, MR BOBBY BYRD, THAT IS IN HIS INTENTION IS TO HAVE THE PROPERTY SURVEYED, THEN GO THROUGH THE PROPER OUTLETS OF OBTAINING A VALID PERMIT. FOR THE FENCE. UH YEAH. GREAT 30 DAY CONTINUANCE. BUT I THINK YOU WANT YOU'RE GOING TO WANT TO MONITOR SOME OF THOSE OUTSIDE THINGS TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT OTHER MEMBERS, YOU KNOW OTHER NEIGHBORING OWNERS NEED TO BE EITHER PART OF THE VIOLATION ORDER. FOR THE PERMITTING PROCESS SOMETHING BECAUSE IT'S IT SOUNDS AS IF THERE'S SOME OTHER. THERE'S SOME OTHER PROPERTY RIGHTS ISSUES THAT ARE GOING ALONG HERE AND I DON'T WANT TO UNDERSTAND WHY I DON'T WANT TO SET IN STONE. ANYTHING THAT MAY HARM THE VILLAGE OR MAY HARM ONE OF THE OWNERS. VISA BE WHATEVER CLAIMS THEY MAY BE MAKING WITH REGARD TO THEIR PROBLEM. MINISTER. I'M GRANTING THE CASE GRANTED 30 DAYS IN THIS MATTER. ALRIGHT NEXT. RIGHT. WE HAVE. TO HAVE NUMBER 17 22 048 HAS BEEN COMPLIED. UM AND THEN WE'LL GO ON TO TAB 18 22 049. US CONCERNING, UM, THE PROPERTY OF THE ADDRESS OF 148 TO 6 SOUTHWEST 172ND AVENUE IN THE IN TOWN, FLORIDA 34956. THE PROPERTY OWNER HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS, UH, NORWOOD.
JOHNNY SHIELDS, UM. SO IN THIS PROPERTY HERE OF ACTUALLY BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THE
[01:40:03]
RESPONDENT AND HE'S REQUESTING ADDITIONAL TIME. UM SO THIS PROPERTY THERE WAS A RECREATIONAL VEHICLE. THAT WAS BEING MAINTAINED ON THE VACANT LOT AND, UM, OCCUPIED BY AN INDIVIDUAL LIVING WITHIN THE TRAILER. UM, SO SINCE THEN, THE RESPONDENT HAS BEEN ADVISED THAT THE TRAILER COULD NOT BE MAINTAINED ON THIS VACANT LOT ON WITHIN A RESIDENCE RESIDENTIAL HE'S OWNED. DISTRICT AND HE IS MAKING THE ARRANGEMENTS TO HAVE THIS TRAILER REMOVED. UM BUT, UM , IN OUR LAST CONVERSATION, IT'S BEEN ABOUT TWO WEEKS NOW, AND HE'S HAD WAS RECENTLY.HOSPITALIST FOR AN EXTENDED PERIOD OF TIME WHEN WE LAST SPOKE, AND HE HAD REQUESTED ADDITIONAL TIME IN ORDER TO HAVE THIS ADDRESS, SO WE'D ASK AT THIS TIME THAT IF WE COULD ATTAIN 30 DAY CONTINUANCE UM, IN ORDER TO ALLOW THE ADDITIONAL TIME TO COMPLY. SO BASICALLY, THIS IS AN ISSUE WHERE SOMEBODY IS LIVING IN A MOBILE HOME LIVING IN AN RV ON A AN EMPTY RESIDENTIAL LOT. ARE THEY WERE THERE ANY OTHER VIOLATIONS? YOU KNOW WHERE WHERE THEY PUTTING THEIR WASTE. SO THERE'S A GRAY WATER TANK WITHIN THE ACTUAL RECREATIONAL VEHICLE THAT, UM, THERE NOW, WHERE IT'S BEING DISPOSED IS, YOU KNOW NOT? WE'RE NOT ENTIRELY AWARE OF, BUT AS OF RIGHT NOW, IN OUR RECENT COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE RESPONDENT, IT IS VACATED. THERE IS NO LONGER ANYBODY IN THERE, AND IT'S JUST A MATTER OF GETTING IT OUT OF THERE. YEAH.
RIGHT BUT IT IS OPERABLE. IT DOES MOVE. YES IT IS OPE AND ITO BE RELOCATED. AT THIS TIME. WE CAN GIVE THEM 30 DAYS FOR THAT 30 DAYS FOR RELOCATION. ALL RIGHT. I MET LOOKS LIKE IT'S GOING. POKER OR THE MOST OF OUR REGULAR DOCKET. YEAH OH, FIVE. OH, COMPLIED, COMPLIED. SO NEXT WE HAVE I DO HAVE THE RESPONDENT HERE, MR CLAUDIUS TAYLOR, UM, FOR OUR SPECIAL SET. IT'S A SERIES OF THREE CASES CONCERNING UM, THREE SEPARATE, UM. VACANT LOTS OR PARCELS. THAT ARE ADJACENT TO ONE ANOTHER. AND THE CASE NUMBERS ARE 19. OH 6 19 OH, SEVEN AND 19. OH EIGHT AND AT THIS TIME, THE RESPONDENT HAS REQUESTED A MITIGATION HEARING. IN ORDER. TO MITIGATE THE FINES THAT HAVE BEEN LEVIED ON THE PROPERTY.
SO THIS, UM. THIS PROPERTY HERE GOES BACK. AH, QUITE SOME TIME. UM WE HAVE. I'M TRYING TO PULL THIS UP BECAUSE I WANNA WANNA 1ST 1ST AND FOREMOST, WAS THERE ANY IS THERE ANY PLEADING HERE? FOR THE MITIGATION, ANY WRITTEN PLEADING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, OR WAS IT DONE ALL THE ORALLY? IT WAS ALL ORALLY. SO THE ONLY THING THEY'RE LOOKING TO THE PROPERTY OWNERS SEEKING MITIGATION OF THE FINAL ORDER OF VIOLATION TAILOR 12 AND THREE YES, OKAY, AND HAS HAS BEEN RECORDED. BY THE BY THE VILLAGE. EACH OF THESE WAS ISSUED OVER ABOUT A YEAR AND A HALF AGO.
AUGUST 20TH AUGUST 18TH 2020. ALRIGHT AND NORMALLY. NORMALLY WHENEVER SOMEONE'S REQUESTING SOMETHING FROM THE MAGISTRATE. USUALLY, THAT PERSON PRESENTS THEIR MATTER. FIRST IS THAT'S BEEN THE NORMAL PRACTICE. YES, THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT. GOOD MORNING. ARE YOU MR TAYLOR? ALL RIGHT, MR TAYLOR, BEFORE WE START THE HEARING, YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN CERTAIN. IS THAT CORRECT? ALRIGHT. WERE YOU PRESENT DURING THE FINAL ORDER OF VIOLATION. ALRIGHT TRIAL THAT WAS HELD BACK IN AUGUST. 2020? NO, SIR, I WAS NOT OKAY, HAVE YOU. FROM REQUESTING THIS MITIGATION HOW YOU CAN'T YOU KNOW, I IMAGINE THAT YOU'VE CONTACTED THE VILLAGE IN REGARD
[01:45:01]
TO THIS BEFORE TO GIVE YOU SOME KIND OF FEEDBACK TO MY KNOWLEDGE OF THIS WHOLE THING. HMM. I GOT I RECEIVED THE LETTERS OF THE THERE'S SOME THE CERTIFIED LETTER THAT HE SENT BUT ALL THE PREVIOUS DOCUMENTATION THAT WAS GOING TO A DIFFERENT MELANIE ADDRESS. BECAUSE I JUST MOVED.UM MY FORMER MELON ADDRESS BECAUSE I'M RETIRED MILITARY AND I CONTACTED MR PEREZ BECAUSE I FOUND OUT ABOUT THESE VIOLATIONS. AND I'M LIKE, WELL I HAVE NOTHING ON MY PROPERTY, BUT GRASS. SO THEN. I KIND OF GOT WHEN FROM SOMEONE ELSE? OH NO, MAN, YOU NEED TO COME TO ANY TOWN AND SEE ALL THIS STUFF ON YOUR PROPERTY. SO I GO OVER AND I'M LIKE, OH, NO, THIS IS NOT HAPPENING. AND I TOOK SOME PHOTOS, THEN. I CALLED IN SOME TOW TRUCKS TO HAVE THE STUFF REMOVED, AND I WAS TOLD THAT I COULD NOT HAVE THIS PERSON'S PROPERTY REMOVED FROM MY PROPERTY. BECAUSE IT WAS NOT. THESE VEHICLES HAVE REGISTRATION . THEY'RE LIKE YOUR CAR PARKED ON MY PROPERTY. I CANNOT HAVE IT LEGALLY MOVED REMOVED. AND I SAID, OKAY. UNDERSTAND THAT SO? WORKING WITH MR PEREZ AND MY NIECE, WHICH IS PERSON IS HER TENANT. I WAS PUTTING ALL THIS STUFF ON THE PROPERTY. AFTER DOING MY DUE DILIGENCE HOMEWORK. IT WAS LIKE, OKAY, I'M FIGHTING AGAINST MYSELF TRYING TO COMPLY. BUT EVERY TIME I GET ONE STEP FORWARD, I'M TAKING FIVE STEPS BACK. BECAUSE EVERY DAY HE WOULD BRING MOIST UP. AND MR PEREZ WOULD TELL HIM TO REMOVE THE STUFF. AND I WOULD TELL HIM TO REMOVE IT. HE WILL TAKE IT, MOVE IT ACROSS THE STREET OR PUT IT IN THE RIGHT AWAY. HE SAYS. I MOVED THEN YOU WILL COME RIGHT BACK. SO THEREFORE THE CASE WAS NEVER COMPLIED. AND I WAS CAUGHT BETWEEN THE ROCK AND A HARD PLACE. THEN I STARTED TALKING TO MY LEGAL PEOPLE. THEY TOLD ME THAT I HAD EIGHT. GIVE HIM NO TRESPASSING. I HAD TO, UM, ALSO DO SOME OTHER LEGAL DOCUMENTATIONS. TO KEEP HIM OFF MY PROPERTY AND PUTTING SIGNAGE IS MR TAYLOR, DO YOU HAVE AN ATTORNEY? I HAVE A FRIEND. THAT'S AN ATTORNEY. PERSON HAS THAT PERSON REPRESENTED YOU BEFORE IN THESE PROCEEDINGS. AND THE REASON I'M ASKING. MY QUESTION IS YOU'RE HERE WITHOUT YOUR ATTORNEY ATTORNEY WOULD BE PREFERABLE TO HAVE THAT PERSON REPRESENTS MORE OF A CRIMINAL ATTORNEY. BUT HIM AND I WILL SIT DOWN AND HAVE CONVERSATIONS THAT WILL MAKE COMMON SENSE AND THE LEGAL EXPECTS OF WHAT TO DO AND WHAT NOT TO DO. ALL RIGHT. UM.
JUST TRYING TO KEEP ME OUT OF JAIL. THAT'S ALL. WELL AT THIS POINT. THIS ISN'T A THIS IS YOU UNDERSTAND? THIS ISN'T A CRIMINAL UNDERSTANDING. OKAY THIS IS A CIVIL LEGAL MATTER, BUT IT DOES INVOLVE PROPERTIES THAT YOU OWN. YES AND APPARENTLY BEING ABILITY TO KEEP THOSE PROPERTIES UP TO THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE INDIAN TOWN. YES, SIR. OKAY, SO. YOU'RE SAYING NOW THAT YOU DIDN'T RECEIVE NOTICE THAT YOUR PROPERTIES WERE IN VIOLATION. IT WAS RECEIVED BY MY NIECE. EVIDENTLY SHE GOT THE LETTER. WHERE SHE LIVING ON THE PROPERTY AT THE TIME IS WRITTEN THE PROPERTY OUT TO ATTEND. CAN I CAN I GIVE YOU SOME CLARIFICATION, SIR? JUST JUST WANNA OKAY. UNDERSTAND? ARE THESE PROPERTIES ADJACENT PROPERTIES HERE IN TIME FOR LIKE , SIDE BY SIDE FOR LOTS SIDE BY SIDE. YOU DIDN'T LIVE ON THESE PROPERTIES CORRECT THERE SINCE I WAS NINE YEARS OLD. ALRIGHT. DID YOU KNOW WHO WAS LIVING ON THE PROPERTY? NO, SIR. I DO NOT. WHY BECAUSE I'VE BEEN IN THE MILITARY OUT OF THE COUNTRY. DID YOU HAVE SOME WAY OF FIGURING OUT WHO MIGHT BE LIVING ON THE PROPERTY THAT YOU THAT'S HOW I FOUND OUT BECAUSE THE GUY THAT WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR CUTTING MY GRASS. NOTIFIED ME THAT MY NIECE MOVED AWAY FROM HER HOUSE AND TOOK ON A TENANT AND HE WAS PUTTING STUFF ON THE PROBLEM. DID YOUR NIECE HAVE PERMISSION TO BE ON THE PROCESS? YES. DID SHE HAVE A LEASE WITH NEVER SO YOU WERE JUST ALLOWING HER TO STAY THERE FOR FREE. NO THE HOUSE I GAVE HER PERMISSION TO BUILD A HOUSE ON ONE OF THE PROPHETS. SO SHE BUILT THE HOUSE . SHE LIVED IN A HOUSE BERG AND WANTS HER AND HER HUSBAND SEPARATED. THEN SHE MOVED AWAY FROM THAT HOUSE, AND SHE PUT A TENANT IN DID THE TENANT PAY HER MONEY? YES. DID SHE TAKE ANY OF THE MONEY THAT THE TENANT PAID HER? AND PUT IT TOWARDS MAKING
[01:50:07]
SURE THAT PROPERTY WAS MAINTAINED. SO. IN THE TIME THAT YOU OWN THE PROPERTY YOU'VE HAD . THERE'S ONLY ONE STRUCTURE BUILT ON IT. YES AND THAT'S HER ASSIGNED LOT. SHE BY TAX RECORD IS HER LIFE. HER LOT YOU EITHER SHE OWNS THIS LOCK OR YOU OWN THIS LOT. THAT LIFE DID YOU GIVE THAT LOT TO HER? YES. DID IS THERE DEEP TO HURT FOR THAT LOT? YES. DID SHE PAY YOU FOR THAT LOT? WHAT DOES THE DEED REFLECTED? IT WAS A GIFT. YES OKAY, SO IT SO REALLY? WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THREE LOTS THAT YOU OWN. NOT FOR. THREE GIVE HER THE FOURTH LOT AFTER THIS CAME OUT WAY BEFORE. OKAY? QUICK QUESTION TO THE VILLAGE TO THE VILLAGE. THESE THREE LOTS. THOSE ARE THE THREE LOTS THAT THAT. MR TAYLOR OWNS NOT THE LOT THAT HIS NIECE OWNS. CORRECT EXACTLY. BUT THE NIECES BUT THE TENANTS THAT THE NIECE THAT LIVE IN THE NIECES PROPERTY HAVE BEEN USING THE OTHER THREE LOTS EXACTLY. SO THAT THE LOT THAT THE NIECE OWNS IS WHERE THE PRIMARY RESIDENCES WHERE THESE TENANTS LIVE. THE LOTS THAT MR TAYLOR OWNS ARE VACANT RESIDENTIAL LOTS THAT ARE DIRECTLY ONE IS JUST ALONGSIDE IT, AND THE OTHER TWO ARE BEHIND IT. HER TENANT, DENISE'S TENANT HAS BEEN USING THE LOTS TO ILLEGALLY PARKED OR STORE VEHICLES. YES, MATERIALS WOULD HAVE YOU. YES, SIR. SO WHEN YOU DISCOVERED THIS, DID YOU RECTIFY THE VIOLATION? THAT'S WHAT I'VE BEEN DOING FOR THE LAST ALMOST TWO YEARS, THREE YEARS. SO EVEN TO THIS EXCUSE ME FOR KANYE THIS MORNING I WENT TO THE PROPERTY. I HAVE PHOTOS THAT I CAN SHOW YOU. THAT IT'S JUST MIND BLOWING. EVEN THOUGH HE HAS A NO TRESPASSING WARRANT. YOU STILL DO DOES WHAT HE WANTS, AND THEY'RE LIKE, TALK TO THE SHERIFF DEPARTMENT. THEY TELL ME THAT BEING THAT IS IN THE RIGHT.SOME OF THE STUFF IS IN THE RIGHT AWAY BECAUSE I HAVE DENIED ACCESS TO MY OWN PROPERTY. IF I WANTED TO DRIVE ONTO THE PROPERTY FROM THE FRONT SIDE. ADJACENT TO MY NIECES HOUSE. I GOT TO GO ASK HIM TO MOVE HIS STUFF. HE'S GOT THE RIGHT AWAY BLOCKED AWAY. IS ANY OF THE PROPERTY FENCED? NO, NOT YET, SIR. HAS IT EVER BEEN MARKED BEFORE? WITH SURVEY FLAGS, INDICATION SHOWING WHERE THE PROPERTY LINE? YES, SIR. SO THAT'S BEEN DONE, BUT IT HASN'T BEEN FENCED. NO, SIR. THERE'S REALLY NO MANNER THAT THERE'S NO WAY FOR YOU TO SECURE THE PROPERTY FROM SOMEONE ELSE USING IT RIGHT NOW. WE HAVE A TENTATIVE PLAN TO DO THAT ONCE WE FINISH THIS AND MITIGATION HERE, BUT AS OF THE TIME YOU KNOW THIS THIS HEARING, AND THIS ORDER WAS ISSUED BACK IN AUGUST OF 2020 OFFENSE, NO PLAN. NO OFFENSE TO THIS DATE. ALL RIGHT.
UM SO. AFTER YOU GOT THIS ORDER. WHAT DID YOU DO TO RECTIFY THE VIOLATION. FIRST I CONTACT THE LEVEL OF SERVICE. GALLERY TOWARDS SERVICE AND AARON TONE, SIR. AND I HAD TWO TRUCKS. COME OUT. AND HE CALLED THE SHERIFF. ALONG WITH HIM HOLDING A BIG STICK. ONE FLIGHT DO BODILY HARM. I SAID, OKAY, JUST MOVE. DON'T PUT IT BACK. JUST MOVE YOUR STUFF. AND ASKED WHEN HE PLACED MOST OF THE STUFF AND TO THE RIGHT AWAY. ON THANK YOU. SO 169. 100 AND UM. OBVIOUSLY SIZED FAMILIAR WITH ANY TALENT. MR CLIFFORD WILLIAMS PROPERTY, HE PUT STUFF ON THE BACK SIDE OF HIS PROPERTY AND THE RIGHT AWAY. ACROSS THE STREET, THEN ON 1, 60 OR 70. HE PUT STUFF IN THE RIGHT WAY TO MIDNIGHT PROPERTY. BUT HE WAS JUST DISCUSSING WITH MR BIRD. SO HE'S GOT STUFF SCATTERED ALL OVER TO EVERYBODY'S PROBLEM. FILL ME PERSONALLY, I'M LIKE, OKAY, PLEASE DO NOT PUT YOUR STUFF HERE NO MORE. I CUT THE GRASS MAKE IT LOOK NICE AND PRETTY.
AND I CONTACTED MR PEREZ HIM AND THAT KINDA AND SOME OTHER SMALL STUFF THAT NEEDED TO BE CORRECTED. BECAUSE HE HAD TOWERS AND YOU NAME IT. IT WAS ALL THERE SO AND I'M PAYING PEOPLE TO DISPOSE OF HISTORY. THAT I CAN LEGALLY DISPOSED OF. SO WHAT DO YOU WHAT DID YOU WHAT ARE YOU TRYING TO DO HERE TODAY? I'M TRYING TO GET THE LEAVES AND THE FINES OF RESCINDED. THAT WAY. I
[01:55:04]
CAN BUILD SOME AFFORDABLE HOUSING AT ANY TIME. THAT WAY. HE CAN'T PUT NOTHING ON THE PROBLEM. WE HAVE PROPOSED YOUR HONOR. NOW THIS MOMENT, LET ME LET ME READ.HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT I'M I'M COMING TO THIS FRESH. YES SIR. I'M READING THROUGH THE ORDERS AND I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT ON THE ORDERS OF VIOLATION. WHAT'S THERE? WHAT ISN'T THERE? AND THEN WHEN YOU SAY THAT YOU WANT YOU WANT TO MITIGATE THEM? YOU WANT ME TO UNDO ALL THE FINES UNDER ALL THE LEANS BUT IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE YOU PARTICIPATED IN THE HEARING. OR IN. YOU IN THE MINIMUM OF AT LEAST PUTTING UP A FENCE TO PREVENT LEADS AND FIND THINGS FOR HAPPENING IN THE FUTURE. SO I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT MIGHT BE THE FAIREST THING TO DO HERE. BUNCH OF PHOTOS IF YOU WANT TO CAN'T THAT'S NOT EVIDENCE. IF YOU HAD PRINTED THEM OUT AND PRESENTED THEM TO MR PEREZ. THANK YOU PROBABLY GOT ALL THE SAME PHOTOS. I AGAIN THIS, YOU KNOW. WHERE AM I GOING TO PUT THAT IN THE RECORD? HOW HOW AM I GONNA HOW AM I GOING TO PRESERVE THAT FOR THE PEOPLE TO COME BEHIND ME SO THEY CAN SEE THAT? YES SIR. I UNDERSTAND.
THAT'S WHAT EVIDENCE IS. EVIDENCE IS UNDERSTAND WHAT HAPPENED. YOU KNOW, I WOULD LOVE TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT. BUT THAT'S NOT I CAN'T. I CAN'T DO THAT. FROM THE DEAD. THAT THE PRESENTED TO ME IN A DIFFERENT WAY. NOT A PROBLEM, SIR. HAS ALL THE TRASH AND RUBBISH BEEN REMOVED FROM THE PROPERTY. YES, SIR. AND ALL THE VEHICLES HAVE BEEN REMOVED. ALL THIS STUFF HAS BEEN REMOVED OTHER THAN STUFF HE'S GOT THERE THIS MORNING, BUT IT'S ON MY NIECES PROPERTY. IS IT ON YOUR PROPERTY? MAYBE ONE OR TWO TIRES WHERE HE HE'S GOT A TRAILER. THAT'S GOT STUFF ON IT, BUT HE DROVE THROUGH MY PROPERTY TO GET TO HIS PROPERTY. SO THEREFORE THAT THE TRAILER IF WE GO RIGHT DOWN THE PROPERTY LINE, THE TRAILER IS THERE. BUT I'M QUITE SURE BY NOW IT'S PROBABLY GONE. BECAUSE HE MOVED EVERY DAY. MHM YOU'RE TRYING TO ASK ME FOR MITIGATION, BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE THERE'S STILL SOME VIOLATIONS GOING ON. SO THAT'S HARDER FOR ME. I'M TRYING TO I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND. SPORT. THAT'S WHY I WANTED TO SHOW YOU THE PHOTOS OF WHAT HE'S GOT WHAT I SAW THIS MORNING. OKAY? BUT WHAT HE'S GOT THIS MORNING AGAIN . 99.9% OF EVERYTHING ELSE HAS BEEN COMPLIED. WELL, THERE'S NO TRASH. NO, SIR. FAR AS A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. WHO'S RUNNING A BUSINESS OFF THE PROPERTY? NO ONE THAT I KNOW OF THE TENANT THAT'S OPERATING THERE WAS SCRAPPING. AND THAT'S THE HOME OCCUPATION IS BEING CONDUCTED THERE. SO HE WAS SCRAPPING ON THE PROPERTY THAT HE WASN'T LIVING ON SCRAPPING ON THE PROPERTY. THAT MR TAYLOR YEAH. YEAH. GAME IS IT POSSIBLE TO GET A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT FOR THAT? NO BUSINESS THERE. SO IS THIS VIOLATION. AND I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND. VIOLATION TO VIOLATION 12 AND THREE DOES.
WHAT I DON'T HAVE IS I DON'T HAVE ANY PHOTOGRAPHIC OR. I DON'T HAVE A AN EXHIBIT THAT SHOWS ME WHERE THESE PROPERTIES ARE, HOW THEIR RELATION TO EACH OTHER HOW THEY LOOK. HMM I'VE GOT TO GO ON WHATEVER IS DESCRIBED HERE, WHICH IS DIFFICULT. LEONOR IT'S OKAY WITH MR PEREZ. I GOT A LOT OF PHOTOS THAT DEPICT THE WHOLE PICTURE FROM THE PROPERTY THAT WAY. YOU KNOW YOU DON'T HAVE A CLEAR UNDERSTANDING. IF YOU JUST WANT TO SEE IT FOR THE UNDERSTANDING PURCHASES. UM I'M TRYING TO GET THE VILLAGE TO TELL ME WHAT THAT IS, RATHER THAN THE RESPONDENT BECAUSE I WANT THE VILLAGE TO SURE ITS CASE I HAVE A SERIES OF DEPICTIONS, UM, FROM UM. WHEN THIS CASE WAS INITIALLY BROUGHT TO HEARING AND WE OBTAINED A FINAL ORDER. UM. I CAN. I COULD PRESENT YOU THE DEPICTIONS THAT WERE TAKEN AT THAT TIME THAT REFLECT WHAT THE ISSUES WERE THAT ACTUALLY, I'D RATHER I'D RATHER HEAR WHAT WHAT REMAINS FROM COMPLAINT FROM A COMPLIANCE. OKAY, SO I MEAN WITH REGARDS TO MR CLAUDIUS IS, UM, PROPERTY. I WOULD SAY THAT. WHAR
[02:00:15]
CLAUDIUS HAS PUT UP. NOT ONLY IS HE HAVE THE TRESPASS ORDER, BUT HE'S PUT UP SIGNAGE, UM, IN AN EFFORT TO DETER, UM, THE. THE TENANT ON THE FROM THE PROPERTY FROM PARKING OR MAINTAINING ANYTHING ON HIS, UM, THREE PARCELS THERE AND I MEAN, WITH THE EXCEPTION I DIDN'T GET A CHANCE TO GO OUT THERE THIS MORNING. BUT AS OF MORE RECENTLY IT'S BEEN MAINTAINED. AND I THINK A LARGE PART OF IT HAS TO DO WITH THE COMMUNICATIONS THAT MR TAYLOR'S HAD WITH THE TENANT.UM AND MAKING SURE THAT HE'S NOT MAINTAINING ANY INOPERABLE EQUIPMENT OR VEHICLES OR ANY TRASH ON THE LOT. THE CONCERN. I KNOW IS THAT, UM AND LURE OF HIM TAKING THE STEPS OF EITHER FENCING IN THE PROPERTY OR DEVELOPING IT IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT THIS IS NO LONGER HAPPENING . UM WHAT IS THE TENANT GOING TO BE DOING? IS HE IS HE GONNA YOU KNOW? ARE WE GOING TO GO BACK TO NONCOMPLIANCE? UM AFTER THIS MITIGATION HEARING, SO I KNOW THAT, UM THE RESPONDENT MR TAYLOR WAS EXPRESSED. I DID EXPRESS THAT TO HIM AND UM, HIS INTENTIONS. I BELIEVE, EVEN PRIOR TO THE HEARING. HE'S BEEN SUBMITTING PLANS AND TO OUR UM BUILDING SERVICES AND ZONING DEPARTMENT FOR REVIEW. UM IN ORDER TO GET THESE PROCESSES ROLLING AS SOON AS POSSIBLE, BUT THE THING IS, SOME OF THESE APPLICATIONS REQUIRE, UM THAT THERE ISN'T AN OUTSTANDING FINE OR LIEN ON THE PROPERTY IN ORDER FOR HIM TO BE PERMITTED TO DO ANYTHING WITH REGARDS TO DEVELOPING THE LOTS. UM. BUT WHAT IS THE AMOUNT OF THE FINE OUTSTANDING FROM THESE THREE ORDERS OF VIOLATION SO THAT THE AMOUNT OUTSTANDING, UM PER PER PARCEL IS, UM. GOING TO BE JUST WITH REGARDS TO THE VIOLATIONS, NOT INCLUDING ADMINISTRATIVE FEES WOULD BE $212,400 PER.
PROPERTY FOR A GRAND TOTAL. OF $637,200. AND THAT'S IN JUST, UM VIOLATION FINES AND THEN AN ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS. UM, IT'S. GOING TO BE A TOTAL OF $250 PER PROPERTY FOR A GRAND TOTAL OF $750 AND ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS. AND WHEN THIS VIOLATION THE FINAL ORDER WAS RECORDED. IT WAE HAD. WE HAD A SET OF THREE VIOLATIONS, SO IT WAS A RUNNING FINE OF $300 PER DAY. FOR VIOLATION. SO THE TOTAL FINALS IS SITUATED A. AT LEAST, IS JUST FOR THE PLANS THEMSELVES. $637,200 YES, SIR. AND RUNNING. YES, SIR. AND RUNNING TODAY. ANY OF THOSE FINES BEEN PAID? NO. YOU SAID $750 AND ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS. YES, SIR.
[02:06:16]
MR PEREZ. I SEE AND I SEE THE INITIAL ORDER WAS ISSUED IN JANUARY. THE INITIAL ORDER OF VIOLATIONS ISSUED IN JANUARY, 2020 AND THEN THE FINAL ORDER VIOLATION IN GERMANY IN AUGUST OF 2020 REASON THAT THE VILLAGE HAS NOT TAKEN STEPS TO FORECLOSE ON THE PROCESS. UM SO WE DID. WE DID SEND A LETTER. FROM OUR ATTORNEY. WITH THE INTENTION OF OR FORECLOSING IF COMPLIANCE COULD NOT BE FACILITATED AND THE NOTICE WAS SENT FROM OUR ATTORNEY OF VOTES LAW FIRM. UM AND IT WAS SENT CERTIFIED MAIL TO MR TAYLOR. UM AND THIS IS WITH REGARDS TO ALL THREE LOTS.SO THERE WAS AN INTENTION. THE VILLAGES CONCERN WAS JUST ENSURING THAT YOU KNOW THE RESPONDENT WAS GIVEN AMPLE TIME TO COMPLY PRIOR TO TAKING SUCH A DRASTIC. UM STEP AND FORECLOSING ON THE PROPERTY. UM AND I DO KNOW SHORTLY THEREAFTER RECEIVING THE NOTICE FROM OUR LAW FIRM, UM REPRESENT OR RATHER OUR ATTORNEY, UM MR CLAUDIUS DID TAKE THE MEASURES AND ATTAINED.
THAT'S WHEN HE ATTAINED HIS TRUST. NO TRESPASS ORDER. AGAINST THE ACTUAL TENANT WHO HAS BEEN REALLY THE PRIMARY ISSUE HERE. UM IT'S VERY YOU KNOW, I UNDERSTAND THAT MR CLAUDIUS LIVES OUTSIDE OF INDIAN TOWN, SO HE DOES FREQUENT THE AREA QUITE OFTEN, AND I DO SEE HIM WITHIN THE COMMUNITY VERY OFTEN VISITING THE PROPERTY CHINA ENSURE THAT IT'S WITHIN COMPLIANCE. AND WE'VE ALSO BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THE LOCAL SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT WHO'S BEEN TO THE PROPERTY SEVERAL TIMES. UM TO ADDRESS THE TENANT THAT'S BEEN AN ISSUE. UM SO THERE HAVE BEEN A SERIES OF MEASURES TAKEN. UM, I MEAN, I'M NOT SURE IF YOU'D LIKE THE VILLAGERS POSITION OR WHAT? WE WOULDN'T YOU KNOW, REQUEST IN THIS IN THIS MATTER, UM. I WOULD. BUT BEFORE BEFORE THAT I WANT TO. I WANT TO GET SOME THINGS FROM MR CLAUDIUS. YEAH TAYLOR, YOU SAY YOU WEREN'T NOTIFIED OF THIS. INFORMATION ABOUT THE VIOLATIONS BECAUSE YOU WERE IN THE MILITARY. I'M STILL CURRENTLY A VERY ACTIVE PERSON IN THE MILITARY. ARE YOU ON ACTIVE DUTY, SIR? I'M HAVE YOU ARE YOU STILL ACTIVE DUTY IN THE MILITARY? YOU RETIRED FROM THE MILITARY? YES, SIR. DID YOU I ACTUALLY RETIRED IN 2000 AND FIVE BUT DID NOT CAME A D O D CIVILIAN. AND I WAS OVERSEAS UNTIL 2000 AND SIX. SO. HAPPENED IN 2020. BUT BEING THAT AFTER THAT DID NOT VISIT INDIAN TOWN BECAUSE I WAS IN STUART HELPING MY MOTHER AND FATHER RUN. THERE ARE 6.5 ACRES OVER IN STUART. TWO VERILY DID COME TO INDIAN TOWN AND MY ADDRESS OF MY OFFICIAL ADDRESS IS A POST OFFICE BOX. BECAUSE OF MY MILITARY AFFILIATION. DID YOUR NIECE MY NIECE OF ANYTHING? MY NIECE CAR LETTER. WHICH MR PEREZ IS VERY FAMILIAR WITH. SHE WAS RECEIVING A LOT OF THE CORRESPONDENCE, AND SHE DID NOT NOTIFY ME OF ANYTHING. YOU KNOW TO BOOT IF SHE RECEIVED THE CORRESPONDENT DIDN'T NOTIFY ANYBODY THAT SHE DO ANYTHING.
NO, SIR. SHE DID NOT. JUST SO HAPPENED WHEN I CAME OUT TO CUT THE GRASS. I KNOW TO DEAL WITH SOME ISSUES WITH HER HOUSE, AND I TOLD HER I SAID, WELL, LOOK, I WILL FIX THEM. YOU JUST GOT TO PAY FOR THE MATERIALS. I'LL PULL A PERMIT. I DO EVERYTHING AND THEN THE SAME DISCUSSION WITH MR
[02:10:05]
PEREZ. AFTER LEAVING GOING THROUGH THIS BACK AND FORTH FOR A DAY OR TWO. I'M LIKE. I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY SHE WON'T GET RID OF THE TENNIS. I SORT OF IT REQUIRES ME PAYING FOR HIM TO BE EVICTED. I'M WILLING TO SACRIFICE TO DO THAT. BUT SHE REFUSED. IS THERE A REASON THAT THE TENANT NEITHER THE TENANT NOR YOUR NIECE THEIR REASON THAT THEY HAVE BEEN ISSUE VIOLATIONS . THEY HAVE THE SO RIGHT NOW, WITH OUR CODE PROCESSES. WE DON'T HAVE THE MEANS OF TAKING PUNITIVE ACTION AGAINST A TENANT PER SE. BUT MISS CARLOTTA WOODY , WHO'S MR TAYLOR'S, UM NIECE WAS ALSO ISSUED A NOTICE OF VIOLATION. AT THE SAME TIME, WE ACTUALLY HAVE A OUTSTANDING LIEN THAT'S HAS FINDS ROLLING ON THIS PROPERTY. UM BUT AS A RESULT OF THE ORDERS THAT HE'S GOTTEN IN THE STEPS HE'S TAKEN ALL OF THE DEBRIS HAS NOW BEEN CONDENSED. TO MISS WOODY'S LOT. UM INSTEAD OF, YOU KNOW, SPREAD OUT AS IT WAS, UM, PRIOR TO SO. VILLAGE. HAVE A POSITION ON THE ON THIS FINE AND IN THIS MATTER, BECAUSE WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE IT SOUNDS LIKE FOR THE MOST PART, THIS PROPERTY IS IN COMPLIANCE. YEAH. AND IT SOUNDS LIKE THERE'S A DIFFICULTY WITH LOCATING BOTH THE OWNERS, TENANTS AND THOSE RESPONSIBLE AND MAKING THEM ACT RESPONSIBLE. YEAH I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE SURE WE DO IS I'D LIKE TO MAKE SURE THAT WHOMEVER HAS FINES AND JUDGMENTS LEVIED AGAINST THEM. THAT THOSE ARE THE MOST RESPONSIBLE PARTIES FOR THE ACTIVITY THAT TOOK PLACE THAT LED TO DID NOT COMPLIANCE. MHM SOUNDS LIKE MR TAYLOR HAS DONE A LOT. YOU KNOW HE WASN'T AS VIGILANT AS HE MAY HAVE OTHERWISE SHOOT. HE'S DONE QUITE A BIT TO TRY TO MAKE THE OTHER PORTIONS OF THE PROPERTY COME INTO COMPLIANCE. SO MY QUESTION FROM THE VILLAGES DO THEY HAVE A RECOMMENDATION WITH REGARD TO THE FINES AND ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS? THEY MIGHT BE WILLING TO ACCEPT. TO MITIGATE THIS. UM I'D SAY OUR POSITION AND THIS IS SOMETHING THAT, UM, WE'VE DONE IN THE PAST WITH REGARDS TO SITUATIONS THAT ARE VERY SIMILAR TO MR TAYLOR'S, UM, WE WOULD LIKE TO COLLECT THE ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS PORTION OF THE $750. UM WHAT WE'VE DONE IN THE PAST, THOUGH, IS WE'VE LEVIED IN ORDER. UM OR THE ORDER OF OR RATHER, WE'VE HAD OUR MAGISTRATES IN THE PAST, 11 ORDERED TO VACATE. WHERE THERE'S A STIPULATION. WHERE IF THE VIOLATIONS WHERE. TO OCCUR AGAIN WITHIN A SIX MONTH CALENDAR PERIOD. UM WE COULD IN TURN, LEVY A FINE OF $1000. HER PROPERTY. UM. THAT'S THAT'S AN IN VIOLATION. SO UM UM YEAH. SO IN RATHER LET ME. IT WAS IT WOULD, IT WOULD BE AT THAT PRIOR ENGAGEMENT. IT WAS $500 PER VIOLATION. SO IN THIS CASE, IT'S THREE VIOLATIONS BECAUSE IT'S A $300 COSTS. UM THAT'S ROLLING RIGHT NOW. SO LET'S SAY WE WENT BECAUSE WE COULD ONLY GO AS HIGH AS THE $500 FEE. SO THE 500 PER VIOLATION PER DAY WHICH WOULD BE $1500 PER DAY. PER PROPERTY PER DAY IN IN THIS IS THIS IS WHAT THE VILLAGE MIGHT BE WILLING TO DO. IF THE IF, IF I MAKE HATED THE ORDER THAT INCLUDES THE FINDS THAT YES, OF THE 700 TO ALMOST $700,000. YES IF MR TAYLOR DOES NOT HAVE THE SITUATION REMEDIED WITHIN SIX MONTHS. IN THE VILLAGE CAN COME IN AND LEVY A FINE AND IMPOSED A FINE ON EACH PROPERTY PER DAY. $1500 FOR A 4005 TOTAL OF $4500 PER DAY. YEAH SHOULD MR TAYLOR NOT HAVE THE SITUATION REMEDIED IN THE FASHION THAT'S ENVISIONED WITHIN EXACTLY AND WITHIN, IT WOULD BE WITHIN SIX MONTHS. SO UPON THE SIX MONTH THAT THE DAY UM, THE. SO LONG AS IT'S WITHIN COMPLIANCE THAN THE ORDER WOULD BE VACATED IN ITS ENTIRETY, SO THERE WOULD BE UM YOU KNOW, NO,[02:15:02]
NO VIOLATION, AND ALL WE WOULD BE WARRANTING IS THE COLLECTION OF THE MINISTRY OF COSTS, ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS BE TOLD AND TOTAL. IT'S $750 BECAUSE WE HAVE $75 PER CASE WHEN IT WAS INITIALLY BROUGHT TO HEARING AND THEN OUR ADMINISTRATIVE COURSE FOR WHEN IT WAS CERTIFIED OF $175. PER CASE, SO IT COMES OUT. ABOUT $250. UM FOR EACH ALL THREE, ADDING UP TO A GRAND TOTAL OF 7 50. AND SO, BASICALLY SIX MONTHS. I MEAN, I COULD TRY TO LOOK AT THE CALENDAR FROM TODAY'S HEARING. I CAN. I CAN CALCULATE THAT. OKAY LETS YOU KNOW BECAUSE I UNDERSTAND THAT, MR TAYLOR. LOOK MR TAYLOR, I UNDERSTAND THAT YOU'VE HAD SOME DIFFICULTY. YOU'VE BEEN A LITTLE BIT ABSENTEE. AND YOU'VE HAD AND YOU'VE BEEN TRYING TO DEAL WITH ATTENDANCE SITUATION WHAT WAS FORMERLY A SHARED INTERESTS AND SHARED LAND SITUATION. I'M PRESUMING THAT. YOU HAD FOUR LOTS. YOU DECIDED TO GIVE A LOT OF WEIGHT TO YOUR NIECE. YOU NEED TO RINSE IT OUT AND SOMEBODY THAT DESTRUCTIVE GIVE ME FOR CUTTING YOU OFF ME THERE IN THE MILITARY AND MY FATHER AND YOU PROBABLY KNOW HIM. MR TAYLOR BEFORE HE PASSED AWAY. HE INSTRUCTED ME THAT HE WAS MY NIECE WANTED TO BUILD A HOUSE BECAUSE SHE GOT MARRIED. SO I SAID, OKAY, AND AT THE TIME, I WAS PROBABLY IN KOREA SOMEWHERE, HE SAYS. GIVE IT ONE OF THOSE LOTS. SO I WENT TO MY MILITARY.JACK HAD HIM DRAW UP TO CLAIM D. SIGN IT TO HIM. CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR MARRIAGE. YEAH AND THAT'S AND THAT'S FINE. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I'M ALWAYS CONCERNED ABOUT IS I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THE WAY THAT PROPERTIES CAN THE WAY THAT PROPERTY IS BOTH HELD. THE WAY THAT PROPERTY IS CONVEYED IN THE RIGHTS THAT PEOPLE HOLD BECAUSE PROPERTY IS PARAMOUNT IN OUR CULTURE, PARAMOUNT UNDER OUR LEGAL SYSTEM. EVERY RIGHT. YOU HAVE DERIVED FROM THE. YES SIR.
SO WHEN I'M DETERMINING ON WHAT TO DO IN THIS MATTER, I'M TRYING TO DETERMINE WHAT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS ARE THE PEOPLE INVOLVED AND THEN PUT THEIR OBLIGATIONS ARE TO HAVE TO THAT PROPERTY WITHIN THE LOCATION THAT THEY'RE LIVING. FOR INSTANCE, THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN YOU HAVE NOT JUST YOU HAVE A PROPERTY RIGHT? YOU HAVE A PROPERTY OWNER, WHICH ALSO HAVE ANOTHER OBLIGATION. TWO. USE THAT PROPERTY IN A WAY IN A MANNER THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CODES OF THE VILLAGE. SO THAT WHEN YOU'RE NOT USING YOUR PROPERTY IN THAT MANNER THE VILLAGE THEN HAS AN OPPORTUNITY HAS ITS OWN OBLIGATION TO ITS CITIZENRY TO ENFORCE THE CODE CHOSEN TO ENFORCE THE CODE IS BY SEEKING COMPLIANCE. SICILY BY BEING PUNITIVE, NOT FROM REMOVING PEOPLE FROM THE PROPERTY, REMOVING THINGS FROM THE PROPERTY BUT ASKING THE PROPERTY OWNER TO BRING THEIR PROPERTY IN THE COMPLIANCE WITH THE VILLAGE CODE. SO THE VILLAGE CAN KEEP IN A CERTAIN AESTHETIC, ESPECIALLY IN ITS RESIDENTIAL AREAS. RURAL AREA. THIS ISN'T A FARM AREA. SO THE CONCEPT OF SOMEONE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA HAVING AN AUTO JUNKYARD IS SALVAGE YARD NEXT DOOR TO THEM. DOESN'T MAKE MUCH SENSE FOR THOSE WHO PAID TO BE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA. THEY PAID TO BE IN AN INDUSTRIAL AREA. THEY CAN'T COMPLAIN THEY PAID TO BE IN A RURAL AREA. THEY CAN COMPLAIN WITH THEIR COMPLAINTS ARE LESS IF YOU PAID TO BE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA IN THE VILLAGES SET THAT UP AS A RESIDENTIAL AREA. THEN YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE THOSE COMPETING USES IN THAT AREA. DESTROY THE NATURE OF THAT AREA. PEOPLE WANT TO HAVE FAMILIES, CHILDREN, THOSE THINGS UNFORTUNATELY, A CELL AN AUTO SALVAGE YARD PRODUCED PRESENTS SOMEWHAT OF A NUISANCE IN A RESIDENTIAL. YES. NEW SUSANNA HAZARD SO IN THIS INSTANCE. I THINK THAT. BASED ON YOUR APPEARANCE HERE TODAY. YOUR TESTIMONY. THE TESTIMONY GIVEN BY THE VILLAGE. I THINK IT'S SENSIBLE THAT WE DON'T IMPOSE A FINE OF $637,200 IN THIS MATTER.
IN THAT WE DO VACATE THAT FINE. AND VACATE THE ORDERS THAT LED TO THOSE FINES. BUT THAT ANOTHER ORDER WILL BE IMPOSED. THAT DEFINE ITSELF HAS BEEN RAISED FROM $100 PER INCIDENT TO $500 PER INCIDENT PER DAY. IT WILL BE IMPOSED UPON THE PROPERTY. IF ALL OF THE VIOLATIONS HAVE NOT BEEN CORRECTED. WITHIN SIX MONTHS. 180 DAYS FROM TODAY. YES, SIR. OKAY THAT'S GOING TO PUT A BURDEN ON YOU TO GET THAT CORRECTED OR OTHERWISE. THESE FINES ARE GOING TO COME BACK AND THEY'RE GONNA BE HARDER AND BIGGER. UNDERSTAND. OKAY? NOW NORMALLY BECAUSE THE
[02:20:01]
MUNICIPALITY NORMALLY THE MUNICIPALITY WOULD FIGHT TO ENSURE THAT IT COULD COLLECT THOSE FINES. AND IT HAS A RIGHT RIGHT NOW BEFORE CLOSING YOUR PROPERTY, SELL IT AND TRY AND GET AS MUCH AS THAT 610,000 AS IT POSSIBLY CAN. YES, SIR. OKAY, SO IF I'M BY FACT, BY THE FACT THAT I'M GOING TO ORDER THAT THOSE ORDERS BE VACATED. I'M TAKING AWAY A POWERFUL STICK.FROM THEIR ENFORCEMENT CAPABILITY, AND I'M BASICALLY. COMING IN ON YOUR SIDE AGAINST THEM. AND SAYING WE WANT TO WORK THIS TOGETHER, BUT I'M TAKING AWAY AWAY SOMETHING THEY HAVE THAT THEY COULD THEY COULD IMPOSE. THEY COULD USE THE HAMMER YOU WITH EVERY DAY. TO BUY YOU NO LONGER ON THE PROPERTY. OKAY SO BY DOING THIS, I WANT YOU TO UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH OF A BREAK. THIS IS UNDERSTAND THAT EVEN THOUGH YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE A LARGER FINE IMPOSED IT'S ONLY GOING TO BE IMPOSED. IF YOU DON'T BRING THE PROPERTY INTO COMPLIANCE.
THAT THE FINE WAS ALREADY IMPOSED AND THAT SHOULD BE IMPOSED. I'M GOING TO VACATED.
UNDERSTAND THAT, SIR? SO THAT MEANS THAT FOR EACH ONE OF THESE ORDERS I AM GIVING THIS IS THE THIS IS THE MATCH FOR GIVING YOU A BREAK. UNDERSTAND THAT HUGE BREAK. THAT. BECAUSE THEN I'M GIVING YOU BECAUSE THE VILLAGE HAS ASKED FOR IT BECAUSE THE VILLAGES WORKED WITH YOU AND THE VILLAGE UNDERSTANDS WHERE YOUR PROBLEM IS AND WHAT THE REAL PROBLEM IS WORKING TO MAKE THAT.
CLIENT RATHER THAN PURE. I'VE WORKED AT OTHER PALETTE EASE. COUNTIES AND OTHER GOVERNMENTS WHERE THE PEOPLE ARE NOT AS GENEROUS AND THEY WANT TO BE PUNITIVE. YES, SIR. UNDERSTAND THAT. WILL COMPLY THIS UNDERSTAND IT IN SIX MONTHS IF YOU DON'T HAVE THIS COMPLIED. I DON'T THINK THERE'S GOING TO BE ANY PROBLEM WITH THEM IMPOSING THE FINE OF $1500 A DAY.
BASICALLY, YOU KNOW $1500 PER PROPERTY PER PER VIOLATION. THESE VIOLATIONS ARE STILL THERE . THAT'S GOING TO BE $4500 A DAY EVERY DAY. THAT'S A LOT. I UNDERSTAND, SIR. LOT TO ADD UP TO THE 637,000. THAT WE'RE NOW WIPING OFF THE BOOKS. ALL RIGHT. BUT I DON'T THINK WE'RE GOING TO BE AS INCLINED TO WIPE THE 4500 OFF THE BOOKS. IF THAT GETS IMPOSED. RIGHT? MILITARY, NO MILITARY TIME IN NO TIME. PART OF THE REASON THAT I'M REALLY MORE WILLING TO DO THIS IS BECAUSE THERE MAY BE SOME NOTICE ISSUES HERE. BECAUSE YOU. CHANGE THE ADDRESSES, AND IT'S POSSIBLE THAT YOU DID NOT RECEIVE PROPER NOTICE. POSSIBLE THAT THE PROPERTY OWNER OF THE PROPERTIES OF VIOLATION POSSIBLE. THERE WAS A NOTICE ISSUE. I FELT THAT THERE WASN'T A NOTICE ISSUE I MIGHT NOT FEEL IS INCLINED TO BE AS GENEROUS. BECAUSE IF YOU WERE NOTIFIED ABOUT THIS, AND YOU KNEW ABOUT AND DID NOTHING. LITTLE HARD FOR ME TO JUSTIFY TAKING A STEP ON TAKING SURE.
OKAY? SO. MR PEREZ. I THINK YOU RECOMMENDATIONS GONNA BE TAKEN TO VACATE THESE ORDERS IN IT IMPLEMENT A NEW ORDER STATING THAT UH, COMPLIANCE MUST OCCUR WITHIN SIX MONTHS. OR. THAT THE ORDER DEFINE OF $1500 PER DAY PER VIOLATION PER PROPERTY WILL BE IMPOSED. AND UH, MR TAYLOR, YOU STILL HAVE TO PAY THE ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS. OF $750 THAT WILL BE IMPOSED TODAY. OKAY THAT'S IMPOSED RIGHT NOW. TODAY YOU STILL NEED TO PAY THOSE COSTS. YES FOR THE OTHER FINES.
IF THE PROPERTY IS COMPLETELY CORRECTED IN SIX MONTHS. THEY CAN BE WITH ALRIGHT. OKAY, PROMISE. ALL RIGHT. THAT A GOOD GOOD RESULT. THANK YOU, MR PEREZ. THANK MR TAYLOR. MR PRESIDENT. TAKE ME A DAY OR TWO TO WRITE THAT UP. SO I WOULD HAVE TO WAIT. AFTER HE FINISHES OLDER. MY CURRENT ADDRESS IS WHAT 26 WHAT. JUST REMEMBER MR TAYLOR AFTER TODAY. THERE'S NO NOT NOT GONNA BE ANY EXCUSES ABOUT NOT HAVING NOT HAVING NOTICED. AND I FOUND OUT I KNOW , I KNOW. THAT'S WHY THAT'S WHY I WAS WILLING TO DO THIS. BUT IF YOU IF YOU KNOW ABOUT NOW THAT YOU KNOW ABOUT THIS, I'M A MILITARY GUY. FOLLOW ORDERS. DON'T YOU GET YOU GOT TO MAKE
[02:25:03]
SURE THAT I GOT I GOT YOUR BLUE AND OUR GUYS GOT A UTI. AVENUE. COURSE I'M LUCY 34953. ALRIGHT, SO THEN I'LL MAIL IT OFF AND THEN THE WAY THAT THAT ORDER WORK. POINTS. TO THE.QUESTION. WAR. I COULD TALK WITH FEAR AND LOWER MEANS ABOUT. CONCRETE WALL AROUND THE WHOLE.
ALREADY SAID. AND YOU CAN GO THROUGH OUR BUILDING SERVICES DEPARTMENT. IF YOU WANT TO FOLLOW YOUR YOUR PERMANENT LIGATION. ARE. THAT WAS THE LAST MATTER FREE HERE, SO I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS IS AN OFF THE RECORD DISCUSSION. THE RECORDS. ALL RIGHT. SO YOU DON'T WANT ME TO CONSIDER THIS? YEAH. NO, NO. IF YOU WANT TO THINK WE'RE DONE IF YOU WANT, OKAY, THIS LET'S LET ME LET ME ADJOURN THE MEETING AND THEN YOU ALL CAN CONTINUE. OKAY ALRIGHT. SO UH, MEETING FOR THE MEANING FOR VILLAGE INDIAN TOWN SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOR APRIL 19TH 2022.
WE CONCLUDED TODAY AND
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.