Mar 03, 2022 Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board

[00:00:01]

SORRY. WE HAVE ACCOUNT TO ORDER MY PC, A BOARD MEETING. OH, MY SORRY. WE'RE CALLING ME TO ORDER

[CALL TO ORDER]

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE, PLEASE. OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION. UNDER GUARD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. APPROVAL OF AGENDA. CHAIR. STAFF WOULD REQUEST THAT. IN APPROVING THE AGENDA THAT ITEMS THREE AND FOUR

[APPROVAL OF AGENDA ]

[APPROVAL OF MINUTES]

YES. FOR MEMBERS TO HAYEK. YES. REMEMBER WILLIAMS? YES. VICE CHAIR. MILEY YES, PALMER. YES.

OKAY? SO I SPENT MOVED IN SECOND. SO WE'RE GOING TO PROCEED TO ITEMS FOR. ITEM 553

[5.  

Application No. LDR-21-8122 - A request to Amend the Village of Indiantown Land Development Regulations to Establish an Efficient Process for the Review and Approval of Special Event Applications.

[00:05:08]

YOU. REMEMBER BANKS. YES. FOR A MEMBER PRESSLER. YES. BOARD MEMBERS ARE HAYEK. YES I REMEMBER. WILLIAMS. YES. NICE CHAIR, MILEY. YES. CHAIR. PALMER? YES. OKAY? SO IT HAS

[6.  

Application No. LDR-22-003 - A Request to Amend The Indiantown Land Development Regulations to Make Revisions to the Permitted Use Table and Related Provisions. 

THE AMENDMENTS WE BRING TO YOU TONIGHT EFFECT. PRIMARILY THAT PARTICULAR ZONING CATEGORY. OUR DISTRICT. AND IT IS AFTER A REVIEW OF OUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND A DETERMINATION BY STAFF FOR CLARIFICATION. THAT WE'RE MAKING THESE CHANGES. SO WHAT YOU'LL SEE EFFECTED IS SOME OF THE RESIDENTIAL USES, SUCH AS ACCESSORY DWELLINGS, DUPLEXES AND SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED DWELLINGS. NEXT SIDE. AND PUBLIC ASSEMBLY PLACES OF WORSHIP. AND COMMUNITY RESIDENTIAL HOMES. UM THOSE HAVE TO BE TREATED EQUALLY ACROSS LIKE DISTRICTS NEXT FIVE. THE L D ARMAMENT PROCESS. YOU KNOW, WE BRING IT HERE TO MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO THE COUNCIL. THE COUNCIL THEN WELL EITHER THROUGH OR DENIED IS TODAY APPROVED THE ORDINANCE AT FIRST HEARING SCHEDULED SECOND READING, AND IT WOULD BECOME EFFECTIVE IF ADOPTED AT SECOND BREATHING OUTSIDE. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT YOU APPROVED THIS APPLICATION, WHICH WAS INITIATED BY THE VILLAGE ADMINISTRATION. AND IT AMENDS THE GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS. TO MAKE THE PERMITTED USE TABLE.

CONSISTENT WITH OUR COMPREHENSIVE PLAN NEXT SIDE. 70 NIGHT STAFF IS ASKING PHYSICAL BOARD TO MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE OR DENY THIS APPLICATION, WHICH WOULD REVISE THE PERMITTED USE TABLE AND RELATED PROVISIONS FOR CONSISTENCY. WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. YOU HAD IT YOUR SEATS TONIGHT. A HANDOUT. THAT LOOKS VERY SIMILAR. TO WHAT YOU RECEIVING YOUR PACKETS. IT WOULD NOT BE IN YOUR NOTEBOOK. IT WOULD BE AT YOUR YOUR SEATS.

IT IS THE ORDINANCE FOR THIS ITEM. UPON SPEAKING WITH THE VILLAGE OF COUNTY TODAY. WE'VE MADE SOME ADDITIONS TO THIS PROPOSED ORDINANCE. AND THOSE ADDITIONS ARE GREEN. FOR THOSE IN THE AUDIENCE. THERE'S A COPY OF THE FRONT TABLE WHERE YOU CAME IN. ANY CHANGES ARE IN GREEN. THAT HAVE BEEN MADE CENTURIES. STEVE, YOU'RE YOUR COFFEE AND YOUR PATH. SO WITH THOSE EDITIONS IN GREEN, YOU'LL SEE SOME NEW DEFINITIONS PROPOSED. AND THESE ARE FOR CLARIFICATION ON. SO THERE'S A DEFINITION NOW FOR CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY TRADES. A NEW PROPOSED DEFINITION FOR TRADES AND SKILLED SERVICES. A NEW PROPOSED DEFINITION FOR WHOLESALE TRADES AND SERVICES. WITH REGARD TO THE PERMITTED USE TABLE ITSELF. YOU WILL SEE THOSE VERY SAME YOU FIND USES. INDICATED IN THE TABLE. FOR MANY USES AND. WHAT I'LL SAY WITH REGARD TO THE DEFINITIONS. THEY ARE. EXACT MATCHES. I BELIEVE OF WHAT WAS IN OUR TRANSITION CODE, WHICH IS THE MARTIN COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATION. SO THIS MAINTAINS THAT CONSISTENCY

[00:10:04]

YOU'RE WELCOME AND CHAIR. I CAN I CAN ADDRESS THE KENNEL DOGGY DAYCARE. UM BIT HERE AS YOU'LL SEE IN THE PERMITTED USE TABLE. KENNELS AND DOGGIE DAYCARES ARE ONLY ALLOWED AS EITHER A CONDITIONAL OR SPECIAL EXCEPTION . USE IN ALL THOSE DIFFERENT CATEGORIES, INCLUDING THE ONE BEING ADDED RELATING TO CANAL MAKES USE. WHAT THAT IN GENERAL TERMS MEANS IS THROUGH ONE PROCESS OR ANOTHER. UNDER OUR CODE. IT'S GOING TO THAT USE IS GOING TO BE RUN THROUGH AN EVALUATION PROCESS TO MAKE SURE YET COMPLIES WITH OUR CODE AND OTHERWISE DOES NOT NEGATIVELY IMPACT SURROUNDING USES. WE HAVE PRECISE UM AH. CONDITIONAL USE RESTRICTIONS IN OUR CODE RELATING TO DOGGIE DAYCARE ENDED ADDRESSES, OUTDOOR KENNELS AND OUTDOOR DOG RUNS. IT BASICALLY HAS A NUMBER OF CRITERIA THAT DEPEND ON IT VARIES ON HOW MANY FEET HOW MANY HUNDREDS OF FEET.

IT IS FROM A RESIDENTIAL USE. OKAY, SO IF BASICALLY, AND THIS IS JUST SCANNING OVER IT. UM IF IT'S MORE THAN 300 FT FROM A RESIDENTIAL USE THAN UM, THEN YOU CAN HAVE AN OUTDOOR DOG RUN, BUT IT CAN ONLY BE USED DURING DAYLIGHT HOURS AND ONLY IN CERTAIN AREAS AND ALL OF THIS, SO THERE ARE A LOT OF CRITERIA LAID OUT IN THE CODE WITH REGARD TO HOW THAT'S IMPLEMENTED, SO IT

[00:15:04]

I CAN GIVE YOU A MORE GENERAL DEFINITION. IF I CAN'T TRACK IT DOWN OTHERWISE. WE DO NOT. WE WOULD DEFER TO A GENERAL DEFINITION. MM HMM. THE WE HAVEE CULTURE WITHIN THE CODE, AND IT'S IN THE CONTEXT OF AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITIES AND IT'O CATEGORIZE IT AS AN AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITY. I WILL GIVE YOU A I CAN GIVE YOU I'LL GIVE YOU CAN GET AND I CAN GIVE YOU A MARTIN COUNTY. DEFINITION WHICH MATCHES UP TO THAT ALMOST EXACTLY? MARTIN COUNTY'S LD. R S DEFINED AQUACULTURE, AND THIS IS THIS IS A GENERALLY ACCURATE DEFINITION ACROSS MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS.

THE COMMERCIAL CULTIVATION OF AQUATIC LIFE SUCH AS BUT NOT LIMITED TO FISH, SHELLFISH AND SEAWEED. IT'S. WHAT YOU SEE, IMPLEMENTED THROUGHOUT A LOT OF THESE USES HERE IS THE IMPLEMENTATION OF WHAT ARE CALLED WATER RELATED OR MARINA MARINA RELATED USES AND AQUACULTURE WOULD BE ONE THAT WOULD SQUARELY FALL WITHIN THAT, OF COURSE, ALL OF THAT'S GOING TO BE SUBJECT TO THE INCREDIBLE AMOUNT OF REGULATION THAT COMES WITH BEING ADJACENT TO AN ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS CONTROL CANAL . SO YOU KNOW HOW ANY OF THAT WOULD PLAY OUT IS ANOTHER MATTER. THANK YOU. AND SHERIFF IF THERE AREN'T ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR DISCUSSIONS FROM THE BOARD MEMBERS, I'D RECOMMEND YOU OPEN UP. REPUBLIC COMMENT. YES, SIR. ARE THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS? YES, MADAM CHAIR. I HAVE HOW MUCH OF THIS IS ROBERT BOB RAINS? GOOD EVENING. FOR THE RECORD. MY NAME IS BOB RAINS. I'M A LANDES, ATTORNEY WITH THE DUNSTER LAW FIRM HERE IN STUART. AND PLEASED TO BE HERE THIS EVENING REPRESENTING SCOTT WATSON AND I TOWN AND THREE LITTLE INDIANS. UH MR WATSON OWNS PROPERTY ALONG THE CANAL. AS I THINK MANY OF YOU ARE PROBABLY AWARE AND HE HAD SOME CONCERNS THAT WE'VE BEEN DEALING WITH MR ROSS AND MS JEFFERSON ON REGARDING SOME OF THE USES WITHIN THE CANAL DISTRICT AND THE LACK OF SOME OF THOSE USES, AND, UH, WE'VE HAD NUMEROUS CALLS OVER THE LAST SIX OR SEVEN MONTHS WITH MR VOS AND MR JEFFERSON. THEY'VE BEEN VERY HELPFUL AND TRYING TO ADD SOME OF THESE USES IN THAT WE BELIEVE WERE APPROPRIATE AND ALSO TO CLARIFY SOME OF THE USES AS TO WHAT CAN BE DONE IN THAT DISTRICT. SO WE DO APPRECIATE THE EFFORT THAT'S BEING MADE ON BEHALF OF THIS TRYING TO ADDRESS HIS CONCERNS. MR BOASTED SHARE WITH ME, UH, EARLIER TODAY BEFORE THE MEETING THE GREEN EDITIONS TOO. THE ORDINANCE, WHICH I WILL PASS ALONG. I HAVEN'T HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO PASS THEM ALONG TO MR WATSON YET, BUT I WILL CERTAINLY DO THAT, AND I DO THINK THAT THEY COULD BE VERY HELPFUL IN ADDRESSING SOME OF OUR CONCERNS. AND THEN WE STILL HAVE ONE OR TWO ITEMS THAT WE'RE STILL WORKING WITH YOUR STAFF ON TO GET CLARIFICATION ON THAT I DON'T THINK YOU'RE ADDRESSED HERE TONIGHT, BUT ARE BEING TRYING TO BE ADDRESSED THROUGH ANOTHER VEHICLE, SO WE APPRECIATE COMMENTS. WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE OBVIOUSLY, TO MONITOR THIS AS WE GO FORWARD TO BE A PART OF THE PROCESS, BUT WE DO APPRECIATE THE EFFORTS BEING MADE TO GET THIS ADDRESS. SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND ALSO YOUR STAFF. OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS ? NO, MADAM CHAIR, OKAY? OKAY, SO WE'LL MOVE ON TO. MADAM SURE.

[00:20:12]

CORRECT.

A SECOND. OKAY. IT'S BEEN. MOVED AND SECONDED SAID JUST FOR CLARIFICATION FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE RECORD THAT THE MOTION ENCOMPASS THE DRAFT BEFORE YOU TONIGHT, WHICH INCLUDES THE GREEN CHANGES. YEAH, VERY GOOD. ALRIGHT WE'RE GOING TO MOVE OVER TO COVER UP. THAT'S OKAY. I GOT AHEAD OF MYSELF. CHAIR IT IT. CAN GET CONFUSING SOMETIMES WHAT YOU KNOW WHEN CONVERSATION. YOU KNOW, IT COMES TO A CLOSE AND SO ON WHEN CONVERSATION SEEMS TO COME TO A CLOSE, AND THERE'S NO FURTHER DISCUSSION. JUST ASK THE CLERK TO ASK THE CLERK FOR REAL CALL VOTE. OKAY? THANK YOU.

ABSOLUTELY. FOR MEMBER BANKS. YES. BOARD MEMBER, PRESSLER. YES, BOARD MEMBER SUHAILA. YES.

REMEMBER WILLIAMS? YES. REMEMBER OUR VICE CHAIR? MILEY YES AND SHARE. PALMER. YES. OKAY. ITEM

[7.  

Application No. LDR-22-006 - A Request to Amend the Indiantown Land Development Regulations to Revise the Requirements for Home-Based Businesses, Pursuant to New Florida Laws.

I'M SORRY, IS THIS UM I'M GOING TO RAISE MY HAND HERE. DOES THIS PRESENTATION INVOLVED LIVING WORK AS WELL? NO. OKAY UM, MEMBERS, SAID HYATT. ARE YOU SATISFIED WITH THAT COMMENT? MY RECOMMENDATION WOULD BE OKAY. GO AHEAD LIKE STAFF, GO AHEAD AND MAKE THEIR PRESENTATION AND THEN, OKAY PARTICULAR OKAY? SO WHAT WE HAVE BEFORE YOU TONIGHT IS A REQUEST TO AMEND THE LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS TO COMPLY WITH THE NEW FLORIDA LAW, WHICH WAS PASSED IN THE LAST LEGISLATIVE SESSION, NOT THE CURRENT ONE AND BECAME EFFECTIVE LAST YEAR. AND BASICALLY THIS NEW LAW STATES THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN NO LONGER HAVE AS MUCH CONTROL OVER HOME BASED BUSINESSES WITH REGARD TO NUMBER ONE REQUIRING ADDITIONAL PARKING MORE THAN WHAT'S ACTUALLY REQUIRED FOR THE OTHER HOMES IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. AH IN ADDITION TO THAT, IT LOOKS AT THINGS LIKE STORAGE OF EQUIPMENT AND WHERE BUSINESS VEHICLES ARE PART MANY CODES. WILL SAY YOU CAN'T PARK YOUR BUSINESS VEHICLE IN YOUR DRIVEWAY AND THAT SORT OF THING. WELL, NOW ARE, UM HANDS ARE TIED TO SOME EXTENT WITH REGARD TO SOME OF THESE ISSUES, AS LONG AS WE'RE HELPING TO MAINTAIN THE

[00:25:03]

GOING. COULD YOU REPEAT THAT? SORRY, YOU CAN WHAT? IN IN YOUR STAFF REPORT PROVIDED ON PAGE TWO OF THE STAFF REPORT PAGE 62 IN YOUR PACKET. WE GIVE AN OUTLINE IN THE ANALYSIS OF SOME OF THE ITEMS AFFECTED BY THE FLORIDA LAW, THE LAST ONE BEING HEAVY EQUIPMENT THAT THE VILLAGE CAN REGULATE STORAGE THAT IS VISIBLE FROM THE STREET ONLY. SS AFFECTED BY THIS NEW LAW AND THE ORDINANCE THAT IS BEING PROPOSED SHOWS IN STRIKETHROUGH WHAT'S BEING TAKEN OUT OF OUR CURRENT CODE AND AN UNDERLYING WHAT'S BEING ADDED IN AGAIN. THE PROCESS FOR AMENDING THE CODE IS THE SAME. WE PRESENT THIS TO YOU TONIGHT. YOU WILL OPEN THE HEARING TO THE PUBLIC FOR ANY COMMENTS THAT MAY BE OUT THERE AFTER YOU'VE TAKEN ON AFTER WE'VE TAKEN YOUR QUESTIONS. YOU ALL MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO THE VILLAGE COUNCIL. AND ONCE IT GOES ON TO THEM, THEY COULD POSSIBLY HAVE TWO READINGS OF THE ORDINANCE TO APPROVE OR DENY IT. NEXT LINE. WE'RE RECOMMENDING TO APPROVE AS THIS IS STAFF INITIATED APPLICATION NEXT SLIDE. AND YOU MAY TAKE THE ACTION TO RECOMMEND THAT THE VILLAGE COUNCIL APPROVE OR DENY THIS APPLICATION, WHICH AUTHORIZES HOME BASED BUSINESSES TO OPERATE IN ALL AREAS ZONED FOR RESIDENTIAL USE. AND TO MATCH ALL THE PROVISIONS OF THE NEW FLORIDA LAW. SO THAT WE'RE IN COMPLIANCE WITH STATE LAW.

WITH THAT I'LL TAKE ANY QUESTIONS NEXT LIFE. I HAVE A QUESTION. YOU READY FOR THE QUESTION? I WAS EXPLAINING. YES, GREAT. OKAY JUST FOR TO BE CLEAR. SO WE HAVE, UM BIZ, HOME BASED BUSINESSES. AND IF THEY HAVE HEAVY EQUIPMENT OR JUST. JUST OUTLAND. JUST STUFF. THAT WOULD REQUIRE THAT WOULD COME BECOME AN EYESORE, ESPECIALLY WITH WHAT THE NEW DEVELOPMENT FRIENDS THAT YOU GUYS WE HAVE PROVISIONS CURRENTLY IN OUR CODE THAT. SOMEONE CANNOT OPEN A USED CAR. SALES OR RENTAL CAR BUSINESS. ANY GIVEN NEIGHBORHOOD THAT'S NOT A HOME BASED BUSINESS. HOME BASED BUSINESSES, SOMETHING THAT'S REALLY SECONDARY. TO ITS PRIMARY USE, WHICH IS THAT OUR RESIDENTS. ANT FALL UNDER THAT DEFINITION. SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. MAYBE A REALTOR HAS A HOME OFFICE AND ACCOUNTANT. UM. TRYING TO THINK OF ANOTHER EXAMPLE. A LANDSCAPER . THAT'S AN EXAMPLE WE HAVE HERE . WE HAVE LANDSCAPING COMPANIES , UM, THAT HAVE THEIR HOME ADDRESSES THEIR BUSINESS, BUT THEY DO WORK EVERYWHERE, RIGHT? NOT UNSURE TAKING QUESTIONS.

YES, WE ARE. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? UM PUBLIC COMING. I'M SORRY. I'M SORRY. IT'S OK. UM I WANT TO MENTION YOU KNOW WHERE YOU HAVE THE ON THIS PAGE TO THE SAME ONE. YOU HAD THE QUESTION ON, UM, ABOUT THE SPACES FOR PARKING. THAT IT ONLY BEYOND IMPROVED SURFACES. AND, UM.

[00:30:03]

OKAY SO I'M SORRY, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS WOULD LIKE TO SAY SOMETHING. GO AHEAD. REMEMBER, SIR, I AM. YEAH. I JUST HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE VILLAGE ATTORNEY HERE. SOME OF OUR PROJECTS. UM SOME OF THE PROJECTS THAT I'VE WORKED ON HAVE LIVE WORK UNITS IN THIS. I KNOW THAT THIS ORDINANCE IS BASED TO HOME OCCUPATION. I MEAN , IF THERE IS A LIVE WORK UNIT COMPONENT TO THIS, UM I KNOW THAT I'M NOT REQUIRED TO, BUT I'D LIKE TO RECUSE MYSELF ON THE VOTE FOR THIS MATTER JUST ON THE APPEARANCE OF CONFLICT. AND IF THAT'S OKAY WITH EVERYBODY. IT'S

[00:35:04]

BROKE ALL THE VOTES. BOARD MEMBER BANKS. YEP. REMEMBER PRESSLER. YES I REMEMBER. SIR HAYEK IS RECUSED BOARD MEMBER WILLIAMS? YES. VICE CHAIR. MILEY YES. CHAIR. PALMER. YES. OKAY.

[8.  

Application No. LDR-22-004 - A Request to Amend the Indiantown Land Development Regulations to Supplement Existing Tree Mitigation Requirements and Establish a Tree Mitigation Fund.

OKAY. OKAY THANK YOU. ROLL CALL . VOTE BOARD MEMBER BANKS? YES. REMEMBER PRESSLER? YES. BOARD MEMBER SUHAILA YES. BOARD MEMBER WILLIAMS. YES. THANKS CHAIR. MILEY YES, CHAIR. PALMER? YES.

[9.  

Application No CPA-22-005 - A Request to Amend the Indiantown Comprehensive Plan to Include a Property Rights Element.

UM FOR TRANSMITTAL TO CEO OF THIS NEW. PROPERTY RIGHTS ELEMENT, WHICH HAS A GOAL, ONE OBJECTIVE AND ONE POLICY, WHICH IS PROVIDED FOR YOU AND YOUR BACKUP. AND PAGE. PAGE 82 OF YOUR PACKET AND PAGE TWO OF THE CORRESPONDING STAFF REPORT. THIS IS SOMETHING ESSENTIALLY THAT THE COUNCIL HAS ALREADY DOING IS JUST A MATTER OF PUTTING IT IN WRITING AND RECOGNIZING THAT, UM ANYONE THAT OWNS PROPERTY HAS PROPERTY RIGHTS AND THAT AND ITS DECISION MAKING, UH, TAKE THAT INTO CONSIDERATION. ANY EASEMENTS LEASES, ETCETERA. THE PROCESS FOR AMENDING THE LAND

[00:40:06]

[00:45:04]

[3.  

PZAB Member Eligibility Requirements

LIBERAL BERRY. I CAN'T. OKAY GIVE HIM A WORD WE WILL DELIBERATE ON ON THAT TWO TESTS USING THE VILLAGE L D R SECTION 11-58. QUOTE. MEMBERS MAY BE REMOVED BY THE VILLAGE COUNCIL UPON WRITTEN CHART CHARGES AT PUBLIC HEARING. MEMBERS OF THIS BOARD SHALL SERVE WITHOUT COMPENSATION AND SHARE RESIDE WITHIN A MINIMUM OF ONE YEAR RESIDENCY. R B, THE OWNER OF A BUSINESS LOCATED FOR A MINIMUM OF ONE YEAR WITHIN THE VILLAGE. ONE OF MANY THINGS I LOVE GENERALLY GENUINELY LOVE ABOUT MY FELLOW BOARD MEMBERS IS THE DEEP ROOTED PASSION THAT EACH HALF FOR INDIAN TOWNS SUCCESS. REMAIN PASSIONATE. BEEP BUT PLEASE BE MINDFUL THAT THIS IS NOT A PERSONAL ATTACK ON ANY ONE OF US. UNLESS A MAJORITY OF YOU EJECT EVERY MEMBER WOULD HAVE UP TO THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM. THE ORDER WILL FOLLOW THE EXACT ONE USED BY THE VILLAGE CLERK FOR ROLL CALL. MANNING CLERK. BOARD MEMBER BANKS. WITHOUT HAVING MUCH

[00:50:05]

BUT I MEAN, NO, I'M NOT TESTS ANY DISCUSSION, ANY COMMENT? WHAT IS? ARE THERE ANY COMMENTS? THAT'S THE THAT'S THE QUESTION WHEN BEFORE WE CAN DO ANY VOTING OR ANYTHING WE NEED TO DISCUSS, UM THE SUBJECT AT HAND. IF THERE IS NO COMMENTS, THEN WE'LL MOVE FORWARD. IS THAT CORRECT? OKAY DO YOU HAVE ANY COMMENTS THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A DRESS ON FEBRUARY 17TH? I EMAILED A MEMO OUTLINING INFORMATION THAT HAD COME TO LIGHT. THAT ONE OF OUR SEATS ON THE PC ABOARD DID NOT MEET THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS AS ADDRESSED IN CHAPTER 11 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT RULES. I HOPE THAT I THINK THAT EVERYONE HAS RECEIVED A COPY. HAS EVERYONE RECEIVED A COPY OF THAT? MM HMM. UM. THE INFORMATION IS OUTLINED THERE WHAT THE CONFLICTS OF INTEREST ARE AND WHAT CONSTITUTES WHETHER OR NOT YOU HAVE A BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE. SO I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION THAT WE ENTER THAT MEMO INTO THE RECORD AND PRESENT IT TO THE VILLAGE COUNCIL FOR ACTION. I THINK YOU SHOULD GIVE EVERYBODY A CHANCE TO SPEAK PERMISSION OF THE CHAIR BEFORE YOU MAKE A MOTION. I WOULD THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE THE DEMOCRATIC THING TO DO HERE.

THANK YOU, MEMBER SUHAILA. HOW HAS MADE A MOTION IF THERE'S A SECOND, WE CAN STILL DISCUSS OKAY? OKAY, MOTION HAS BEEN MADE AS THE SECOND. I WAS SECOND. I STILL LIKE TO GIVE MY COMMENTS BEFORE EMOTION IS MADE. I DON'T BELIEVE THAT EVERYBODY HAD THE CHANCE TO MAKE A COMMENT HERE.

OKAY? OKAY? UM REMEMBER WILLIAMS, I WOULD HAVE TO SAY NO. I CAN'T GO ALONG WITH REMOVE HIM. BECAUSE OF ME BEING JUST PRESENT ON THE BOARD. FOR A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME. OKAY SO I'M GONNA PASS ON THIS. OKAY? OKAY, OKAY. WORK. CHEER CAN I CAN I RECOMMEND THAT THERE HAS BEEN A MOTION IN THE SECOND. UM, I THINK THERE MAY HAVE JUST BEEN A MISCOMMUNICATION ON ASKING IF THERE WERE ANY BOARD MEMBERS WITH ANY COMMENTS, BUT WITH THERE BEING A MOTION ON THE FLOOR AND RECOMMEND, MR SYKE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO I TOTALLY AGREE. I WAS, UM I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOUR SAYING ATTORNEY. THAT'S WHAT I WAS THINKING TO EVERYONE SHOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY, INCLUDING MEMBERS OF HIGH TO VOICE THEIR OPINION. OR REFRAIN. AS OUR TWO MEMBERS HAVE SO UM. WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE ON WITH THE UM YES. WHAT THE DISCUSSION. I MEAN, I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT I'M ALLOWED TO SPEAK. YOU ARE AMERICAN IS MADE HERE YOU ARE ALLOWED TO SPEAK, OKAY? ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. BOARD MEMBERS TO HAYEK HASN'T TEXTED YOU GO.

THANK YOU. I APOLOGIZE. I JUST WANTED TO COME ON ZOOM, SO THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF A DELAY HERE. UM I'D LIKE TO JUST COMMENT ON THIS. I WOULD HAVE LIKED TO COMMENT ON THIS BEFORE IT EVEN BECAME ON THE AGENDA. UM, AND LAST THE LAST MEETING AND I RESPECTED YOU KNOW THE VILLAGES, WHICH IS AND THE REST OF THE OF THE COUNCIL'S WISHES, SO I DO APPRECIATE YOU. BUT TO ME SPEAK NOW AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. SO FIRST AND FOREMOST, I'D LIKE TO THANK UM. EVERYONE IT'S BEEN ONE OF THE GREATEST HONORS OF MY LIFE TO BE APPOINTED ON THIS PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD TO SERVE THE COUNCIL, THE FELLOW PLANNING AND ZONING MEMBERS, THE STAFF, THE COMMUNITY AND THE RESIDENTS OF INDIAN TOWN. UM I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO DEAL WITH THIS ISSUE AT HAND IN A PUBLIC FORUM. UM I'D LIKE TO NOTE THAT MY SIDE OF THE STORY HAS NOT BEEN TOLD, AND THE ONLY SIDE HAS BEEN MISR ANITA PRESSLER. AND I HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO SPEAK TO THIS MOMENT AND IT STILL SURPRISES ME THAT SHE WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION BEFORE I EVEN HAD THE CHANCE TO SPEAK. BUT NOW THAT I AM ABLE TO SPEAK, I APPRECIATE THAT OPPORTUNITY, AND I APPRECIATE THE BOARD. ALL OF YOU, INCLUDING MYSTERY, NINA PRESSLER TO HEAR MY SIDE OF THE STORY SO I WAS

[00:55:05]

PERMITTED HIM, UM OF ONE YEAR WITHIN THE VILLAGE. AT THE TIME OF MY APPOINTMENT, THERE WAS NO ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT. THAT WAS THE RULE AT THE TIME OF THE APPOINTMENT, SO I INFORMED THE VILLAGE AND THE STAFF THAT I HAVE BEEN AN OWNER OF THE BUSINESS OF A BUSINESS LOCATED WITHIN THE VILLAGE. SO THERE WAS NO REQUIREMENT TO OBTAIN A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IN THE L D.

R AT THE TIME OF MY APPOINTMENT. SO I WEAR. THAT WAS THE RULE AT THE TIME OF MY APPOINTMENT. I JUST WANT THAT TO BE CLEAR. UM IF THERE WAS A BUSINESS TAX REQUIREMENT THAT WAS IN THE CODE AT THAT TIME. IT'S JUST A MATTER OF PAPERWORK TO FILE THAT AND I WOULD HAVE BEEN MORE THAN HAPPY TO ABIDE BY THAT REQUIREMENT. UM AND JUST TO SHARE WITH EVERYBODY . YOU KNOW, I DO WEAR A LOT OF DIFFERENT HATS ON THE VILLAGE. I THERE I AM A ATTORNEY. THERE'S SO HIGH A CLAW. I'M IN THE REAL ESTATE BUSINESS. THERE'S A HIGHER COMMERCIAL REALTY. UM. AND THE LAW FIRM HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE SINCE 2000 AND 14. THE SAHARA COMMERCIAL REALTY IS SINCE 2000 AND 15 UM. MEMBER YOU KNOW I AM I YES. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES CHAIR. YOU'RE NOT GOING TO. LIKE WHAT I MUST FINISH. MY RECOMMENDATION WOULD BE THIS MATTERS. PERTAINING TO MR SO, HAYEK. I THINK DUE PROCESS WOULD REQUIRE YOU OKAY? MAKE HIS POINT. OKAY MEMBERS, I CONTINUE, PLEASE. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. I WILL TRY AND BE BRIEF. UM YOU KNOW, I AM DIVERTED BY OPERATE VIRTUALLY. I DO USE MY FATHER'S MEDICAL FACILITY FOR MALE THAT IS THE 1983 PJ BOULEVARD SUITE. 105 I AM NEVER IN THE OFFICE. I RECEIVED MY MAIL THERE. I SPEND ALL OF MY LIFE MY TIME, MY EMAILS REGARDING THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. I'M OFTEN AT DUNKIN DONUTS. I'M OFTEN AROUND TOWN. EVERYBODY'S MY TIME. MY FOCUS, UM, PHYSICALLY, YOU KNOW, THIS IS WITHIN THE TOWN. SO, UM I HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN, UH, THE DUNKIN DONUTS PLAZA AS AN ATTORNEY TO COMMERCIAL REALTY, WHICH IS SEPARATE FROM THE OUTWEIGH. AND SO HAYEK FAMILIES . UM I WAS INVOLVED AS AN ATTORNEY AND AS A BROKER AND THE TRACTOR SUPPLY DEAL. UM I WAS INVOLVED AS AN ATTORNEY AND A BROKER IN THE CASA. BE A DEAL. I AM INVOLVED IN THE PARKVIEW PROJECT. UM ALL AS AN ATTORNEY, AND AS YOU KNOW, IT'S A HIGHER COMMERCIAL REALTY. SO THOSE I KNOW THAT MR ANITA JUST MET ME ON THE BOARD ABOUT A YEAR AGO.

UM BUT I'VE BEEN DEALING WITH THE VILLAGE AND THOSE CAPACITIES SINCE MARTIN COUNTY HAD THE JURISDICTION OVER INDIAN TOWN PRIOR TO THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN, WHICH WAS IN 2000 AND 17.

SO THAT GOES BACK TO ALMOST FOUR OR FIVE YEARS AGO. UM. NOT ONLY THAT I ALSO HAVE DIRECT OWNERSHIP AND PARKVIEW. UM THE LLC FOR THAT, WHICH IS, UH, ACTUALLY IS CLOSE BY THE BUILDING THAT YOU GUYS SIT IN RIGHT NOW. THAT LLC WAS FORMED MORE THAN ONE YEAR PRIOR TO MY APPOINTMENT. THE LAND. THERE WAS THE CLOSING WAS AFTER THE YEAR REQUIREMENT, BUT I THAT LLC WAS FORMED PRIOR TO A YEAR. UM I JUST WANT TO BE CLEAR THAT THE CLOSING DID NOT TAKE PLACE TILL ABOUT 11 MONTHS IN A FEW DAYS. BUT WHEN I LOOK BACK, THAT WAS THE ACTUAL TIMEFRAME THERE. I'D LIKE TO ALSO ADD THAT I CURRENTLY OWN A HOUSE IN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. UM SO, UM. YOU KNOW, I BELIEVE WITHOUT A DOUBT THAT I HAVE OPERATED A BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. UM IF THERE HAD BEEN A REQUIREMENT AT THE TIME OF MY APPOINTMENT, I WOULD HAVE EASILY SATISFIED IT. AND MOVING FORWARD, YOU KNOW, ADDING THE REQUIREMENT OF THE BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IS NOT A BAD THING. I THINK THAT THERE ARE THERE ARE MANY WAYS TO QUALIFY AS OPERATING A BUSINESS IN THE VILLAGE OF TOWN. CAN YOU BELIEVE PHYSICALLY LOCATED HERE? WHAT

[01:00:02]

A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IS NOT THE ONLY WAY TO SHOW THAT YOU HAVE PHYSICAL PRESENCE WITHIN THE VILLAGE. SO, UM. NO, I JUST AND I DO JUST WANT TO POINT OUT IN THE PREVIOUS MEETING, IT WAS SAID, YOU KNOW, HONEST. ANYWAY, I'M JUST GONNA KEEP TO THIS ISSUE AT HAND. SO FOR THE I'M HAPPY TO GO GET THE BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT, EVEN THOUGH IT WAS NOT A REQUIREMENT AT THE TIME OF MY APPOINTMENT. HAPPILY SUPPORT THAT ADDITION TO THE CODE, AND I DON'T THINK THAT THIS BOARD, UM AS THE ABILITY TO REMOVE ME OR SUGGEST MY REMOVAL AS I WAS APPOINTED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. UM AND THAT'S ALL THAT I HAVE TO SAY REGARDING THE BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. I DON'T THINK THAT I NEED TO COMMENT ABOUT THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST. I'M HAPPY TO IF ANYBODY WOULD LIKE ME TO BEAUTIFUL. THANK YOU MEMBERS. AH, YES. REMEMBER WILLIAMS. THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME SPEAK. YES SIR. BOARD MEMBER. WILLIAMS SAID THAT HE WISHES THE PAST AT THIS TIME. IS THAT CORRECT? STILL, SIR. I'M SORRY. YOU WISH TO PASS ON COMMENTS AT THIS TIME ? YES THANK YOU. AND VICE CHAIR. MILEY IS NEXT. HELLO AGAIN. SO UM, IN REGARDS TO THE TOPIC AT HAND, I WOULD FIRST LIKE TO START BY ASKING, UM BOARD MEMBERS TO HIRE. MANY ALLEGATIONS HAVE BEEN MADE IN REGARDS TO YOU HAVING NOT HAVING A BUSINESS LOCATED. ARE YOU ABLE TO BE DIRECT AND LET US KNOW WHAT BUSINESS UM, YOU HAVE THAT LOCATED IN THE VILLAGE AT THE TIME OF YOUR CONCEPTION? BECAUSE YOU YOU YOU MENTIONED MANY THINGS THAT YOU'RE INVOLVED IN, BUT YOU NEVER SPECIFICALLY SAID WHAT THE BUSINESS IS THAT WITHIN THE VILLAGE? SURE SO. HI THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION. SO HIGH A COMMERCIAL REALTY IS ONE SO HIGH A CLAW IS TO WHICH BOTH OPERATE VIRTUALLY EVEN THOUGH THAT I DO RECEIVE MAIL AT A PHYSICAL AT A PHYSICAL ADDRESS, SO THAT'S HOW I'VE ALWAYS OPERATED AND NUMBER THREE, UM PARKVIEW APARTMENTS THAT LLC WAS FORMED. UM UM.

PRIOR TO A YEAR OF MY APPOINTMENT AND THE MISSION OF THAT COMPANY WAS TO PURCHASE A PIECE OF LAND, DEVELOP IT AND TO CREATE APARTMENTS. SO WE START. WE STARTED ON THAT PRIOR TO A YEAR WE CLOSED ON IT ABOUT 11 MONTHS AND 30 DAYS WITHIN SO THOSE THREE ENTITIES WORK FORMED. PRIOR TO, UM MY APPOINTMENT, SO I. IN ANY OF THOSE THREE COMPANIES. UM. YOU COULD. THEY COULD QUALIFY AND I JUST WANT TO BE CLEAR. SO I A CRIME MERCIAL REALTY AND TO HAYEK LAW DO WORK FOR THE DUNKIN DONUTS PLAZA CASABLANCA. PARKVIEW TRACTOR SUPPLY INDIAN TOWN MEADOWS, SO I WEAR AN INDIVIDUAL HAT SEPARATE FROM THE OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY AND WORKING ALL THOSE PROJECTS. AND THAT'S TO ANSWER YOUR SPECIFIC QUESTION. HOW DID I QUALIFY? FOR OPERATING A BUSINESS. AND THOSE THREE WAYS. OKAY. THANK YOU. SO, UM WHEN THOSE BUSINESSES WHERE.

FORMULATED DID YOU HAVE TO A PLOT LIKE DID YOU APPLY TO WITH THE VILLAGE IN ORDER TO DO BUSINESS IN THE VILLAGE OR LIKE, HOW DID THAT COME ABOUT WHERE'S YOUR BUSINESS? IS IT BASED IN THE VILLAGE? SO I SO HIGH, A COMMERCIAL REALTY AND SO HIGH A CLAUSE OF VIRTUAL SO IT'S MANY OF THE MEETINGS ARE ON ZOOM AND VIA EMAIL. THERE'S NO I DON'T SEE CLIENTS OR CUSTOMERS OR SO GOODS. I'M I'M OPERATE VIRTUALLY AND THEN THE PARKVIEW APARTMENTS THAT WAS FORMED TO PURCHASE AN ACTUAL PIECE OF LAND. SO UM, YOU KNOW, OR THESE THESE BUSINESSES ARE SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT THAN A HAIRDRESSER RIGHT OR A SANDWICH SHOP BECAUSE YOU WOULD HAVE A PHYSICAL LOCATION. YOU'RE GETTING CUSTOMERS COMING IN, AND YOU WOULD HAVE A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT THAT YOU WOULD PUT ON THE WALL. THAT'S SAYING THAT I'M SERVING CUSTOMERS AND, UM, SELLING MERCHANDISE IN A PHYSICAL LOCATION. OUR BUSINESS IS SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT. AND WHAT THE SIA CLOUDS HIGH COMMERCIAL

[01:05:04]

BUT YOU KNOW, GETTING A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IS NOT A BAD THING. IF THAT'S AN ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE THANK YOU. THANK YOU, UM. UM THANK YOU, UM, MEMBERS OF HOW YOU FOR ANSWERING THE QUESTIONS. UM. MY QUESTIONS WOULD BE OUR COMMENTS WOULD BE ALONE. WE'RE BEING CONJUNCTION WITH MEMBER PRESSLER AS WELL AS VICE CHAIR MILDLY, SO I'M NOT GOING TO REGURGITATE ANYTHING THAT THEY'VE SAID THAT, UM THOSE ARE THE QUESTIONS THAT I HAD TO THINK THAT I'M I'M I'M GRATEFUL AND THANKFUL THAT YOU ANSWERED THE QUESTIONS. UM. HONESTLY AND I THINK THAT YOU, UM WHEN WE HAD A CONFLICT OF INTEREST, YOU DID RECRUIT YOURSELF. I THINK ONLY ONE THING THAT I WOULD LIKE TO MENTION IS THAT ALL THE BUSINESSES THAT YOU'VE MENTIONED THAT YOU THAT YOU ARE THAT YOU ARE THAT YOUR OWNER OF A CO OWNER? ALL IN THE IN THE VILLAGE, RIGHT? AND THEN YOU'RE CONSTANTLY RECRUITING YOURSELF. SO I GUESS ONE QUESTION HOW DO YOU HOW DO YOU INTEND? HOW HOW WOULD YOU INTEND TO MAINTAIN THE INTEGRITY? YOU KNOW OF YOUR MEMBERSHIP ON THE BOARD? YES WE CAN'T TASTE REMOVE YOU ARE MAKE YOU REMAIN. THAT'S OUT OF OUR HANDS. ALREADY, RECOMMENDATION WOULD BE TO SEND THIS BACK TO THE COUNCIL FOR THEM TO MAKE THAT DECISION. BUT IN IN ALL FAIRNESS AND OUR HONESTY. HOW DO YOU MAINTAIN INTEGRITY? I THINK THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION AND YOU KNOW IF A FAMILY MEMBER OF MINE OR OMAR AT WAY OWNS A PIECE OF LAND OR ANY BUSINESS IN THE VILLAGE. SEPARATE FROM MY OWNERSHIP. I HAVE A DUTY AND AN ETHICAL OBLIGATION TO RECUSE MYSELF VIA FAMILY STATUS OR A BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP. SO. WE'RE GOOD. I HAVE DONE THAT. TWICE I DID THAT ON INDIAN TOWN MEADOWS AND I DID IT ON. ON CASA BIA AND , UM, AT THAT TIME, I DID NOT HAVE ANY DIRECT OWNERSHIP IN EITHER OF THOSE PROJECTS. SO. I VOLUNTEERED THAT INFORMATION AND I'M UNDER THE DUTY TO DO THAT, AND I DID DO THAT, AND I RECUSED MYSELF BOTH TIMES TODAY I RECUSED MYSELF. AGAIN WHEN I DON'T HAVE A DUTY TO WITH THE LIVE WORK UNITS BECAUSE IT GIVES THE APPEARANCE THAT I COULD HAVE A CONFLICT BECAUSE CASA BIANCA AND PART OF YOU HAVE LIVED WORK, SO I TRY MY BEST TO ALL. WHATEVER THE RULES ARE, I TRY TO GO ABOVE AND BEYOND, AND I WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT, AND THAT'S A PROMISE THAT I WILL MAKE TO THIS BOARD THE COUNCIL AND THE VILLAGE IS ALWAYS TO DO THAT. OKAY. THANK YOU. SO MUCH.

MEMBERS ARE HIGH YET. ARE THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS? YES, I HAVE MR KEVIN POWERS. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. I MEAN, IT WAS KEVIN POWERS IN A SMALL BUSINESS OWNER HERE IN TOWN AND PUSH UP THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE IN FRONT OF YOU TONIGHT. UM I WANTED TO HIT THIS THING. TWO DIFFERENT WAYS. NUMBER ONE. YOU KNOW, I FEEL IT IN THE ROOM AND DIDN'T TOWN ALWAYS COMES TOGETHER AS WHEN WE ALL COME FROM DIFFERENT DIFFERENT ASPECTS. BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY INDIAN TOWN, UM HAS A WAY OF COMING TOGETHER AS ONE AND I THINK IN THIS PARTICULAR INSTANCE, IT SEEMS THAT AT LARGE IN A GENERAL SENSE THERE'S BUSINESSES BEING SINGLED OUT AND THEN AN INDIVIDUAL, SO IF YOU'LL INDULGE ME, I'D LIKE TO GO BACK.

AND JUST WHEN I THINK ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP OF THE BUSINESSES AND THE COMMUNITY AT LARGE, THE FIRST THING THAT POPS TO MIND IS SOMETHING THAT WAS NEAR NEAR TO ME. AND THAT WAS THE VERY FIRST AMBULANCE BRAND NEW AMBULANCE THAT INDIAN TOWN EVER HAD. AND IT WAS A DONATION FROM FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT. AND IT WASN'T TO SERVICE THEIR CAMPUS OUT THERE. IT WAS THE SERVICE THE COMMUNITY AT LARGE. I'M FAMILIAR WITH IT BECAUSE MY MOM WAS ONE OF THE MANY VOLUNTEERS THAT DROVE IT AND SERVED AS AN EMERGENCY VOLUNTEERED TO HELP. UM THE COGEN PLANT WHEN THEY CAME TO TOWN. WHAT DO THEY DO? THEY ESTABLISHED THE COMMUNITY FOUNDATION. WHAT ELSE CAN WE DO? AND HOW CAN WE HELP? THE YMCA. IT'S NOT JUST CALLED THE WILLIAMS A. IT'S CALLED THE

[01:10:03]

AND I'VE ONLY GOT 21 SECONDS AND I WILL SAY THAT DANIEL SAN HIKE IS A STAND UP PERSON. HIS FAMILY ARE STAND UP PEOPLE. THEY CAME TO INDIAN TOWN AND INVESTED WHEN NOBODY WOULD AND THEY BROUGHT US COMMERCIAL ADDITIONS FOR COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL AND RESIDENTS NEEDED THEIR BUSINESSES ARE ACTIVE AND INVOLVED. DANIEL'S A PERSON OF HONOR AND INTEGRITY, SO KEEP IT.

KEEP IT AT SEVEN. IF I HAD ANY ADVICE EXPANDED, INCLUDING NONPROFITS, THEIR STAKEHOLDERS THEY OWN ASSETS HERE IN INDIAN TOWN AND FINALLY, THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE AND YOUR TIME.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR POWELL. YES I WANTED TO SAY A FEW THINGS. UM. OF THE THINGS THAT MR ZAHARIA BROUGHT UP. I DIDN'T HEAR ANY ADDRESS OF ANY BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE WAS JUST WHAT THE RULE SAYS THE RULE WAS IN PLACE WHEN MR ZAR HAYEK WAS APPOINTED. UM IT JUST WAS NOT KNOWN THAT HE DIDN'T HAVE A BUSINESS WITHIN INDIAN TOWN. WHAT I DID HERE WAS A LONG LIST OF CONFLICTS. UM ONE OF THOSE THINGS, UH ARE THAT I DIDN'T KNOW THAT YOU WEREN'T ACTING AS AN ATTORNEY FOR TRACTOR SUPPLY. YOU DID NOT RECRUIT. RECUSE YOURSELF FROM THAT VOTE. I DIDN'T LIVE HERE. YOU MENTIONED THAT. UM. I'M GOING TO HAVE TO JUST STOP YOU RIGHT THERE. I DO APOLOGIZE, BUT THAT'S JUST NOT APPROPRIATE TO SAY THAT IN A PUBLIC FORUM. I DID RECUSE MYSELF WITH THE TRACTOR SUPPLY. YOU SAID THAT IN THE PREVIOUS MEETING AND THAT IS NOT A STATEMENT OF FACT, THAT IS A FALSE STATEMENT. I RECUSED MYSELF IN THE IN THE INDIAN TOWN MEADOWS AND THE TRACTOR SUPPLY. I RECUSED MYSELF FROM THE DIOCESE. THE REQUIREMENT WAS TO NOT SAY ANYTHING. I LEFT THE DIESS AND I CAME AND I SAT IN THE AUDIENCE, WHICH WAS AN ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT. OKAY SO YOU'VE SAID THAT TWICE. I DON'T MIND FOR YOU TO BRING UP THIS ISSUE. BUT YOU HAVE TO SAY STATEMENTS OF FACT, YOU CANNOT SAY STATEMENTS THAT ARE NOT FACTUAL. YOU LISTED THE THING AND I SAY THAT RESPECTFULLY TO THINGS THAT YOU RECUSED YOURSELF FROM AND YOU HAD JUST MENTIONED THAT YOU ACTED AS AN ATTORNEY FOR TRACTOR SUPPLY, AND I DON'T REMEMBER YOU RECUSING YOURSELF FROM THAT VOTE. UM IN THE DEAL WITH TRACTOR SUPPLY FROM THE SALE OF THE FOUR ACRES FROM FROM, I RECUSED MYSELF. OKAY UM, NUMBER PRESSLER. I'M SORRY, REMEMBERS A HIGH THOSE THAT WE'RE NOT GOING TO GO BACK AND FORTH WITH THOSE BECAUSE WE CAN JUST PULL UP. WE HAVE THE, UH, THE OTHER MINUTES TO PULL UP. UM I APOLOGIZE TO YOU. I WOULD JUST LIKE TO STATE FOR THE RECORD, PLEASE. THAT THAT THAT YOU COULD PLEASE STATE THAT I DID RECUSE MYSELF FOR THAT PROJECT THAT, UM, OUR. OUR CLERK. SHE WILL PULL THAT UP AND SHE CAN MAKE YOU KNOW, MAKE SURE THAT THAT STATEMENTS ARE ACCURATE. I UNDERSTAND. I APOLOGIZE. THAT UM, THAT YOU FEEL THAT WAY AND IF ANY ERRONEOUS STATEMENTS ARE MADE WE APOLOGIZE AS A BOARD TO YOU, OKAY, BUT WE ARE GOING TO MOVE FORWARD. UM WE'RE GOING TO RESPECT ONE ANOTHER. WE'RE NOT GOING TO BICKER ABOUT IT. UM WE'RE GOING TO MAKE A MOTION TO SEND THIS BACK TO THE ER. WE

[01:15:04]

YEAH. WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO READ THIS? NO THAT'S FINE. I JUST WANT TO JUST SAY YOU'RE YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO SEND SOMETHING THE COUNCIL FOR REQUIREMENTS OF ELIGIBILITY RIGHT? THAT BEING SAID, THEN I'LL ADDRESS COUNCIL ON THAT. BUT I WANT TO JUST TELL THIS BOARD THE SAME THING THAT MR POWER SAID. WE HAVE A WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY IN THIS TOWN TO KEEP A QUALITY PERSON. ON THIS BOARD TO MAKE GOOD JUDGMENTS ON SOMETHING THAT HE'S KNOWS ABOUT YOU ALL THE SAME WAY YOU ALL MAKING DECISIONS THAT ARE BENEFICIAL TO THE COMMUNITY, OR I HOPE THEY ARE ANYWAY. AND I THINK YOU ARE BUT THERE AGAIN YOU RECOMMEND THE COUNCIL. NOT ONE ON ONE. I THINK IT WAS VERY INAPPROPRIATE FOR HERE. IF YOU DIDN'T WANT HIM ON HER, YOU CAN RECOMMEND THAT THE COUNCIL AND THEIR CHOICE TO TAKE HIM OFF. WELL, WE DIDN'T PUT MEMBERS OF HEIGHT ON THE BOARD. ALL OF US WAS RECOMMENDED AND ACTS TO BE A PART OF THIS BOARD. OKAY SO, UM , WHAT WE'VE ALL SAID, BASED ON THE REQUIREMENTS IF A PERSON WITH THIS ME OR ANYONE THAT IS NOT THAT DON'T MEET THE BASIC REQUIREMENTS. THAT THE COUNCIL SET THEN THE BOARD HAS AN OPPORTUNITY AND THE OBLIGATION TO SEND THAT BACK TO THE COUNCIL AND SAY TO THEM THESE THIS IS WHAT YOU SAID. AND THIS IS WHAT'S HAPPENING. SO YOU CORRECTED. WE JUST MAKE A RECOMMENDATION. I UNDERSTAND THAT. I KNOW HOW THINGS ARE NOT HOW THINGS WORK AND AGAIN THE RECORD. WHAT'S THE RECOMMENDATIONS? YOU'RE GOING TO SEND BACK THE COUNCIL? I'M SORRY. WHAT IS THE RECOMMENDATION WE'VE GOT. WE'RE GOING TO GET TO THAT AS A AS A WHOLE. WE'RE GONNA WE'RE GONNA VOTE. HOW IT'S GONNA BE OKAY. YOU JUST HAVE A SEAT AND YOU'LL SEE WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN.

THANK YOU. YOU WANT ME TO REPEAT MY MOTION? UM UNTIL WE REDO IT. DO THE MOTION. I HAVE A MOTION TO SET THE MEMO INTO THE RECORD AND TO SEND IT TO THE COUNCIL. IT WAS IT WAS, IT WAS SECONDED.

IT WAS SECOND. CORRECT OKAY, RED FOOTBALL. YES MADAM. I'M SORRY. GO AHEAD. WE REPEAT THE MOTION.

ABSOLUTELY IT WAS TO SEND THE MEMO INTO THE RECORD. AND TO PROVIDE IT TO THE COUNCIL. THE MEMO BEING THE ONE FROM HIS PRESSLER PRESS YES. THEN YOU GOT IT RIGHT? I DID, BUT I WAS UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT THE COUNCIL HAD ALSO RECEIVED IT. THEY HAVE RECEIVED IT. OKAY THAT DID THE BOARD RECEIVED. EVERYBODY SHOULD HAVE RECEIVED. DID YOU RECEIVE IT? MR WILLIAMS? THE LETTER OKAY? YES, YES. CHAIR. IF I CAN SAY SOMETHING REALLY QUICK. UM SO WHEN I SECOND THE MOTION, MY SECOND WAS NOT IN REGARDS TO HIS STANCE OR HOW I FEEL. HE IF HE SHOULD BE REMOVED OR NOT. MY MOTION WAS JUST TO SEND THIS INFORMATION THAT WE HAD RECEIVED TWO COUNCIL. THAT'S THAT'S WHAT I WAS SECONDING, RIGHT? THAT'S THE MOTION. OKAY JUST MAKING SURE WHAT SHE SAID TO EVERYBODY WAS JUST MAKING SURE OKAY. OKAY? SO. SO THE MOTION IS SIMPLY TO FORWARD THIS INFORMATION.

[01:20:03]

YES AND WHEN THE ONCE THEY WROTE , GO AHEAD. YOU YES. OKAY, GO AHEAD, MADAM CHAIR. SO. AS YOU LAID OUT THE BEGINNING AND AS IS LAID OUT IN THE AGENDA ITEM. WE'RE TWO RELATED ISSUES GOING ON IN THIS AGENDA ITEM. ONE IS PARTICULAR. IT RELATES TO THE MATTER YOU'VE BEEN DISCUSSING CONCERNING THOUGHTS AND INFORMATION THAT HAVE BEEN OFFERED TO YOU BY BOTH THIS PRESSLER AND MR SO HAYEK ABOUT HIS ELDER BUILDING. ALL RIGHT, SO ONE ISSUE IS SPECIFIC TO HIM.

AND THEIR NUMBER OF MOTIONS THAT COULD HAVE BEEN MADE WITH REGARD TO THAT ITEM. THE MOTIONS THAT THAT'S BEEN MADE IS UM. I WOULD SUGGEST YOU PRETTY MILD. I DON'T KNOW THAT, UH, IT'S BEEN SUGGESTED, UH, FROM PUBLIC JUST NOW THAT. TRANSMITTAL OF THAT MEMO. NECESSARILY MAJOR. YOU'RE MAKING A RECOMMENDATION THAT THEY DO A PARTICULAR THING. UM I DIDN'T HEAR THAT PRECISELY IN THE MOTION. BUT FOLKS COULD TAKE THINGS DIFFERENT WAYS. EXACTLY THAT YET AND KEEP AND KEEP THAT IN MIND IT WAS IT WASN'T IN. IT WASN'T IN THE EXACT WORDING IN THE MOTION, BUT FOLKS CAN TAKE THINGS ALL MANNER OF DIFFERENT WAYS. AS YOU HAVE HEARD. THE VILLAGE COUNCIL HAS, IN FACT.

RECEIVED COPIES OF THAT MEMBER OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL DOES IN FACT HAVE A QUESTION BEFORE YOU IS WHETHER OR NOT YOU'RE GOING TO TAKE A FORMAL ACTION TO TRANSMIT IT TO THEM SUCH THAT YOU'RE SAYING WE HAD A VOTE ON THIS? AND WE'RE SENDING IT TO YOU. FOLKS MAY TAKE THAT TO MEAN SOMETHING. JUST KEEP THAT IN MIND, THE OTHER MATTER THAT'S BEFORE YOU ON THIS AGENDA ITEM.

AH IS MORE GENERALLY RELATED TO SOME OF THE OTHER DISCUSSIONS YOU'VE HAD. AND WHAT EVERYONE HAS DISCUSSED THE FACT THAT THE LANGUAGE WITHIN THE L D. R S RIGHT NOW ABOUT QUALIFICATIONS.

COULD USE SOME TUNING UP COULD USE SOME ADDING SOME SPECIFICATION. SO I WOULD SUGGEST YOU THAT WOULD BE AN ITEM YOU TAKE UP. AFTER YOU MAKE A DECISION WITH REGARD TO THIS FIRST ITEM THAT'S BEFORE YOU OKAY, JUST LET ME JUST EXCUSE ME. ONE MINUTE. UM, REMEMBER CHAIR UM, REMEMBER, PERSONALLY, UM, JUST FOR CLARITY. ITEM THREE. HE'S A BOARD MEMBER ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENT. THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD BE TALKING ABOUT, RIGHT. THAT'S WHAT WE TALKED ABOUT. THAT'S WHAT THE DISCUSSION WAS ABOUT. SO NOW WE WERE SUPPOSED TO BE DOING A VOTE. TO DETERMINE. DO WE SEND THIS TO THE COUNCIL? FOR THEM TO SCREEN LAND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS. IN MY CAREER, I WOULD SUGGEST THAT WHAT YOU WOULD DO NEXT, OKAY? BECAUSE YOU HAVE YOU HAVE A YOU HAVE A MOTION. THAT YOU HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR THAT WAS DIRECTED TO A PIECE OF AND THIS CAN GET CONFUSING. SOMETIMES I UNDERSTAND THIS AS I AS I MENTIONED BEFORE THIS ITEM HAS EFFECTIVELY TWO PARTS. SOMETHING DIRECTED TO THE PARTICULAR AND SOMETHING DIRECTED SECOND TO SOMETHING MORE, JIM. I'D SUGGEST AFTER THIS. MOTION AND PORTION OF THIS ITEM IS DISPOSED OF ONE WAY OR ANOTHER APPROVED OR IT'S NOT APPROVED. YOU WOULD GO ON TO THEN HAVE A DISCUSSION MORE GENERALLY TO WHAT SORT OF TUNE UPS TO THE, UH TO THE REQUIREMENTS. WOULD YOU RECOMMEND GENERALLY GOING FORWARD? THE PEACE RIGHT NOW. IS TO HAVE THE LETTER TASK ONE LAST ONE. SENT TO COUNCIL. IT, UM. YES AS A BOARD. YOU'RE DECIDING TO SEND. THE BACKUP FOR THIS ITEM TO THE COUNCIL. OKAY AS A BOARD THE BOARD, OKAY. THEY DO ALREADY HAVE IT DECIDED TONIGHT. IF YOU WANT TO SEND IT. TO THE COUNCIL. AS A BOARD. AND SUGGESTS THAT THEY EVALUATE OKAY , SO THAT WAS WHEN YOU MADE THAT MOTION. THAT'S WHAT THAT WAS THIS ABOUT, RIGHT? WHAT SHE SAID. OKAY AND VICE CHAIR. THAT'S WHAT YOU WERE TAUGHT THIS YOU'RE CLEAR ON THAT. THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT AS WELL, RIGHT? WELL LET ME JUST GET VERIFICATION TO MAKE SURE THAT I'M ON THE RIGHT PAGE. SO, UM, WITH US, SENDING THIS DOCUMENTATION IF WE ALL COME TO THAT AGREEMENT WITH US AND IN THIS INFORMATION TO THE BOARD.

[01:25:04]

[01:30:07]

THAT PART IS PARTICULARLY CLEAR . IN MY OPINION, IT'S THE SECOND PART THAT I HAVE ISSUE WITH. DID IT. WOULD THAT BE CURRENT? YEAH I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE BECAUSE THERE'S TWO PARTS TO IT SO RIGHT TO MAKE SURE THAT PART WAS OKAY. IT'S CLEAR MOST OF YOU FEEL THAT WAY. YES. SECOND PART STATES. SHALL BE THE OWNER OF A BUSINESS LOCATED FOR A MINIMUM OF ONE YEAR WITHIN THE VILLAGE.

DOES THAT LANGUAGE NEED CLARIFICATION? YES, MADAM JARED. AGAIN APPARENTLY NOT. YOU CAN VIRTUALLY HAVE A BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE. IT NEEDS TO BE COMPLETELY CLEAR THAT YOU NEED TO HAVE AN ADDRESS. A PHYSICAL ADDRESS. YOU NEED TO HAVE A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT HANGING ON THE WALL, A CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY. YOU NEED TO RECEIVE YOUR MAIL THERE.

JUST TO HELP BUILD FACILITATE THIS DISCUSSION. ARE THERE ANY OTHER THOUGHTS ON CLARIFICATION . WELL I DON'T HAVE ANY. UM THIS IS THIS IS A GOING FORWARD, RIGHT? YES AND I THINK, UM, MEMBER PRESLEY BRING UP SOME VERY VALID POINTS. UM IF YOU'RE GOING TO IF YOU LIVE IN THERE, YOU NEED TO BE PHYSICALLY LIVING THERE. NOT JUST BOUGHT A PROPERTY AND YOU'RE NOT THERE, ARE YOU? YOU KNOW YOU NEED TO BE PHYSICALLY LIVING THERE. CHAIR MEMBERS OF HOW I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON THE MATTER. GO AHEAD, JUST LIKE TO. I JUST LIKE TO SAY ON THE OWNING A BUSINESS COMPONENT. I THINK THAT THE RECOMMENDATION TO ADD ONE WAY OF HAVING PRESENCE IN THE VILLAGE WITH A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. IS A WONDERFUL ADDITION. BUT THEY'RE DIFFERENT BUSINESSES PAY DIFFERENT TAXES, SO A BARBER DOES NOT PAY REAL ESTATE TAXES. BARBER OPERATES A BUSINESS DOESN'T PAY REAL ESTATE TAXES AND OWNER OF A SHOPPING CENTER OR AN OWNER OF A OF REAL ESTATE IS PAYING THE REAL ESTATE TAXES. THAT THE BARBERS LOCATED IN SO THE REAL ESTATE OWNER. AS A THE

[01:35:02]

I BELIEVE IF I'M QUOTING CORRECTLY THAT SAYS YOU HAVE TO HAVE YOU CANNOT OPERATE A BUSINESS WITH IN MARTIN COUNTY. UNLESS YOU HAVE THAT. SO IF YOU'VE BEEN OPERATING A BUSINESS WITH IN MARTIN COUNTY WITHOUT THAT, I THINK THERE'S SOME ACCRUED FINES. UM I'D LIKE TO ADD SOMETHING THAT WOULD, UM. RESOLVE A LOT OF PROBLEMS THAT WE HAVE WITH TRANSPARENCY.

BEFORE WE VOTE ON THIS. I'D LIKE TO TAKE JUST A MINUTE AND REVIEW OR LOOK BACK AT INDIAN TOWN HISTORY. INDIAN TOWN HAS SPENT OVER 60 YEARS BEING GOVERNED BY SOMEONE WHO DID NOT LIVE HERE.

SOMEONE WHO INHERITED THE UTILITIES. THE LAND THE BANK, THE WATER, THE WASTE MANAGEMENT, YOU NAME IT. AND IT WAS INHERITED FROM FATHER TO SON. RESIDENTS HAD NO SAY. THERE WAS NO HOME RULE. RESIDENTS AND INDIAN TOWN VOTED TO INCORPORATE SO THEY COULD HAVE A SAY SO THEY COULD HAVE HOME RULE. SO RESIDENTS COULD DECIDE. THE DECISION BEFORE US ON MEMBERSHIP ON THIS BOARD. WOULD AS IT IS WRITTEN, ALLOW NON RESIDENTS TO SIT ON THIS SPORT. AND I SAY NO.

BECAUSE WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF SOMEONE WHO LIVES IN SEWELL'S POINT. AH IF YOU LEAVE IT THE WAY IT IS. SOMEONE WHO LIVES IN SEWELL'S POINT COULD HAVE A VOTE ON THIS BOARD. UM. I THINK THAT I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION THAT THE MEMBERSHIP ON THIS BOARD THE LIMITED TO RESIDENTS ONLY. OKAY? WE'RE NOT MAKING THE MOTION RIGHT NOW. OKAY? WERE PAID WHERE SHE'S WRITING EVERYTHING DOWN THAT YOU SAID, AND WE GOT RIGHT. YOU LET ME KNOW WHEN THAT'S APPROPRIATE. YES, MA'AM. UM DIRECTOR. YEAH, ACTUALLY. YEAH, I WAS I WAS JUST GOING TO MENTION THE. CHANGING AROUND THE COMPOSITION. OF THE BOARD. AS OPPOSED. TO ENHANCING OR MODIFYING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE EXISTING COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD. THAT ITEM. THE MOTION. I THINK YOU'RE ABOUT TO MAKE WOULD BE. WOULD BE IN ORDER UNDER ITEM FOR WHICH WE'RE ABOUT TO GET TO THAT GETS TO OTHER ITEMS RELATING TO HOW THE BOARD IS CONSTITUTED. AREN'T WE ON ITEM FOR WE'RE STILL ON ITEM THREE.

WE'RE STILL WE'RE STILL TALKING ABOUT. OKAY I THOUGHT WE HAD MOVED BEFORE WE HAD TWO TESTS FOR ITEM THREE. THIS IS THE SECOND TASK SOUTH, SPECIFICALLY LOOKING AT THE LANGUAGE THAT BOARD MEMBER. SHALL BE THE OWNER OF A BUSINESS LOCATED FOR A MINIMUM OF ONE YEAR WITHIN THE VILLAGE. I HEAR. CHOOSE SEPARATE THOUGHTS. ONE IS. DELETING. THE LANGUAGE THAT I'VE JUST READ TO YOU AND LEAVING. THE MEMBERSHIP AT SHALL RESIDE. HIS SIDE WITH A MINIMUM OF. ONE YEAR RESIDENCY.

DID YOU HAVE PHYSICALLY RESIDE? I MEAN, I DON'T KNOW HOW ELSE WE CAN. WE'RE SEARCHING FOR WAYS TO MAKE THAT CLEAR THAT IT NEEDS TO BE A PHYSICAL THAT YOU ARE PHYSICALLY RESIDE. RECEIVE YOUR MAIL, ACTUALLY WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF THE VILLAGE. HERE'S WHAT I SUGGEST WE CAN OFFER A DEFINITION FOR VILLAGE RESIDENT IN CHAPTER TWO, AND SO WHEN WE USE THAT PHRASE OR VILLAGE BUSINESS OWNER. WE CAN DEFINE BOTH IN CHAPTER TWO, AND WHEN WE USE THAT PHRASE, WE'LL MAKE SURE YOU GUYS AGREE ON THE DEFINITION. THAT IS WHAT WE'LL BE REFERRING TO. WE CAN COME BACK TOON. WHAT ABOUT? UM, I MEAN, YOU KNOW YOU HAVE YOU MAY EVEN HAVE

[01:40:05]

WHAT ABOUT IF YOU ADD A REQUIREMENT LIKE THAT, TO EVEN MAKE IT MORE CLEAR? THAT YOU ARE A RESIDENT WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF THE VILLAGE. AND IT IS THE PLACE WHERE YOU PHYSICALLY RESIDE AND WHERE YOU VOTE. IF I MAY I HAVE MY HAND RAISED IF I MAY SPEAK NO, GO AHEAD. GO AHEAD MEMBERS TO THE HIGH. THANK YOU. UM I JUST WANTED TO JUST SHED SOME LIGHT IN HERE. YOU KNOW THE COUNCILS MADE UP OF RESIDENTS. THE PLANNING AND ZONING HAS FIVE SEATS. THAT OUR RESIDENTS AND THE BUSINESS THE TWO BUSINESS SEATS ARE PEOPLE THAT. ARE A PART OF THE COMMUNITY. SO INSTEAD OF TRYING TO SILENCE A PORTION OF THE COMMUNITY, THIS BOARD SHOULD ALWAYS ALLOW FOR EVERYBODY THAT HAS A VOICE IN THIS COMMUNITY TO HAVE A VOICE. SO IF YOU'RE A BUSINESS PERSON, IF YOU'RE A NON FOR PROFIT IF YOU'RE A LIBRARIAN, BY ALL MEANS, SPEAK AND BE ABLE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD. THERE SHOULDN'T BE. WE SHOULDN'T BE SPENDING OUR TIME TRYING TO PREVENT PEOPLE FROM BEING ON THIS BOARD. IF THERE ARE PART OF THIS COMMUNITY THAT'S JUST MY TWO CENTS. THANK YOU MEMORY SO HIGH, BUT I DON'T THINK THAT'S WHAT SHE WAS SAYING. SHE WOULD.

I WOULD I IF I'M CORRECT ME FROM WRONG. WHAT SHE'S SAYING IS THAT THAT PERSON NEEDS TO LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY AND HAVE A PHYSICAL BUSINESS ADDRESS AND DOING BUSINESS THERE AS WELL AS LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY. AM I CORRECT? YES OKAY. ALRIGHT ANYONE COULD DEFINE THEMSELVES AS BEING A PART OF THE COMMUNITY. THAT'S TOO VAGUE. WE NEED TO BE ABSOLUTELY IRONCLAD, CLEAR THAT YOU ARE PHYSICALLY HAVING ADD BREASTS AND YOU LIVE WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF THE VILLAGE. OKAY, THANK YOU, MEMBER PRESLEY. DIRECTOR JEFFERSON POLICE PROCEED. BEYOND THAT. THERE WERE SOME SUGGESTIONS THAT. THE BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT BE ADDED T, MAILING ADDRESS AND THE LIGHT.

MY RECOMMENDATION AGAIN IS TO PROVIDE A DEFINITION OF. THE VILLAGE BUSINESS AND A VILLAGE RESIDENT IN THE CODE AND DO NOT ADD ALL OF THAT LANGUAGE, TOO. WE ALL OF ELIGIBILITY. I MEAN, WE ALL ABIDE UNDER MARTIN COUNTY ORDINANCE THAT YOU HAVE TO HAVE HAVE THIS WITHOUT IT. YOU CANNOT OPERATE A BUSINESS IN MARTIN COUNTY. SO I DON'T UNDERSTAND. WHY UM, LIKE THIS IS SOMETHING NEW STATE LAW IT TO STATE STATUTE. THERE'S TWO OF THEM MENTIONED, UM AND THEY REFERENCED THIS. OKAY SO I DON'T SEE HOW YOU CAN CLAIM YOU HAVE A BUSINESS IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT WITHIN MARTIN COUNTY, STATING A AND FOR US A PHYSICAL ADDRESS WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF THE VILLAGE. OKAY, SO NOTED. IS THERE. IN HEARING THIS DISCUSSION. IS THERE ANY FURTHER APPETITE FROM OTHER BOARD MEMBERS FOR STAFF TO PUT TOGETHER SOME LANGUAGE ALONG THE FROM DRAFTING PERSPECTIVE? I AGREE WITH OUT THERE THAT WE HAD TO ADD THIS IN SOME DEFINITIONS RATHER THAN COMING UP THAT SENTENCE AS IT IS GETTING INTO THE PARTICULARS OF IT. IS THERE ANY APPETITE FROM OTHER BOARD MEMBERS TO SEE SOME LANGUAGE THAT WOULD IMPLEMENT A REQUIREMENT THAT, UH, TO QUALIFY AS A BUSINESS OWNER FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS? THAT THEY HAVE A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. FOR A PHYSICAL ADDRESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. AGAIN YOU'RE NOT APPROVING THAT AT THAT POINT WHERE MANY STEPS FROM THAT BOOK. BUT IS THERE AN APPETITE TO HAVE LANGUAGE BROUGHT BACK TO YOU TO THAT SAYS THAT TO TAKE A LOOK AT IT. I WOULD SAY YES GOING BACK TO WHEN THE OTHER L D R THAT WE VOTED ON . WHEN I HAD A QUESTION IN REGARDS TO THE IF I WANTED TO HAVE A SALON AT MY HOME, WAS IT REQUIRED FOR ME TO HAVE THE BUSINESS TAX RECEIPTS? IF I HAVE TO HAVE THAT FOR THAT PURPOSE, THEN THAT SHOULD BE CLEARLY DEFINED. IF A PERSON CLAIMING TO HAVE A BUSINESS IN THE WITHIN THE VILLAGE AND WANT TO SIT ON THE BOARD. BUT WE CAN GO AHEAD AND PUT TOGETHER LANGUAGE LINES . JUST OFFER ONE LAST THOUGHT BEFORE YOU ALL MOVE ON TO ITEM FOR, UM WASN'T THE PRIMARY THING WE THOUGHT WE WERE GOING TO

[01:45:05]

THERE'S A LARGE PORTION OF THE COMMUNITY THAT IS SEASONAL THAT DO OWN HOMES THAT DO PAY REAL ESTATE TAXES THAT HAVE RESIDENCY. I MEAN BEYOND MYSELF OR ANYBODY ON THIS BOARD. I STILL DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY WE'RE TRYING TO EXCLUDE THOSE PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY ARE PART OF THE COMMUNITY AND THERE ARE REAL PART OF THE COMMUNITY. A SEASONAL PERSON THAT COMES DOWN HERE FROM NEW YORK OR FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE. THERE ARE NEIGHBORS. WHY ARE WE TRYING TO EXCLUDE THEM FROM BEING ABLE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD AND HAVE A VOICE? I CAN ANSWER THAT QUESTION. UM WHY WOULD YOU ALLOW SOMEONE WHO DOES NOT LIVE HERE? TO MAKE DECISIONS FOR THOSE WHO DO. THANK YOU REMEMBER PRESLEY? THANK YOU. MEMBER SAHA. YAK DIRECTOR JEFFERSON. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU HAVE OUR DIRECTIONS YOURSELF. GOT SOME STUFF TO WORK ON THEM. WE JUST HAVE ONE MORE PUBLIC COMMENTS. PUBLIC COMMENTS, MADAM CHAIR, OKAY? YES, MA'AM, GLADYS. IT'S BEEN QUITE A FEW YEARS. SENSE. THE QUALIFICATIONS FOR PC TO REFERS DISCUSSED AND ONE OF THE REASONS THAT THEY SELECTED OR DECIDED IN THIS WAS THE COUNCIL. THAT MAKES A DECISION, SO EVERYBODY HAS TO BE VETTED THROUGH THE COUNCIL. THEY MAKE DECISIONS. BUT THEY WERE TRYING TO INCLUDE PEOPLE WHO WERE MAKING INVESTMENTS IN THE VILLAGE. NOT TO GUARANTEE THAT THEY HAD A PLACE ON THE BOARD BUT TO GIVE THE COUNCIL MEMBERS AUCTIONS SO THAT IF THEY FELT THERE WAS A NEED THAT THEY COULD APPOINT SOMEBODY. WHO HAD A BUSINESS INTERESTS. IN THE VILLAGE. BUT DID NOT NECESSARILY LIVE HERE. I DON'T I HOPE THAT YOU DON'T FORGET THAT IN THIS DISCUSSION. BECAUSE IT IS THE COUNCIL. THAT DECIDES IN THE VOTE ON AS A GROUP. IT'S NOT ONE PERSON. THE OTHER THING IS I CHECKED WITH A TAX COLLECTOR. ABOUT VIRTUAL BUSINESSES OPERATING IN MARTIN COUNTED AND THEY CAN OPERATE IN MARTIN COUNTY WITHOUT A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT FROM MARTIN COUNTY.

BECAUSE THEY HAVE A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IN ANOTHER COUNTY. THAT THEY DON'T REQUIRE THAT THEY HAVE ANOTHER BUSINESS CAPTURING , SEE IF THERE ARE VIRTUAL BUSINESS. UM AND WE DON'T HAVE ONE YET. IN INDIAN TOWN FROM MY UNDERSTANDING. UM AND I'M A HOME BEATS BUSINESS OR WILL BE AND THERE ARE A LOT OF HOME BASED BUSINESSES. CHRISTOPHER GOT A HOME BASED BUSINESS. SO THAT'S SOMETHING THE VILLAGE IS WORKING ON I UNDERSTAND. SO HAVING THATD MEASURE OF QUALIFICATIONS THAT

[01:50:15]

[4.  

Application No. LDR-22-010 - A request to Amend the Indiantown Land Development Regulations to Revise the Required Number of PZAB Members and to Revise the PZAB Quorum Count.

APPLICATION NUMBER LD R DASH 22 010 A REQUEST TO AMEND THE INDIAN TOWN LAND DEVELOPMENT.

REGULATIONS TO REVISE THE REQUIRED NUMBER OF P C. A B MEMBERS AND TO REVISE THE P G A.

B CORUM COUNT. YES SO PLAIN AND SIMPLE. STAFF WON'T GO THROUGH THE. THE POWER POINT ON THIS ONE. YOU KNOW THE PROCESS. YOU KNOW WHAT WE'RE DOING THAT ESSENTIALLY THE QUANTUM NUMBER WILL BE THE LAST PART OF THIS DISCUSSION BECAUSE YOU FIRST NEED TO DETERMINE THE MAKEUP OF THE BOARD, THE NUMBER OF MEMBERS AND OKAY, THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE FORUM. YOUR PLEASURE WILL TAKE ANY QUESTIONS. IF THERE ARE ANY AND YET, LET ME JUST GO AHEAD AND STATE FIRST STAFF HAS THERE'S NO STAFF RECOMMENDATION WITH REGARD TO THIS ITEM HERE. THIS DRAFT ORDINANCE BEFORE YOU IS A TOOL FOR MARKING UP, OKAY, WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE BEFORE YOU IS LANGUAGE THAT'S BEEN HIGHLIGHTED. IT'S SHOWING THE LANGUAGE IF IT WERE THE DESIRED TO TWEAK AROUND NUMBER OF MEMBERS, BUT IGNORE THE STRIKETHROUGH AND UNDERLYING THEIR FOCUS ON THE HIGHLIGHTED PORTIONS. THAT'S THAT'S WHAT'S BEFORE YOU. THERE HAS BEEN DISCUSSIONS PERIPHERAL TO THE IDEA AND MORE DIRECTLY TO THE IDEA OF MAKING CHANGES TO THE ACTUAL COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD AND MAKING RECOMMENDATIONS ON THAT IT'S WITHIN YOUR PURVIEW TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS BECAUSE RECOMMENDATION TO CHANGE THE LD OURS. UM AND SO LOOKING AT THAT. THIS WOULD BE THE TIME TO DISCUSS WHETHER IT BE YOUR RECOMMENDATION TO. DO ANY MANNER OF THINGS, INCLUDING GOING TO FIVE MEMBERS THAT ARE JUST RESIDENTS OR WHAT HAVE YOU AS OUR AS JEFFERSON INDICATED WITH WHATEVER RECOMMENDATION YOU MAKE THAT WOULD INVOLVE A TWEAK TO THE QUORUM REQUIREMENTS, ONE WHERE THE OTHER TWO CLEAN THAT UP, BUT THAT'S SECONDARY TO THE REST OF THIS. THIS IS I BELIEVE

[01:55:05]

ESPECIALLY WITH THE IMPENDING GROWTH THEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IT JUST DOESN'T COMPUTE FOR ME.

WELL, I'D LIKE TO SAY ALSO THAT I THINK SEVEN IS MUCH STRONGER THAN FIVE BECAUSE FIVE TAKES FEWER MEMBERS TO CONSTITUTE A QUORUM. AND EVEN FEWER VOTES TO MAKE A DECISION. FEWER PEOPLE IS FEWER HEADS ON THE ISSUES AND FEWER VOICES. IT MAKES THE BOARD WEAKER. WHAT HAPPENS WHEN ONE MEMBER HAS TO RECUSE? I THINK, ACCORDING TO A CHART, I LOOKED UP THE QUORUM WOULD THEN BE THREE. UM AND THE OTHER THING THAT THIS IS A LITTLE OUTSIDE OF JUST THE NUMBER. BUT WHAT ABOUT LANGUAGE FOR THE APPLICATION? WHERE WOULD THAT BE? YOU KNOW, LANGUAGE. CONCERNING. FILLING OUT AN APPLICATION TO BE ON THIS SPORT. REMEMBER PERSONALLY, THAT'S JUST STICK WITH THIS.

THIS IS HOW WE GET CONFUSED. LET'S JUST STICK WITH, UM COMMENTS ABOUT THE SEVEN OR FIVE MILLION SO THAT I DON'T KNOW. ARE YOU READY FOR A MOTION? NO WE'RE NOT MAKING THE MOTION EVERYBODY GOING TO HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY DISPLAY AND THEN WE'LL GO FROM THERE. STAY WITH THE NUMBER SEVEN, OKAY? ALL RIGHT. OKAY, SO I WOULD SAY THAT I WOULD ALSO BE IN FAVOR OF KEEPING OUR CURRENT NUMBER AT SEVEN. WE'RE FIVE OF THOSE MEMBERS AS IT CURRENTLY STANDS FIVE OF THOSE MEMBERS BEING OF THE COMMUNITY AND THEN THE OTHER TWO BEING TO BUSINESS PEOPLE, YOU KNOW. THAT SUPPORTS OR WITHIN THE VILLAGE. OKAY? ALL RIGHT. UM UH, REMEMBER, REMEMBER SIDE REMEMBER SO HIGH ALREADY HERE, MISTURA, I DO APOLOGIZE EVERY TIME I INTERRUPT, JO JUST TRYING IT BECAUSE I'M ON ZOOM. UM I'LL WOULD ALSO SUPPORT THE, UM SEVEN AND AGAIN. I JUST WANT TO REPEAT IT. YOU KNOW, EVERYBODY DESERVES A VOICE AND IT'S NICE TO SEE THAT THERE IS A YOU KNOW AGREEMENT ON THAT ACROSS THE BOARD. SO IT'S YOU KNOW, AT LEAST SEEMS TO BE SO THAT'S THAT'S MY TWO CENTS. THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY IS A PART OF THE COMMUNITY, JUST LIKE THE RESIDENTS ARE AND IT'S YOU KNOW, DIVORCE, THE MORE VOICES, THE MORE DEMOCRATIC PROCESSES AND IT'S A POSITIVE THING. THANK YOU MEMBERS OF HIGH. ARE THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS ON IT? YES, I HAVE MISS BARBARA CLAUDIUS. OKAY, THEN I HAVE NO FURTHER. OKAY? BUT I WOULD LIKE TO SAY, UM. AGREE THAT THE, UM THE SEVEN MEMBERS MAKE US STRONGER AND BUT I DON'T. I DON'T WANT TO. I DON'T THINK THAT WE SHOULD JUST SAY, UM FUN. FIVE RESIDENTS TO BUSINESS PEOPLE. WHAT IF WE CAN'T FIND TWO BUSINESS PEOPLE THAT WOULD CONSTANTLY HAVE TO RECUSE THEMSELVES? I MEAN, I DON'T KNOW. UM, DIRECTLY JEFFERSON AND ATTORNEY OF OURS. IS THAT SOMETHING? IS THAT THE LANGUAGE OF THE COUNCIL? SO YES , THE LANGUAGE CURRENTLY ADDRESSES THAT IT SAYS THERE ARE SEVEN MEMBERS, OKAY? AND THEN IT PUTS A CAP ON THE NUMBER OF FOLKS WHO CAN BE NONRESIDENT BUSINESS OWNER MEMBERS. OKAY, THE COUNCIL IN APPOINTING FOLKS COULD MAKE ALL SEVEN OF THE ALL SEVEN OF THE PCB BOARD MEMBERS, RESIDENTS. RESIDENTS OKAY. AND NONE OF THE MONA BUSINESS ALRIGHT THE AND THAT WAS THIS WAS DISCUSSED A LOT. ALL RIGHT, AND IT WAS THIS DYNAMIC WAS AFTER A LOT OF DIFFERENT THINGS. BOUNCING GROUND WAS PRECISELY WHAT THEY LANDED ON. THE IDEA THAT IT'S SEVEN MEMBERS WITH A CAMP OF UP TO TWO. WHICH COULD MEAN 21 OR ZERO UP TO TWO NON

[02:00:10]

WELL, I THINK IT'S JUST I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ALL LOOK CLEAR. I WAS THINKING THAT IF WE REMAINED AT SEVEN BUT WE WILL IF WE HAVE BUSINESS. OWNERS ON THE BOARD THAT THEY WILL COME FROM INDIAN TOWN. THAT'S WHAT I WAS THINKING. SO AND LETS YOU MEAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE A BUSINESS OWNER, AND THEY NOT ONLY OWN A BUSINESS AND IN IN INDIAN TOWN, BUT ALSO ALSO RESIDE IN INDIAN TOWN. THAT'S MY THOUGHTS. YES. IT'S JUST MY THOUGHT. I DON'T KNOW. DO ANYONE ELSE SHADOWS

[02:05:01]

NOW IT SAYS YOU HAVE TO BE THE OWNER OF A BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE. AND WE HAVEN'T SEEMED TO. I MEAN, THAT IS LIKE CLEAR. STAY TO ME. UM IT ZOOM OR OUT OF YOUR CAR DOES NOT QUALIFY. YOU HAVE TO HAVE A PHYSICAL ADDRESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE. OKAY, UM ANYWAY, YOU'RE SAYING SEVEN RESIDENTS, REGARDLESS OF WHETHER THEY OWN A BUSINESS OR NOT CORRECT. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT MY MOTION WAS SEVEN RESIDENTS AND YOU JUST YOU KNOW, YOU DON'T HAVE TO SAY TO HAVE TO OWN A BUSINESS BECAUSE A LOT OF THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE BUSINESSES HERE OUR LANDSCAPING OR EVENT.

PLANNERS OR THINGS THAT ARE SUPER. THEY JUST PHYSICALLY DON'T HAVE THE TIME TO SERVE, AND IT'S BEEN HARD TO GET SEVEN. MR CHAIR IF I MAY GO AHEAD. THE, UH. THERE ARE SEVEN SEATS ON THIS BOARD. FIVE ARE RESIDENTS THAT YOU RIGHT? SO THEY'RE THE TWO APPOINTMENT OF THE OF THE BUSINESS SEATS. YOU HAVE TO OWN A BUSINESS, SO THERE ARE BUSINESSES WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN. THAT, UM. YOU KNOW THAT ARE NOT RESIDENTS, SO THE RESIDENTS WILL ALWAYS BE HEARD.

AND THERE THEY ARE. THE MAJORITY . THERE ARE FIVE SEATS OF RESIDENTS, FOR INSTANCE, YOU KNOW, THERE ARE THERE ARE RESTAURANT CHAINS. THAT YOU KNOW, THE OWNER MAY LIVE. IN A IN ANOTHER STATE, BUT THEY HAVE A BUSINESS HERE OR THEY LIVE SOMEWHERE ELSE. SO MAYBE THEY LIVE 20 MINUTES AWAY. MAYBE THEY LIVE, BUT THEY DO HAVE A BUSINESS HERE. THEY'RE EMPLOYING PEOPLE. THEY'RE PAYING PEOPLE SALARIES. THEY'RE PROVIDING INCOMES FOR FAMILIES TO PAY RENT TO PURCHASE A HOME AND THOSE, ONLY THOSE TWO SEATS ARE THE TWO SEATS THAT ALLOW SOMEBODY THAT IS JUST A BUSINESS OWNER TO HAVE A VOICE ON THIS BOARD. SO THE RESIDENTS WILL ALWAYS HAVE A VOICE AND A MAJORITY IN THE FIVE SEATS. THE TWO SEATS FOR THE BUSINESS OWNERS IS PURELY FOR ITS, UM, I IT IS A MINORITY OUT OF THE SEVEN, BUT IT RESERVES SOME SORT OF VOICE. FOR THOSE PEOPLE THAT DON'T LIVE HERE IN A RESIDENT SENSE, BUT YOU KNOW, ARE VERY THEIR DAY TO DAY. IT'S PROBABLY YOU KNOW, FOCUSING ON TRYING TO RUN A GOOD BUSINESS WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIA ATTEMPT, SO I WOULD I WOULD URGE EVERYBODY TO INCLUDE EVERYBODY'S VOICE. THERE'S ONLY TWO SEATS FOR THE BUSINESS OWNERS IN SOME MINORITY, BUT AGAIN, WE SHOULDN'T BE SILENCING. NOBODY'S TRYING TO SILENCE MR ANITA FROM SPEAKING ON THIS BOARD. OR OR ANYBODY ELSE ON THIS BOARD. UM I DIDN'T MEAN A SINGLE MR ANITA OUT, BUT YOU KNOW IF ALL VOICES ARE ALLOWED TO BE PRESENT, YOU CAN HAVE AGREEMENTS DISAGREEMENTS. YOU VOTE ON THINGS. AND IT GIVES EVERYBODY A CHANCE TO BE HURT. THANK YOU, MR. SAY IT. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. SMILING SO I'M GOING TO HAVE TO SAY THAT I DISAGREE WITH YOU GUYS NOTION THAT ALL SEVEN SEATS SHOULD BE FOR RESIDENTS AND THE REASON WHY I DISAGREE IS BECAUSE IF I WAS NOT A RESIDENT OF INDIAN TIME, BUT I WAS A RIGHTFUL BUSINESS OWNER WITHIN THE VILLAGE OF INDIAN TOWN, AND IF I WAS ELECTED OR SELECTED BY SOMEONE WHO SITS ON THE COUNCIL TO REPRESENT THE BIT BUSINESS ENTITY OF THE VILLAGE. I WOULD WANT TO RIGHTFULLY DO SO. I SHOULDN'T HAVE TO LIVE HERE IF I HAVE A VESTED INTERESTS IN THE COMMUNITY. RALLY POINT. OKAY, SO AT THIS POINT, WE CAN MAKE IT. I'M SORRY, MR CHAIR. I DO, BOY.

GO AHEAD AND I JUST WANT TO. I DID WANT TO SAY THAT THE PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONS OF HAVING A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. IT'S NOT A IT IS A GOOD ADDITION TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE IS A PRESENCE WITHIN THE VILLAGE. SO INSTEAD OF GETTING RID OF THE BUSINESS PEOPLE FURTHER DEFINE WHAT IT

[02:10:06]

THANK YOU, MR. OKAY. THANK YOU. BALLOT POINT. SORT OF FALLS. WE HAVE. WHY ARE YOU DRESSED HER? YOU SHOULD BE ADDRESSING ME. SHE WAS JUST TELLING THE CLERK WHO'S AND MAKE A PUBLIC HOME. THE ROOMS. COME UP, OKAY. AND THEN I HAD ONE MORE AFTER HER. ONE MORE OKAY? THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY. YES. YES, FATHER. THIS. SOMETIMES WE FORGET. THAT HOW NEW WE ARE BUT. IT'S THE INVESTMENT THAT WE NEEDED AN INDIAN TOWN FOR SO MANY YEARS. AND BUSINESS OWNERS ARE THE ONES WHO PROVIDED JOBS. AND AFFECT SO MANY RESIDENTS WITH THEIR LIVELIHOODS. SO THAT'S WHY THE COUNCIL MEMBERS WANTED TO INCLUDE NON RESIDENTS BECAUSE WE HAVE BUSINESSES. SO MANY BUSINESSES. THANK GOODNESS. WHO WANT TO INVEST THEIR MILLIONS BECAUSE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN INDIAN TOWN. AND ALL YOU'RE DOING IS GIVING THE COUNCIL OPTIONS. SO THAT THEY CAN SELECT WHO MAKE FEEL MEETS THE NEEDS THAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR. BY ELIMINATING IT, MAKING IT MORE STRAIGHT. THEN YOU'RE ELIMINATING SOME OF THOSE OPTIONS THAT YOUR COUNCIL HAS AND SELECTING FEEL. IS NEEDED TO BALANCE THE INTERESTS. OF INDIAN TOWN. THAT'S BASICALLY THE ONLY REASON THAT THEY. DECIDED ON NONRESIDENT BUSINESS CENTER. I DO THINK. THAT. WE DON'T ADVERTISE ENOUGH. AND THAT'S WHY WE DON'T GET APPLICATIONS TO THE COUNCIL, OR LETTERS OF INTEREST TO THE COUNCIL TO SERVE THEM PC. A BOARD. I MEAN, I'VE I'VE NEVER SEEN IT IN THE VILLAGE NEWSLETTER, FOR INSTANCE. AND I THINK IT WOULD BE IMPORTANT TO MAKE IT IMPORTANT. IN THE NEWSLETTER THAT. THERE'S A VACANCY AND THEY'RE SEEKING LETTERS OF INTEREST. TWO. THE VILLAGE MANAGER. OR TO WHOMEVER WOULD BE COLLECTING.

APPLICATIONS TO SIT ON THESE BOARDS BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE AREN'T EVEN AWARE. OF WHAT YOU'RE DOING, AND IT'S ANOTHER WAY OF LETTING PEOPLE KNOW THIS IS A VITALLY IMPORTANT BOARD.

AND I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU DO, AND I APPRECIATE YOUR DISCUSSIONS, AND IT'S MORE WORK THAN PEOPLE REALIZE, TOO. SO I WANT YOU TO KNOW I APPRECIATE YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MA'AM. APPRECIATE YOU. KEVIN POWERS. GOOD EVENING, AND THANKS AGAIN. MY INTENT HERE IS ONLY TO HELP YOU MAKE THE VERY BEST DECISION YOU CAN AND THINGS COME TO MIND THAT I JUST FEEL COMPELLED TO SHARE WITH YOU. AND WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT YOU KNOW, A RESIDENT WITHIN THE VILLAGE THAT DOESN'T MEAN AN ISLAND AND EVERYTHING ELSE IS AN OCEAN, RIGHT? THAT'S A IT'S A IT'S A LINE. IT'S A ROAD. IT'S A BOUNDARY THAT DEFINES INDIAN TOWN. THERE'S A LOT OF FOLKS THAT HAVE BUSINESSES THAT ARE IN INDIAN TOWN, BUT THEY'RE RIGHT ACROSS THAT LINE AND THE THOUGHT RIGHT WHETHER IT'S SOMEBODY IN SAINT LUCIE MOBILE VILLAGE SPRING HAVEN. CLEMENTS VILLE THAT YOU WOULD SUGGEST THEY'RE NOT A RESIDENT OF INDIAN TOWN STRIKES A CHORD WITH A LOT OF THEM. ONE THAT COMES TO MIND IS P O. BOX NUMBER ONE. TECHNICALLY IS NOT A RESIDENT. BUT THEIR FAMILY HAVE BEEN HERE LONGER THAN ANYBODY I KNOW. AND JUST SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT, UH, WHEN? WHEN YOU CONTEMPLATE WHAT IS AND WHAT ISN'T A RESIDENT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY MORE CALM. PUBLIC COMMENTS. THAT'S ALL I HAVE. MADAM CHAIR, OKAY? CAN I JUST THIS FOR A SECOND? DANIEL BROUGHT UP A VERY GOOD POINT WHEN HE WAS TALKING ABOUT KEEPING THOSE BUSINESS. FIVE MEMBERS CARRIES A WEIGHT AND I REMEMBER WHEN. WE INCORPORATED THE CONVERSATION WAS THE BUSINESSMAN. THAT WERE ASKED. TO BE ON THE BOARD WAS TO ASSIST

[02:15:03]

WITH THE LANGUAGE BEING THAT THE COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD IS MAINTAINED, BUT THE QUORUM IS SET TO FOUR. OKAY? AND DECLARE IT TO SIMPLIFY THINGS. SOMEONE CAN SAY SO. MOVED. SOME MOVED.

THAT WE NEED A SECOND. SOME OAT , I'LL SECOND READY FOR THE VOTE. IT'S MANAGER BOARD MEMBER BANKS. YES, REMEMBER PRESSLER? NO. FOR MEMBERS OF HAYEK. YES. BOARD MEMBER WILLIAMS. YES CHAIR. MILEY YES. SARAH PALMER? YES. OKAY? IT SEEMS WE HAVE COME TO THE END. DIRECTOR DO HAVE THE DIRECTORS REPORTED BEFORE I GET INTO THAT YOU DO HAVE A MEMBER. THAT'S. TO BE RECOGNIZED. I'M SORRY. GO AHEAD. REMEMBER PRESIDENT? YES I'D LIKE TO. UM SINCE THIS WHOLE ISSUE HAS BROUGHT TO LIGHT HAVING SOMEONE WHO HAS IS INVOLVED IN COMMERCIAL REALTY AND NUMEROUS PROPERTIES IN THE FUTURE, THIS SOMETHING SIMILAR OR MAYBE NOT TO THIS DEGREE BUT COULD BE HAPPENING AGAIN. AND I THINK IT WOULD BE WISE IF WE WOULD LOOK AT, UH WHAT CAN BE DONE FOR DISCLOSURE? IN OTHER WORDS, MOST OF US HAVE OUR HOMEOWNERS. WE HAVE A HOME AND THAT'S IT, BUT YOU MAY HAVE PEOPLE COMING ON THIS BOARD WHO HAVE NUMEROUS PROPERTIES AND UP UNTIL NOW WE HAVE TRUSTED THEM AND TAKING THEM AT THEIR WORD AS TO HOW MANY PROPERTIES ARE INVOLVED IN YOU KNOW, UM AND I THINK MORE IS NEEDED. YOU KNOW, DO WE NEED TO VISIT THIS ANNUALLY MONTHLY? IMMEDIATELY YOU KNOW WHEN SOMEONE ACQUIRES PROPERTY, OR, YOU KNOW IS GOING TO GET A COMMISSION OR SOMETHING ON PROPERTY THAT THEY DISCLOSE IT IMMEDIATELY. UM AND THAT YOU KNOW WHEN YOU HAVE SOMEONE WHO HAS A LOT OF PROPERTIES THAT WE HAVE A MAP THAT THEY SUBMIT A MAP TO US BOARD MEMBERS OF WHERE THOSE PROPERTIES ARE, SO WE'RE AWARE OF WHAT IS ADJACENT TO SOMETHING ELSE THAT WE'RE ABOUT TO VOTE ON. WE DON'T KNOW UNLESS YOU HAVE PAPER AT THAT MEETING THAT SHOWS LOOK HERE. I OWN ALL THESE LOTS OR I'M A PARTNER IN THESE LOTS OR WHATEVER IT IS, BUT YOU NEED SOMETHING. NOT THAT YOU KNOW. IN OTHER WORDS, IT'S NOT FAIR TO SAY WE'RE GOING TO JUST TAKE THEIR THAT PERSON AT THEIR WORD TO SAY THAT THEY'RE GOING TO RECUSE WHEN THEY ARE AWARE. OF A CONFLICT OF INTEREST . OKAY THAT NEEDS TO BE BEEFED UP. UH, MUCH MORE STRONGLY AND THE VILLAGE ATTORNEY DOESN'T HAVE TIME TO GO LOOK INTO WHAT PROPERTIES ANYONE ON THE BOARD WHO'S VOTING WHAT THEY OWN, YOUR SIMPLY TAKING THEIR WORD FOR IT, WHICH I FEEL IS UNFAIR. OKAY THANK YOU. MEMBER. PRESSLER UM, ATTORNEY VAULT STAFF IS NOTED. OKAY BUT I JUST WANT TO SAY, UM,

[02:20:08]

[02:25:02]

THAT'S THAT'S PART OF THE VOTING CONFLICTS, TOO. PREEMPTIVELY SATISFY FELLOW MEMBERS OF A GIVEN BOARD. I DON'T HAVE A CONFLICT, IT'S INCUMBENT UPON THEM TO RECOGNIZE WHETHER THEY HAVE A CONFLICT AND RECUSE THEMSELVES. AT THE RISK OF SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES IF THEY DON'T ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MEMBERS OF HIGH END ARE YOU? DO YOU WANT TO ADDRESS? UM MEMBER OF PRESLEY'S COMMENT OUR WORK BECAUSE WE WANT TO MOVE ON. IF WE DON'T JUST WANTED TO QUICKLY ADD ONTO HER COMMENT THAT THERE THERE IS A REPORTING REQUIREMENT. THERE IS A FORM THAT THE VILLAGE PROVIDES US TO DISCLOSE ANY INTERESTS THAT WE HAVE. AND IT'S A STATE FORM IF I'M CORRECT AND EVERY PERSON ON THE BOARD, INCLUDING MYSELF, SHOULD FILL THAT OUT. AND, YOU KNOW, REPORT TO IT WHEN I SO I JUST WANTED TO ADD TO HER COMMENT THAT THERE IS YOU DO DISCLOSE WHAT YOU HAVE TO THE VILLAGE UNDER THEIR REPORTING REQUIREMENTS, OKAY? ALL RIGHT.

[10.  

March 2022 Director's Report

ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS? SO THAT'S IT. THANK YOU, EVERYONE FOR ATTENDING THE FIELD TRIP THAT THOSE OF YOU THAT COULD MAKE IT. WE LOOK FORWARD TO FUTURE TRAININGS WORKSHOPS AND MORE FILLED TRIPS AND WE'LL BE IN TOUCH WITH THOSE DATES AND LOCATIONS. OKAY? SO THAT CONCLUDES ALBUM, UM TURNING BALLS BECOME THERE. I HAVE NOTHING. OKAY VERY MUCH, SO, THANK YOU. EVERYBODY THANK YOU, MEMBER SO HIGH THAT CONCLUDES OUR MEETING. LP, XABI, MEANING THANK YOU ALL HAVE A SAFE NIGHT. AND A GREAT WEEKEND. THINK THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. YOU'RE WELCOME.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.